[The first chapter of this is
here
. It describes Charlotte as a twenty-six-year old perennial student at the City College of New York. Her boyfriend, the narrator, is six years younger.
A role play with another girlfriend - Michelle - is mentioned in the story and described
here
.]
*****
In the first days of August 1975, right after I came back from a month-long trip out West, Charlotte and I were hanging out in a coffee shop.
I said, "I've been thinking of my own role-play concept. Everybody else seems to create some, so I got one of my own now."
"That's great. Tell me about it."
"It's a sequel to what we did in June, the pick-up game at the Albion Bar. I, or he, comes back and finds her there again.
"He's he stalking her?" It was interesting how we had figured out that we were talking about the characters we played. Like Venn diagrams those characters only partially overlapped our real selves.
"Not really, he swings past the bar on occasions and at the second time she's there."
"That sounds promising. In fact, I'm really impressed." She wasn't faking her anticipation here.
I said, "I have some ideas about this but I'm not going to tell you about those now. I'll be in the lead and you'll follow. Think you can deal with this?"
"Of course, I can deal with it."
I thought,
maybe you can't.
For the most part she hadn't experienced the more disturbing results of role playing that I had seen.
We worked out a weekday, late afternoon deal just like the time before. The appointed day was even hotter and more humid than the first one. This time I was grateful for the cool air in the Albion. My clothes were different but just as bad as before. I'd have been hard-pressed to find anything better in what I owned.
I strolled over and sat to her right again, but this time I went to the stool next to her.
"Hi Charlotte."
"Hey, look who just walked in." She seemed pleasant enough but I caught an undertone, something like,
look what the cat just dragged in
. She continued, "What have you been up to?"
"I work right over here on 24th Street, part time. I do paste-up for a typesetting company."
"How did you get that?" She seemed to be just filling in conversational space.
"My girlfriend works there; she got me in."
"That's so cute; it must be fun to have her there." There was a contrasting nasty and nice tone in her voice.
I looked her over; I loved noticing the details of women I was sleeping with. I think she had the same straw hat, but now it was on the bar with her sunglasses. She was wearing her regular glasses, which I knew she often avoided if she didn't have a specific task at hand like reading a book. I guessed the task now was to see my face during the game.
I continued the rest of my hot-weather Charlotte inventory. She had one of her trademark hairbands, this one white with red dots. Her blouse was a white pullover, sleeveless; her skirt was light blue denim, short enough to be interesting but not enough to be brazen. I always wondered if women ever used the back pockets on skirts like that.
And finally there were brown sandals instead of white ones. Overall, it was a fine balance between sexy and subtle. My next move after collecting these facts was to compliment her. Was she fetching, delightful? I ordered my drink now to give myself a bit more time to think. It was going to be a Manhattan, a cocktail I had never even seen before.
"Anyway, Charlotte, you look great today."
"Well, thank you!" I thought she might add,
not that I care what you think
.
"We sure had a notable time when we met here back in June."
"Oh that; look, so I had a few laughs at your expense. And you really have nothing to complain about."
"Really? How so?"
She lowered her voice, I assume so no one could overhear her. "That peep show thing I staged for you. Remember?
"I remember. I also remember how you got rid of me."
"Come on, I was grouchy. It had been a long day. You can't be that sensitive."
There's the door; I'm showing it to you.
That had been one the things she had said during that game. Was that such a big deal or not?
My drink arrived and the timing was perfect. I was just about to push the game up a notch and I needed a moment to get ready. My college boy self was surprised that Manhattans came in martini glasses.
I had a question for her, a proposal actually, and I tried to be off-the-cuff about it. "Charlotte, have you ever had a man discipline you?"
"What the hell does that mean?" Her first, mild cussing. Of course the real Charlotte knew what I was talking about. I had firsthand experience with her taste for that kind of activity.
For the game I had to come up with the right word for a part of the female anatomy; I didn't want to overplay it at the start. "What I mean if a woman is, call in misbehaving, a man will get her back in line by spanking or paddling her butt."
She had turned her face to me and I was alert to what her reaction would be. She blinked and I'm sure she swallowed hard. There was a quiver in her legs and she squirmed on her seat; then she opened and closed her thighs a couple of time. It was my familiarity with the real Charlotte No. 1 that gave me clues of what to notice about this role playing Charlotte No. 2.
