A little background into the main characters in this story.
Me - Gary 22yo male with a girlfriend Debs. Still living at home
Debs - my girlfriend 20yo drop dead gorgeous (she told me to mention that).
Cathy - 18yo neighbor who lives across the road. Always looks sweet and innocent
Meg - Cathy's mum looks mid 30s but must be a bit older. I've always fancied her, from afar, as the older woman.
Story
My parents were away for the weekend leaving Debs and me alone to enjoy ourselves. We rarely got this opportunity and we were both looking forward to spending much of the time in bed. Saturday morning started badly, really badly. Debs arrived at about 11.00 o'clock with a worried look on her face.
"Have you seen your dad's car?"
When I said that I hadn't and asked her why she said that there was a scrape right along one side. She was right and I knew my dad would be furious. I wasn't sure exactly what to do about until the front doorbell rang. It was Meg with an even more than usually subdued Cathy standing nearly behind her.
"We have come over to apologize because Cathy has scraped your Dad's car."
Cathy looked like she was just about to burst into tears. We invited them in. I was slightly relieved as knowing who did the damage would at least mean their insurance would pay for the repairs without Dad losing his no claims bonus. This relief was short lived when Meg admitted that Cathy was not insured on the car she was driving. Meg asked if we would do them a huge favor and allow them to submit the claim saying that she had been driving. While I knew this was ethically wrong I was prepared to leave the claim up to them. Debs jumped into the conversation at this point.
"Obviously while we know the car will be fixed it will still be a pain in the ass. How do you think Cathy should be punished for driving without insurance and crashing the car?"
All three of us looked at Cathy who was clearly not going to come up with any answers. It was Meg who tried but failed to answer, as she had not given it any thought. Debs however had given it very quick and very clear thought.
"Gary and I might be happy to agree to turning a blind eye to the details on your claim but I propose that we punish Cathy here and now. In fact I am not sure one spanking or caning would be adequate punishment but we could agree that it would at least be a start."
I was shocked by Deb's forthright and instant proposal. It did seem very decisive but it quickly dawned on me that I had shared that I found the mother and daughter both rather attractive. Maybe Deb's was either playing the situation for my benefit or more likely she wanted to take Cathy down a peg or two. Either way the idea of spanking or caning the sweet and innocent looking Cathy quickly put my underwear under serious pressure.
"You are right that Cathy does need to be punished but I am not sure Gary spanking her is necessarily the answer."
"Don't worry it would not be Gary doing the spanking. I will be doing the spanking and you two can both watch."
Deb's had completely taken control and it seemed that it was only the finer points that were on the table for discussion. Cathy had not said a word, I had not contributed anything of significance but it seemed to be agreed that Deb's would be spanking and or caning the shocked looking Cathy. It was agreed that our neighbor's would arrive at 7.00 that evening and that the first punishment would take place with Meg and I witnessing everything. It was almost an afterthought when I asked Cathy if she agreed to the arrangements. As she had throughout the 'discussion' she looked demure and innocent but when she did look into my eyes there was a fiery excitement that I had not expected.
"Please punish me so that when that is done I can be fully forgiven by everyone."
As she said the last few words she looked at her Mum who seemed to acknowledge what she was saying. Meg's last comment confirmed this.
"I think that it is a suitable arrangement and we both thank you for your understanding. I was not sure how to punish an 18yo but this seems a satisfactory answer."
When the door closed behind them I was not sure which of Deb's or I were more stunned. Her eyes were ablaze with excitement and she flung her arms around me and we held each other tight. She laughed when she felt my erection pushing against her. She teased me about it until I eased us apart and slid my had down into her panties to discover that my erection was not the only sign of extreme sexual arousal.
"If you do that for more than a few seconds I am going to explode in orgasm right here and now. As much as that would be wonderful I would rather wait and enjoy the anticipation of spanking a young innocent bottom. There will be plenty of time for us both to get lots of pleasure this weekend."
"Why did you insist that Meg witnessed the punishment as well as me?"
"I thought that it would mean that Meg would not need to punish her any further if she saw her daughter receive what she was due. Well that was part of the reason but maybe not the main one,the other was that I knew that you have the hots for Meg and I did wonder whether I could persuade her to show her gratitude for us agreeing to her claim problem."
Of all that had gone on in the last half an hour this was the biggest shock of all. Was Deb's really suggesting that Meg would thank me sexually in some way and that if she did that Deb's would be okay about it?
"If she did it might cure you of your fixation with her. I know how hot you find her. I don't feel threatened by her but I must admit that the idea of you fucking her senseless while I watch really floats my boat."
My head was spinning. The picture Deb's was painting of her spanking Cathy and me fucking Meg nearly blew my mind. The spanking was going to happen but I was sure that Meg would never agree to anything sexual with me. Deb's used the possibility to keep me primed all afternoon regularly feeling my partial erection until it became rock-hard. She teased me about fancying an older woman. It wasn't until nearly 7.00 that it dawned on me that Deb's was incredibly aroused by the idea of spanking a girl's bottom. When I mentioned it to her she went a little quiet before asking me.
"Does it bother you that I am very aroused by the prospect?"
I smiled, cuddled her and told her that it was more than fine by me. I slipped my hand into her panties trying to suggest that by doing that I was confirming my answer but really I just wanted to feel her excitement one more time before our guests arrived. I was delighted at the state of her pussy that confirmed my suspicions. How we had managed not to fuck each other brains out for the last seven hours I was not sure but now I was delighted we had not.