Too Good to Be True

I made an error in my first submission I would like to clarify. I mistakenly transposed some numbers, April was 150lbs not 105lbs.

*****

I regularly received calls from Lisa but couldn't bring myself to answer them. Finally, I answered one day, guilt and some hard life lessons over the past few months really changed my perspective and I realized, I really was being an asshole.

"Hello"

"Jesus, finally, are you just never home or are you ignoring me?"

Lisa's voice was velvety, I missed her alot, but I couldn't say that. If April found out we were even talking on the phone, I was afraid she might try to hit Lisa again, and I couldn't live with the thought of that happening.

"No, I'm not ignoring you, but I've been really busy lately. Got alot going on right now. Good to hear from you though."

"I'm not pregnant!" Lisa didn't mince words either, and a tremendous weight came off my shoulders when she said those words. I did a little happy dance quietly, took a deep breath and calmed down before responding.

"That's great news! I'm glad that isn't something you have to deal with, I know I left on bad terms."

"Yeah you did jackass! You didn't even tell me you we're leaving, didn't say bye, I woke up with that bitch still chewing my ass the next day."

"I'm sorry hun, I know she was upset at me and she had every right to be."

"No, she didn't!" Lisa cut me off.

"It's not her fucking decision what I do, I'm an adult now, she can't control me anymore!" she said angrily.

"Maybe so, but she's still your mom Lisa, don't shut down on her."

"I'm done talking about her. So what have you been up to lately, you sound down" she changed the subject quickly.

"Oh, trying to find a good job, I can't seem to find one, they all require experience. Experience I can't get without doing the damn job. I just need a shot, I can prove myself, but nobody will give me one" I said almost pouting.

"Why don't you go to college then dumbass? That's what everyone is trying to tell you, but you aren't listening!"

Lisa never cared before, I was a little shocked. Had her feelings toward me changed? I didn't ask, I didn't want to be wrong and be an ass again, assuming I know everything.

"I know, but I don't have high enough scores to get into the university"

"Tell you what, I am going to pack some stuff and come down to your apartment and help you," she said.

"How did you know I had an apartment? I haven't told Ray, and I sure haven't talked to April." I asked.

"Tammy told me. She said you moved into it about a month ago and wouldn't let her stay there to help you get situated. If I had to bet, you still have your clothes in garbage sacks on the floor, you need some help, I'll be there tomorrow. Muah!" She said, sternly, making that little kissy sound before she hung up.

I stood there holding the phone in shock. My mind started racing in a thousand directions. How many times has Lisa called Tammy? What did Lisa tell her? How the hell did she get my new number? Tammy, duh, she said that once. I hung up, picked it back up immediately and called home.

"Hello?" Mom answered.

"Hey momma. Is Tammy around? I need to ask her a question."

"Yeah, hang on. TAMMY!" she yelled, not bothering to take the phone away from her mouth.

"Geez mom...can I borrow your hearing aid now? I think I need it after that!" I joked.

"Ha ha asshole. Here she is. It's your brother" I heard her trail off as she handed the phone over.

"What?" Tammy said.

"Why did you give Lisa my new phone number, and tell her I had an apartment?" I asked.

"Wow, nice to talk to you too big brother! Haven't talked to you in a couple months and you start chewing my ass the second I pick up the phone!" She said sarcastically.

"Sorry, I didn't mean to sound like I was chewing your ass. I'm just confused, you don't even like Lisa, why would you give her my information, even more why would you even talk to her on the phone?" I calmly asked.

"She wouldn't stop calling here looking for you. I finally answered and she really opened up to me about April and Ray, how April hit her, it was awful and I felt bad for her. She was crying and needed help, I couldn't just hang up so I helped her."

"Ok, but what did that have to do with me?" I asked, calmly again. The whole time my stomach is churning, wondering, what is Tammy about to say? Did she know?

"I'll be over in 10 minutes, I can't talk on the phone about this." She said. The way she said it, I knew mom was standing close, within earshot, and Tammy didn't want her to hear what she was saying.

"Shit, mom can hear you huh?"

"Yeah, see you in 10." As she hung up.

I hung up too, slowly sinking into the stool next to the counter. I could feel tears welling as I sat there and thought the worst. My sister, the one person I always had in my corner, would be here in 10 minutes to take me over the coals. I was about to lose the last person in my life that was always there.

I stayed there, losing track of how long I actually sat there. I heard the lock jiggling and the door swung open. I completely forgot Tammy had a key, she had an extra made for herself to drop off some of my stuff when she headed into town every now and then.

I quickly wiped my cheeks, eyes puffy and red, Tammy took one look at me and knew I was crying. She shut the door, dropped her purse and the laundry basket, and ran across the living room to wrap her arms around me as I cried like a baby.

"I fucked up alot. I know I did. I knew it was wrong but I couldn't help it, it just happened!" I said between sobs.

"Shh...stop crying, it's ok. You're gonna be ok. Here, have a smoke and let me make some food." She said, lighting a cigarette and handing it to me.

She went around the counter to the fridge to open it. I laughed at her. "Nothing in there but a couple beers and expired milk"

She grabbed 2 of the beers, closed the fridge, and walked around to hand me one as she took a huge chug out of the other.

"Pizza it is then." As she picked up the phone, ordering pizza. "Ok thanks, 15 minutes, got it." As she hung up.

"I don't have enough money for pizza Tammy. I was going to come home for dinner tonight. I was also going to announce that I wanted to go to college." I admitted.

