Innocence Surrendered
As I contemplated my helpless predicament, Peter pulled my thong panties slowly downward until they hung up on my spread thighs. Cool air tickled me between my legs. With my legs spread and ankles bound, he wouldn't be able to get my panties off the normal way. But he didn't give up. He gave a firm tug and the skimpy fabric ripped. Another determined tug and my panties tore free. I shivered with excitement that he would actually rip from me my panties. I'd never before known him to be like this, so animalistic and passionate as he'd been with the crop and now with my panties.
Soft sounds reached my ears, the rustle of clothing. Peter was undressing. More odd sounds. A soft popping sound, like a lid being opened. A gentle squirt. The hand lotion, I realized. Peter had brought it out earlier. I waited for him to massage the lotion into my burning bottom cheeks, to soothe me with it, but instead when his slippery fingers came it wasn't upon my bottom cheeks at all but in the valley between. And he wasn't soothing at all but preparing, spreading the cool lotion around my untried pucker.
I squirmed against the table and against my bonds, tingling with anxiety. I wasn't sure I really wanted him to take my last virginity, but I was sure I had no choice. I was helpless and I'd asked him to do anything to me he wanted... and he was doing just that. He parted my bottom cheeks even further and I held my breath. It was time, and I was helpless. And yet he didn't penetrate me, didn't touch me there except with his gentle breath as he leaned down close.
"So beautiful," he murmured. "Like a little bud just waiting to blossom. I wonder, Catherine... did you have the foresight to stretch yourself before hand? With your fingers, perhaps? Or even a dildo?"
I groaned. I hadn't stretched myself. I hadn't even thought of it! How on earth could I not have foreseen that Peter would want this of me? The entire time I'd prepared for tonight, and anticipated, and dreamt, I'd only hoped that Peter would share my fantasy enough to accept my submission for the night and crop me like I wanted, and not think my request too strange. Not once had I considered how much further he might take his liberties with me, and how quickly. Not once had I considered that he might want me in my virginal tightness. Oh, how short sighted I had been! Now that I felt his fingers pressing gently for entrance, and imagined how big his penis was going to feel, I wondered if maybe I hadn't made a mistake. Maybe I shouldn't have asked to be bound and gagged, helpless and unable to protest or even beg him to be gentle. And maybe, just maybe, I should have prepared myself a bit more. Oh god...
But it was too late now. Peter penetrated me gently with his finger tip. The lotion felt impossibly cool within my tightness, shallowly at first but soon deeper as he gently worked his finger in further. I instinctively tightened on him and he chuckled.
"Relax, Catherine. Open yourself to me."
I tried to relax, but it was such an odd sensation. I blushed to feel his finger inside me there, in so intimate a place as my bottom hole. He slipped his finger out for a moment to get more lotion and then pressed back inside, deeper and more firmly this time. I gasped at the suddenness. It was mildly uncomfortable, more perhaps from a psychological perspective than actual discomfort. Such a foreign violation, so cool and so reluctant a fit.
And this was only Peter's finger. When he added a second finger alongside the first it hurt a bit. My virginal bottom hole wasn't ready for two fingers. And yet he eased me into it gently, applying more hand lotion and probing me shallowly until I relaxed to him, only pushing deep with his fingers when it was obvious I could let him. As he opened me gently he spoke to me, reassuring me, telling me how much he loved me, how sexy my crop-reddened bottom looked, how snuggly my bottom gripped his fingers.
"How beautiful your submission is, Catherine, that you would allow me such a delight. That you would allow me to posses you so intimately."
His two fingers were deeply within me now, stretching me uncomfortably and spreading the cool lotion deep. I clenched instinctively on him. From time to time he slipped his fingers from me and gathered more lotion before pressing back in deeply. Each time he seemed to penetrate me more easily, my bottom hole each time less reluctant. I was opening to his gentle efforts.
At long last Peter withdrew his fingers and didn't push them back in again. He moved close, pressing up against me from behind as I lay trapped over the table. The hair on his legs tickled the backs of mine. His smooth, stiff cock settled snuggly between my bottom cheeks, lying along the gentle valley there, and I tensed. God, it felt so big. I'd never before felt him so hard for me, so eager. I'd never before felt so attuned to a simple touch. His warm presence between my bottom cheeks felt strangely alive, and in that moment it was almost as if I could feel his pulse throbbing in his cock as it lay against me, as if his stiffness betrayed a pent up excitement at having his new bride bottom up and helpless.
"Do you feel that, Catherine?" Peter asked quietly. He kissed my ear, and then the back of my neck. "That's my love for you, Catherine, and my lust. Do you feel it lying there? I want you to imagine it, Catherine. Imagine it inside you back there, where no one has ever been before. I want you to imagine it stretching you open and pushing deep. Imagine how it's going to feel, Catherine, how it's going to hurt... and how it's going to feel so good."
I groaned around my gag, imagining. In my mind I was suddenly O, bent over helplessly and blind before her lovers. I shuddered to think myself O. O's first violation of her narrowest passage at the hands of her unseen lover had been rough and violent. O had screamed. She had wept afterward. I shuddered. My beloved Peter would be gentler, wouldn't he? Oh god, he had to be. He just had to.
Peter stroked my hair gently, kissing the back of my head and my neck and my shoulders even as he shifted and positioned himself at my tight hole. Not pressing, not pushing, just resting there, his thick glans suddenly feeling so impossibly big between my bottom cheeks and against my tight, virginal pucker. His voice was husky as he whispered to me. "I love you, Catherine. I will always love you, and always lust for you. I want you to remember that as I push up inside you, Catherine. As I take your last virginity, as I have you as no man ever has before. You are mine, Catherine, now and forever."
If I hadn't been gagged I would have told him I felt the same, only twice as much. But I was gagged, and all I could do was groan as his presence against my tight bottom hole became an insistent pressure as he pushed for entry. Not forcing, but firm. Oh God...
In my fantasies, whenever the hero took the heroine's unused bottom hole it always happened in a rush, and it was always to her moans of delight. But this was different. I was tight and unprepared, despite the lotion and Peter's fingers earlier, and I could only grunt into my gag... not with delight, but with discomfort. It hurt. Peter was being gentle and not rushing, but still it hurt. Ever so slowly he eased inside me, just the tip of his cock.
Just having him inside me back there, stretching me open even that little bit, made me instinctively tense. I closed my eyes and willed myself to relax, tried to imagine my virginal bottom opening to him like a flower and accepting his penis. Only it wouldn't come, at least not more than a little bit each time Peter pushed gently forward.
"Don't worry," he whispered in my ear as he stroked my arms reassuringly. "Just relax, my pet. It'll come."
I groaned around the gag. Why, oh why had I asked him to gag me? If my mouth had been free, I would have surely asked him to pull out. But I couldn't ask him that. I couldn't ask him anything, or beg, or plead, or anything, except strain helplessly against my bonds and try to force myself to relax.
Through the heady flush of my predicament I was barely aware of Peter slipping his hand beneath me and feeling between my legs. He searched with his fingers, sliding easily there along the wetness between my folds, and when he brushed against my clit I couldn't help but smile and push back a little. Oh, that felt nice! I moaned into my gag, and in my mind I begged him to please, please touch me like that again. He did. And again. And his fingers stayed, stroking gentle little circles around my clit even as his cock continued to press for entrance at my bottom. I couldn't help but relax a little, couldn't help but angle my hips so he had better access with his fingers, and in that moment I felt myself open to him behind. I winced and grunted in surprise, biting down hard on my gag as he sank suddenly into my tight bottom hole.
"Mmmm... so that's the trick!"