She said, "That's for little kids."
"It's for grown-ups too. Like me girlfriend; she can be quite a snip at times. If she really pushes it I have to take her over my knee and thwack her." Thwack sounded British and I knew Charlotte had an interest in all things Anglophilic.
"I'm not sure I believe you, but even if it's true your girlfriend sounds weird."
"No, she knows she needs it, she knows it's for her own good. Right on her bare ass, knickers down as they say in Britain." I leaned forward and said quietly, "And she likes it too."
Charlotte No. 2 crossed her legs. I had learned a bit about body language in recent months and I always noticed what women did with their limbs. She started kicking the bar panel, not hard but steadily. I waited for a reply but she went back to her tonic drink.
I tasted my Manhattan and tried to form an opinion about it. Then, as I had the floor, I did my bit as a tavern pundit. "It's not just a physical thing, it's emotional too. People have guilt and other difficult feelings. This allows them a release. That's why people, especially woman, often cry during a spanking. It's not just the pain, it's a cathartic experience."
Now that I had demonstrated my liberal arts training, I waiting for her response. She had been looking at me and paying attention to me. She finally tried for nonchalance, "Okay, so what?"
"I think that you could use such an experience; I think you have some feelings you'd like to get out."
"And who would do that for me?"
I came in at a slightly indirect angle, "I'd like to talk to you about it. Let's go to your place and I'll tell you what I think."
"Oh, good try."
"I'll give you a different kind of incentive. You'll get a chance to mess with my head again, and that was fun."
She shook her head, "I won't admit to anything like that. Besides, I don't think you have the nerve to follow through even if I gave you the chance."
A direct challenge; Charlotte No. 2 should have known not to do that with any man, even one as young and inexperienced as I was. I let her have her opinion for the moment, "Whatever I do, you know you can handle it. We saw that last time."
She said, "I wonder - well I wonder if today is such a dull day that I'd actually . . ."
She didn't finish her sentence so I let her think about it as I tried my Manhattan again; I was probably too young to appreciate its taste.
We sat in silence for perhaps a minute. When she did speak it was, "Why did you think you could just sit on the stool next to me"
Because I've seen your cunt
was what came to my mind, but that would be too much. I said, "You're griping about it now?"
She snickered at that. A few moments later, "All right, I am kind of curious about what kind nonsense you'll come up with." She gestured towards the door. I was going to abandon half of an expensive drink again but there were more important matters to consider.
This time she wore both her hat and sunglasses in the street. Also, she wouldn't talk to me. She didn't start a conversation and I sensed I shouldn't either. This gave me the attention to notice that she walked differently. No. 2 kind of sashayed as she walked. No. 1 didn't go in so much for self-dramatization.
We were quiet going through the streets and up the staircase to her apartment. Inside she got the air-conditioner going without the fuss of last time. I sat in an armless chair by the far wall. I had already done this with her numerous times on a sofa or in a chair. For some reason I preferred to use a chair for this session.
She was looking out the window even though there was little to see except the building across the way. Then she looked back at me over her shoulder, over the rims of her sunglasses. Was this a come-hither look or just fooling with me?
When she sat on the couch - my
New York Times
couch from last month - she went through her purse and got her regular glasses on. One leg was up on the cushions so that she could look down the length of it at me. She said, "What I think is, you've had some intense jerk-off fantasies about me, starting with the night you left that time, and now you want to tell me about them."
My response went around that directly to the point, "Here's what I propose to do: once you're over my lap, I'll spank you on the back of your nice little denim skirt." Complimenting her clothes seemed like a good idea. "Just as a warm up. Then you'll get my hand on your bare backside." It seemed good to vary the words; backside sounded more blunt, perhaps. "I'll give it to you pretty hard and for a while too, like several minutes. And then I'll finish with a hairbrush, maybe ten whacks with that. I'm sure that will get your attention."
During this I carefully watched her for more clues. I saw one: she briefly licked her lips. But she didn't speak at the end of my little speech. I had to press this a bit more.
"You do have a hairbrush here? A wooden one?" Of course I knew she had more than one.