Please enjoy this new chapter of Twins Score. Despite the High School setting, this particular lot of horny characters are all at least eighteen years old.
The previous chapter ended when Jason tricked Isleta into thinking she was blowing his twin brother, Justin. To continue the charade, the twins have swapped clothes and it's time for her to formally meet Jason. Enjoy
—Taylor VanCannon.
*****
"Hi Jason," Isleta said, extending her hand, "it's good to meet you. Come in before you freeze."
Jason walked in ahead of his brother, taking Isleta's hand. Any hint of her sultry body was now hidden by a bulky knit sweater and loose fitting jeans. She gave him a peck on the cheek before turning and kissing Justin, pressing her tongue against his lips.
Justin winced as her tongue probed his mouth, knowing that his brothers cock had been in that luscious mouth just moments before. She had sucked his cock many times, and he was pretty sure that the tongue probing his mouth was recently coated with his brother's cum.
If Isleta noticed his reaction, she ignored it. She took Jason by the hand and led him over to the fireplace, leaving Justin to follow them.
"Thanks," Jason said, "It's pretty cold out there."
"I know," Isleta said, "I can't believe Justin made you wait out there with your lame cover story."
Justin opened his mouth to speak when Isleta hushed him, placing her fingers to his lips, "Don't, I told you I am okay with what happened with Maggie, so just let it go."
"Isleta," Jason said, "This is all my fault, I was the one who told him to try the mistaken twin routine."
She looked at him skeptically, "Why, you didn't have to do that for your brother. Anyway, what made you think it would work, nobody is going to mistake the two of you?"
"Don't be so sure," Justin challenged her, before instantly regretting it.
"Really Justin?" she shot back, "I thought this was settled. Are you going to deny being with Maggie?"
"No... no...," Justin stammered, realizing he'd stepped right back into it.
"And I can prove it to you, both of you," Isleta said, defiantly, "Take off your shirts."
"Isleta," Jason pleaded, "I don't think—"
"Do it!" she commanded, cutting him off.
"Fine," Justin said, "but it won't prove anything."
Jason watched his brother strip off his shirt and toss it on the hearth. He made one last ditch effort to save his brother from self destruction, "Isleta, you're right, you don't have to prove it. Justin is ripped, and I'm not, so it's no contest."
"I'm glad you see that, but your brother needs to be taught a lesson in humility, so get your shirt off."
She started with Justin, running her hands up his arms, squeezing his powerful biceps. Looking into his eyes, she said, "Mmmm, just the way I like them. What do you think I'm going to feel when I do that to your brother?"
"Alright, you've made your point," Justin said, "but, it doesn't prove that I was with Maggie."
"Are you fucking crazy," she replied, "of course it does." Just to emphasize her point, she ran her hands over Jason's arms, then across his chest and down to his abs, giving them a quick slap. There was a noticeable difference between them, but Jason was not as soft as she was expecting. To erase any doubt, she said, "Sorry, Jason, but's there is no way Maggie mistook you for your brother."
"No offense taken," he said, trying to act nonchalant as her soft hands caused his cock to stiffen in his pants. Fortunately, she turned back to Justin without noticing.
"Is it settled?" she asked Justin, daring him to disagree with her.
"I guess," he said, trying to contain a laugh.
"What's so fucking funny?" Isleta, demanded, more annoyed than ever.
"Look what you've done to my brother," he said, pointing to Jason.
"Oops," she said, instantly realizing what she had done. "Sorry Jason, I didn't... I mean..."
Jason's face flushed when Isleta joined his brother, unable to contain her laughter.
Justin was relieved, even if it was at the expense of his brother. Maybe this was over.
Jason was not happy being the butt of their joke, "I'll give you two something to laugh about," he said, with a devious look in his eye, "Justin, describe what Isleta was wearing when she answered the door."
"What are you talking about Jason?" Isleta asked, her laughter fading.
"It's a simple request," Jason said, as innocently as he could.
"Okay," Isleta said to Justin, "I think your horny brother wants to know what happened after you knocked on the door."
"Isleta," Justin pleaded, "Don't."
"I don't mind if he knows what I was wearing, just tell him."
After a long pause, Jason said, "He can't tell you, because he didn't see you."
"What?" Isleta asked, still not comprehending.
"It wasn't him," Jason said, "It was me."
She closed her eyes for a moment, trying to comprehend her predicament. Had Jason taken advantage of her? Or, should she be grateful that Justin had been faithful to her? She walked up to Jason and squeezed his firm cock. "Did I really suck you off?"
"Uh-huh," he said, sheepishly, fearful of what she was about to do.
"And Maggie too? She sucked you off?"
"Uh-huh," he repeated.
"And you," she said, turning to Justin, "apparently, nobody has sucked your cock today, is that right?"
"Uh-huh," Justin said, matching his brothers trepidation.
Isleta smiled, bewildered that she was so easily fooled. "I'll tell you what," she said, "you two keep quiet about fooling me, but let me rub it in Maggie's perky little face, at least give me that."
