A few weeks later we were lounging around the house after dinner. Julie was texting on her phone, when she suddenly spoke up.
"Get ready; we're going out."
I knew the routine: shower, shave everything, and put on loose clothing. When I came out, Julie had left two blue pills on the kitchen counter. I swallowed them immediately.
"Grab that bag," Julie said.
I pulled a duffel bag out of the closet and hopped in the car. Eventually we pulled into a quiet neighborhood on the other side of town. After a few more turns, Julie stopped along the curb behind some other cars.
"It looks like this is as close as we can get," she said. "Put these on."
She handed me a collar, gag, and handcuffs. I stripped, as I knew I was supposed to do, and hesitantly stepped out of the car. It was dark, and the street was not well lit, but anyone looking out their window would not mistake a naked guy. Still, I was on the passenger side of the car, which afforded some cover from the street. Hunched over I put the collar on first, then the gag, and finally closed one cuff on my right wrist. Julie grabbed the bag and came around to my side of the car just as I brought my hands behind my back and close the other cuff on my left wrist. She clipped a leash to my collar and without a word turned and strode off down the street, me in tow. The house three down had a full driveway and I realized that is probably where we were going, which meant I had to walk that far through a nice neighborhood completely naked with a full erection, unable to cover myself. Despite having gone to events like this several times before, I felt like I had never been more humiliated. As we approached the house the front porch lights were on and I realized that I no longer had the cover of darkness to hide my shame. Julie rang the doorbell then turned to me.
"I haven't looked at you yet." She peered over my naked body, searching for missed grooming.
"Turn," she instructed, and I turned around to face the street, knowing it was my job to present myself for inspection, even if it meant exposing myself to the entire neighborhood on the well illuminated porch. After what felt like an hour (but was probably only a few seconds) the door to the house opened in the girl called out.
"Get in here!"
Julie and I stepped into the house.
"Do you want to get me in trouble with the neighbors?" She was clearly talking to me. "That's not nice."
Then she smiled and landed a hard smack on my ass as I was passing her through the doorway.
"Go on in; everyone's in the living room."
As we entered the living room everyone started cheering. About a dozen girls were hanging out. I recognized maybe half of them from previous parties. Julie handed the bags to a nearby girl, who immediately open them and started pawing through the toys. Several other girls jumped up and pushed over to the bags. Julie brought me to the center of the room, undid my leash, and stuck her foot between my legs, kicking my feet apart slightly. I always felt this was the most humiliating: to be completely naked, surrounded on all side by clothed girls, and restrained, so there's nothing I could do about it. Julie knew this, which is why she had me stand in this position. Despite my humiliation, I stood there obediently, waiting for instructions.
"I saw this online," one girl piped up after a while of rummaging through the bags. "It's like pin the tail on the donkey. We blindfold him a strap a marker to his dick, and make him walk toward a target on the wall. We'll each get a turn and whoever is closest to the bullseye wins."
The girls agreed enthusiastically.
"Here are the markers," one girl called out.
"I can draw a target on this easel pad," another girl said.
"And here are some rubber bands to hold the marker to his dick," a third said.
"Everyone, take a color," the first girl said.
"Where should I put the target?"
"How about over on that wall," came the reply.
"Here?"
"It needs to be the same height as his dick."
"OK, bring him over here."
Someone grabbed my arm and dragged me to the wall. The girl with the target adjusted the height so the bullseye was even with my cock and taped the target to the wall. Then she went back from the wall about ten feet and put a strip of tape on the floor.
"We'll start behind this line."
I was dragged back across the room.
"Let's go in rainbow order," someone said. "Red, orange, yellow and so on. Who has red?"
A girl stepped forward timidly.
"OK, strap your marker to his dick. Here's a couple rubber bands."
She clearly was uncomfortable touching me right away. Holding the marker by the cap, she gently rested it on my cock and tried to slip the rubber band over both. The rubber band snapped away before it was around either. She tried again, unsuccessfully. The girls laughed, and one came over to help. This girl clearly had no qualms about touching me. Slipping two rubber bands over the marker, she stretched one out, slid it over my cock, and let it go near the base so it snapped onto my dick. I winced. Not noticing (or not caring) she snapped the other rubber band over my cock near the head. Finally, she removed the cap to the marker.
"OK, bring him over here," the girl with the tape instructed.
"Wait," someone called. "He needs a blindfold."
One girl found a blindfold in the bag. The unabashed girl slipped it over my head and adjusted it to cover my eyes.
"Bring him over to the line, spin him around three times, and send him towards the target."
The timid girl gently grabbed my elbow and walked me to the line. I felt a small push on one arm and a pull on the other, and after a moment of hesitation I realized that was the signal to spin, so I started to shuffle around. The timid girl unwittingly stood too close because, when I reached about halfway around, my cock collided with her. She let out a small shriek and jumped back. The other girls laughed and I paused. After a second, I felt hands on my arms again, and I continued spinning. Eventually she let go, and I stopped. I felt a small push on my back, and I started walking. Unaware of my surroundings, I crashed into a wall before I realized I was there, almost losing my balance. The girls laughed. A hand grabbed my arm firmly and lead me back.
"Good job, Lauren," someone called. "Does anyone have a ruler?" After a pause someone replied, "eleven inches from the bullseye."
I felt the rubber bands being loosened on my dick and another marker being secured. This girl was clearly more confident. When she was satisfied with how the marker was attached to my cock, she immediately grabbed my arms, walked me in three circles, placed a hand firmly on my back, and pushed me towards the wall. This time I knew to be cautious. I slowly shuffled ahead. I felt the marker contact the wall and I immediately stopped.
"Nice!" someone called.
Again, I was brought back and a new marker attached to my cock.
"Four inches," someone called out to cheers.
"Is anyone writing this down?" I heard a girl say.
After a moment of conversation, someone else answered.
"Let's just write it on his chest."
"Great idea!" came the reply.
I felt a marker press firmly into my bare chest.
"Lauren, eleven inches, Kylie four inches," the girl muttered. "OK. Who's next?"
Another pair of hands grab my arms and spun me around three times. Suddenly I felt a hard slap on my ass, and I leapt off toward the wall. The girls laughed and cheered. Unfortunately for me, the spanking made me forget how cautious I needed to be and again I crashed into the war to renewed cheers.
The process of strapping a new marker to my dick, sending me towards the wall, and writing the score on my chest continued. Toward the end, the girls clearly became more brazen, letting the rubber band snap onto my cock harder and slapping my ass harder. When all the girls had gone, they looked at the final results on my chest and stomach.
"It looks like Zoe wins with just three inches from the bullseye," someone said. "Good job!"