Author's Note: I thought I'd try a different sort of story, using fictitious letters, and a fictitious sex advice columnist. The letters are obviously much longer than would ever be used in a column of this nature, but I felt the added length was needed to tell the stories. All characters involved are over the age of eighteen.
Ms. Eva Amore has been offering her many readers and fans the naughtiest most scintillating sex advice in her syndicated "Ask Eva Amore" column for over a decade. Formerly a professor of human sexuality at a prestigious university, Ms. Amore uses her extensive knowledge and experience regarding sex to craft poignant, yet humorous responses to her audiences' inquiries. All questions, comments, and stories may be directed to askevamore69@sexpress.com.
Dear Eva Adore,
My fiance "Melanie" is bisexual, and before meeting me, she was convinced that she would end up with a woman. She'd been fucked over by a lot of men in her past, and had basically lost faith in the gender before meeting me.
We have a great, very active sex life, and until recently Melanie had never mentioned missing the company of a woman in bed. However, she'd been hanging out with her friend "Kimmy" who's bisexual, and involved in the kink community, and hearing of Kimmy's escapades made her simultaneously aroused and jealous.
In particular Melanie missed being with multiple partners, so she proposed the idea of having a threesome. She'd had multiple threesomes before we'd begun dating, but I was a three-way virgin. And while I'd of course fantasized about it, when actually presented with the idea it sounded more scary than arousing. However, it also struck me as something I shouldn't pass up, so I agreed to one if the circumstances were right.
Melanie took this as an open invitation, and no more than a month after discussing the idea of having a threesome, asked me if I was still serious about it. She explained that there was a woman in her yoga class named "Brandy" she'd been flirting with, and would be interested in joining us. Unbeknownst to me, Melanie had even shown Brandy pictures of me, including one of me standing in the shower with a full-on erection.
Before I could get too angry about this invasion of my privacy, Melanie informed me that her friend thought I had "a great body, and a really nice dick". She then asked if I'd like to see a picture of Brandy, and pulled up a picture on her phone that made me instantly hard. On the screen was a photo of a thick, pale brunette, wearing nothing but stockings, performing fellatio on a large, black dildo. The picture was taken in a full length mirror, and showed Brandy on all fours servicing the dido in a doggystyle position. "That could be your dick," Melanie said coyly.
Two days later Brandy came over to our house, not so coincidentally gifting us a bottle of brandy. The chemistry between the three of us was palpable right off the bat, and after a few drinks we made our way to the bedroom.
Brandy had been dressed fairly conservatively, so when she disrobed I was surprised to see her in an extremely sexy, open mesh bodysuit get-up that left nothing to the imagination. Melanie never wore fancy lingerie like that, but she looked pretty hot herself topless in nothing but a skimpy, white thong.
I was a little dumbstruck, and not really sure where to begin, so Melanie took charge by playfully pushing me onto the bed, and ordering me to take my shirt off. The girls then took their place on either side of me, and Melanie kissed me while Brandy ran her hands over my chest, even sucking my nipple a little bit.
Then Melanie started fidgeting with the zipper of my jeans, and taking the hint, Brandy helped slide off both my jeans and briefs. "Wow, you're a lucky woman," she remarked to Melanie upon seeing my large endowment.
Melanie continued kissing me, while also starting to stroke my penis. We were still learning each other's boundaries, and Brandy asked if it was okay if she played with my balls, and Melanie made it very clear she could do anything she liked to me.
So not only did Brandy squeeze and tickle my balls, but she gave them little butterfly kisses, and sucked them sweetly. Getting aroused by the sights and sounds of another woman orally pleasuring me, Melanie soon joined.
Teasing me for as long as I could handle, the ladies french kissed each other right in front of my penis, occasionally showering it with little kisses and licks, letting their tongues swirl around the head with the delicacy of a figure skater twirling on virgin ice. Then Brandy finally took the entire length of my penis in her mouth, while Melanie sucked my balls.
They continued to perform oral sex on me for what felt like an eternity, while I nearly passed out from ecstasy. Believe me dear readers, a double blowjob feels even better than it looks, and nothing can make a man feel more powerful.
The rest of the night was a dream. Both girls sucked me generously whenever I so much as put my penis anywhere near their mouths, as well as bringing each other to orgasm with their oral skills. I even got to taste Brandy, licking her out from behind with her big ass in my face, while she was going down on my fiance. I did this until her juices were dripping all over my mouth, and then finally mounted her from behind.
Melanie is a petite girl, so the opportunity to be with a thick, curvy girl like Brandy was a dream come true. Watching her ass ripple as I pounded it brought me too much pleasure so I had to pull out after less than a minute of making love to her to keep from cumming.