They were both quick to agree, grateful to have Isleta off the warpath.
Isleta knelt in front of Justin, unbuckled his pants and dropped them to his ankles. "Fuck!" she said.
"What's wrong," Justin asked.
"Just a little detail you two conspirators overlooked."
"The boxers?" Jason asked.
"Uh-huh, changing clothes fooled me, so it's a good thing I didn't notice the boxers on my own. There's no telling how I might have reacted." She slid Justin's boxers down, and licked the head of his cock.
"Should I leave?" Jason asked, slightly embarrassed to see his brother getting his cock sucked.
Isleta turned to him and asked, "Jealous?"
"A little," he said, "I know how good that must feel for Justin."
"Wait a minute, when you told me I was the best cocksucker, was that the truth?"
"Well... Maggie didn't exactly suck my cock, so I guess I can't say for sure," he said, truthfully, then quickly added, "But, you were fantastic."
"So what? You fucked her?"
"Yes, but she let me finish in her mouth, just like you did."
"Really, how did you talk her into that?"
Justin chimed in, "Don't underestimate how devious my brother can be. Remember, while he was pretending to be me, he convinced Maggie that she should give my brother a mercy fuck, along with the other cheerleaders."
Isleta turned to Jason, "Is that true?"
"Hey," he replied, "I just wanted to share in my brother's bounty. It's not like I can get that on my own."
Isleta looked to Justin, "What do you think? Should I do the same? Give Jason a mercy fuck."
Jason was ready to jump out of his boxers, nodding his head enthusiastically.
"Do I have a choice?" Justin asked.
"Not if you want me to suck you off," she said, warming up to the prospect of doing both brothers. "Jason, drop those boxers and let's go up to my room."
Isleta peeled off her clothes off as she climbed the stairs, seductively flinging each piece at the boys following her. By the time she entered the door to her room, she was naked, her clothes in the hands of the twins.
She stopped short of the bed and turned to face them. She looked at them seductively, her dark, mysterious eyes, beckoning them too her. She fondled her large breasts, cupping her hands under them, rolling her nipples between her thumbs and forefingers. She had their undivided attention.
"You can drop my clothes," she said, reaching for their cocks. "God, you two are good looking, and these cocks are fantastic."
The twins looked at each other apprehensively. It was the first time they had been naked together since they were little kids, and they were uneasy about seeing each others cocks.
Sensing their discomfort, Isleta said, "Ease up you two, it's not like your going to have to suck each others cocks. That's what I'm here for."
That seemed to break the tension. She dropped to her knees and took Justin's cock into her mouth, slowly pushing him down her throat. After a couple of strokes, she switched to Jason and repeated the treatment she had just given Justin.
She continued sucking them, moving back and forth between them until they were both rock hard. "That was easy, let's move up to the bed."
She rolled Justin over on his back and lay on her side with her head resting on his abs, his cock just inches from her mouth. She tucked her legs up, exposing her ass to Jason. He lay on his side, behind her and pressed himself against her ass, fondling her crack.
"Mmmm," she whispered, before taking Justin's cock into her mouth and gently stroking him with her hand.
Jason probed her crack with the head of his cock, searching for her entrance. Keeping Justin's cock in her mouth, she reached back and gently guided Jason's cock into her tight, wet cunt.
Her moan was muffled by Justin's cock in her mouth as Jason slowly pushed his cock in, filling her cunt.
Jason watched intently as Isleta spread her saliva over his brother's cock and stroked him while she sucked on the head of his cock. Justin was aware of his brother watching, and propped himself up on a pillow to get a better view for himself.
Isleta came off Justin's cock and said, "Mmmm, Jason's cock feels so good. Is that getting you hot, watching your brother fuck me?"
"I guess," Justin said, slightly annoyed that she had stopped sucking him and seemed more interested in his brother.
"Oh yeah, Jason, keep that up, your cock inside me feels so good." She continued to stroke him, but didn't take him back into her mouth. Instead, she focused on Jason's cock, sliding in and out of her wet pussy.
"Like this?" Jason asked, picking up the pace and thrusting himself deep into her.
"Oh yes," she moaned, "even harder." She ignored Justin's cock just inches from her face and moved her hand down between her legs to concentrate on her own pleasure.
Justin watched his brother pound away at Isleta, bouncing her against his body with each thrust, propelling her closer and closer to an orgasm.
The combination of her fingers and Jason's cock sent her over the edge, shrieking as a powerful orgasm crashed over her, giving her wave after wave of intense pleasure.
Justin looked at his brother, expecting him to blow his load into Isleta's writhing body. But, it didn't happen and Jason rolled back, exhausted, his cock flopping out of her wet pussy.
"Fuck!" she finally exclaimed, "That was so good. Did you cum?"
"No, not yet," Jason said, gasping for breath.
"Mmmm," she cooed, "you mean I get to do this again?"
"Uh-huh," Jason said, "but maybe we better switch places, I think I need a rest."
"Justin?"