It wasn't until a little later in the night, after having made love to both girls, that I came inside of Brandy while Melanie was riding my face. The girls then sixty-nined, bringing each other to a final orgasm while I watched.
Due to the late hour and alcohol in our systems, we invited Brandy to spend the night. I slept between both lovely ladies in our California king bed, and had no trouble falling asleep.
Then at some point in the night I woke up, with my erect penis pressed firmly against Brandy's large, bare ass. Heat was radiating off it, seemingly sending me an invitation. I started running my free hand over her ass, and down her crack, taking a second to tickle her pussy. Then in her semi-catatonic state, Brandy reached behind and started fondling my penis, playfully but lovingly. I returned the favor by rubbing her clit, feeling her wetness drip down my fingers.
I pressed my penis against her pussy, hoping she'd let me inside her, but she wanted to lubricate me first. Quietly sliding under the sheets, she wrapped her lips around my penis, and treated me to maybe a minute of passionate, gentle sucking.
Then with both of us nice and wet, I slid inside her. In the moment my mind was overcome with arousal and sleepiness, so I failed to consider that this wasn't within the parameters Melanie and I had set before engaging in a threesome. We'd both made it very clear that we wanted each other to be involved every step of the way.
After a few pumps, when it did dawn on me exactly what I was doing, I started moaning a little, hoping it might wake Melanie up. But Brandy put her hand over my mouth, and Melanie sleeps like a log anyway, so she didn't wake up.
The whole encounter didn't last long, five minutes tops, before we simultaneously orgasmed, her body convulsing on my cock, as I came inside her uncontrollably. She then slipped away to the bathroom, while I fell right back asleep, and that was that. Neither of us mentioned it the next morning, and Brandy left bright and early.
Melanie and I are usually very honest with each other, but I still haven't mentioned this encounter. I genuinely have no idea how she'd react, and am not sure it's worth the risk of telling her. She can be the jealous type. Any advice would be greatly appreciated. Is it best to just keep this little secret, or should I open up? If I do tell my fiance what happened, how do you suggest I go about it?
- To Tell or Not to Tell
Dear To Tell or Not to Tell,
Okay, so first you should know that many guys that write me have real problems. Things like not being able to get laid, being insecure about their penis, or not being able to satisfy their woman.
So let's start by putting this in perspective. You have a bisexual fiance that thinks you should be having more threesomes, you have a big dick, you recently had two women playing with your big dick, and you got a hot piece of new ass after presumably thinking you'd only be getting some from the same woman for the rest of your life.
Now the bad news. Relationships, including open relationships, are built on trust. It sounds like the two of you set boundaries before your threesome, which is a great first step, but it sounds like these boundaries may have been unclear. If your fiance thinks you knowingly violated these boundaries, that doesn't bode well for her trusting you in the future, let alone letting any more hot yoga babes go down on you.
Not once did you mention how your fiance felt about the threesome. It sounds like she got off a few times, so that's great, but overall did she enjoy the experience? Did it make her at all jealous? Did it make her miss having a woman as a sexual partner? Are threesomes something she'd like to continue exploring? Before doing anything else you should get the answers to these questions, if you haven't done so already.
Check the vibe from there. If she's expressing a lot of regrets about the threesome, figure out why, and drop the topic for the time being. If she enjoyed it as much as you seemingly did, ask what she enjoyed most. If she doesn't bring it up, mention how much you enjoyed watching her with another woman, especially when they sixty-nined with you as a spectator. Then tell her how much it turned you on to see the way she looked at you, and held you as your dick was being caressed by another woman's lips. Chances are if she enjoyed the threesome, she enjoyed seeing you getting pleasured by another woman.
After it's been established that you both enjoyed the experience, tell her what happened while she was asleep. There's no need to lie, but there's also no need to be detailed. Tell her that while you were half-asleep, Brandy started pleasuring you. Tell your finance you were hoping she'd wake up organically, but you came before this could happen. She may not take this well, but then again, maybe it will turn her on. Either way, use the discussion to clarify or re-calibrate your sexual parameters. If she's upset, perhaps you offer her the chance to spend a night with Brandy, or another woman to make it even. Give her the option of letting you watch or not.
However, the thing that concerns me most about your letter isn't your lack of being forthright; I'm more concerned that in your description of the threesome, you hardly mention feeling aroused by anything your fiance did. I understand that it's exciting to get a new piece of ass, but don't let it affect your desire to get married. Your fiance and you can have a life of fulfilling sexual experiences so long as you're honest with each other, and communicate clearly.