"You are? That is the best decision you have ever made! I'm so damn proud of yeewwww!" She shrieked as she wrapped her arms around my head and shook back and forth. "Don't worry about the pizza, I got it. Cheers to the college boy!" She raised her beer.

"Cheers!" Our bottles clanked and we drank.

Tammy walked to the only piece of furniture I had, my bed, and sat down. I grabbed my beer and pack of smokes to join her and let her say what she started to on the phone.

"Ok, spit it out. I know you had something to say on the phone earlier and you didn't because of mom. What was it?" I asked, ready for my ass chewing and maybe slap.

"Gimme a cigarette first." Shocked, I handed her the pack with my eyes wide.

"I started smoking a year ago, I just hid it well." She said answering my shocked expression.

"You, however, don't hide anything well. What was it that was so bad you were crying and apologizing to me for when I walked in?"

"Nuh uh...you first. What were you going to say?"

"Lisa told me Ray touched her and actually fucked her. I couldn't believe it. I didn't want to say that in front of mom, she would've had him arrested again!" She said.

"Again?"

"Yeah, I know. Lisa told me he went to jail for forging prescriptions. What an idiot!" She said.

"What else did Lisa tell you?"

"That April got drunk and threw you out, you called her out on being like Ray only with whiskey. Lisa said she stood up to her and April slapped the shit out of her. She blamed you and threw you out that night"

"Oh, ok. Well, Lisa will be here tomorrow, said she is packing some clothes and coming to help me"

She shifted her weight, pulling her left thigh on the bed and turning towards me. "Spill."

"Huh?"

"Don't treat me like I'm an idiot or I don't know you. You're hiding something, something big, I can feel it. Tell me!" She said in her little high pitched voice as she pushed my shoulder.

"I can't, you wouldn't understand and I can't risk losing the last person in my life that has some faith in me"

"Randall James! How dare you say that to me! After everything we went through growing up, we always stuck together. I have told my darkest secrets to you. Spill dammit!"

"Promise you won't hate me?"

"Promise!" As she raised her bottle to cheers again, shaking it afterwards, sad it was empty.

"Hold that, you only have 2 more beers, let's go to the corner and get more. Cmon, we still have time before the pizza gets here. Grab your ID" she called back, headed for the door.

I turned 21 that summer so I was old enough to buy alcohol, but I didn't have the money if I wanted to make rent. I followed her out anyway.

"You giving me money to buy it?" I asked, locking the door.

"Yeah this rounds on me." She said, walking to her car.

"Damn girl, buying AND driving? To what do I owe this once in a lifetime gift?"

"Judging from you all panicking about me getting mad, you got some serious skeletons you're about to tell me about, I owe you. Kinda like foreplay really, buttering you up to get what I want from you!"

"Yeah...let's not make that reference again sis..."

I hop back in the car, 12 pack in hand, as she opens the center console and grabs a pack of cigarettes out of the carton she had tucked in there.

"Here, pack these and light me one." She said as she handed me the pack and backed away from the store. "Light yourself one too, you look like you need it!"

We walked back to the door, my hands full with a box of beer and her smokes, she unlocked the door and pushed it open. I set the beer on the counter and started to put them in the fridge. The doorbell rings, Tammy pulls a $50 from her purse and walks to the door.

"$29.75 please." Said the delivery guy.

"Here you go, keep the change"

"Wow, are you sure? That's a huge tip for 2 pizzas!"

"Hang on." As she walks toward the counter, sets the pizza down, and grabs the now empty box of beer. "Throw this in that dumpster by the road as you drive out, there you earned it" she said, waving bye with her fingers as she shut the door.

"Where the hell did you get this much money?" I asked, holding what had to be $5,000.

"Nuh uh...you first. Spill."

"Ugh, do I have to?"

She was taking a bite of pizza and froze, giving me that look I recognized all too well.

"Ok, ok, fuck. Here goes!"

She sat in stunned silence as I laid out the details of how I had incestuous sex with my new stepmom and stepsister about a year ago. She gulped down a few more beers with her pizza, now lighting a cigarette.

"And you said I looked like I needed a smoke!" I joked.

"I knew something was up, Ray was way too easy to get money from" she said, stopping suddenly looking like the cat that ate the canary.

"What money? What are you talking about Tammy?"

"Well, this is awkward"

"HA...nope, keep going. I just told you and described how I fucked April and Lisa, you don't get to stop now!"

"Well, Lisa told me a long time ago about Ray, like right after you moved up there. So, I called Ray and told him I would tell mom about Lisa if he didn't send me money. So he did, every month, $500 a month. I didn't have anything to spend it on so I saved it. This is what's left, about $4,000." holding up a wad of cash.

"Wait, you did what? And he did it? What did he say?"

"Ok, look, don't tell your mom, she will have me arrested again just out of spite. I'll send you the money, just don't tell anyone I fucked Lisa's ass!"

I sat back, thought, and started laughing my ass off. The irony of what happened, and that Ray bought Tammy's silence, that sure wasn't what he was worried about on the lake that day.

"Ok, what's so funny?" She asked, serious as she could have been, at least while buzzed anyway.

"He paid you to keep quiet about something I already knew about!"

I have no idea why I found that funny, neither did Tammy, as she looked at me with almost pity while I laughed hysterically.

Tammy stood up and went to throw away the empty plate and bottle. "Want another beer there funny guy?"

"Sure why not!" As I began to collect my control and settle down again.

Tammy handed me an already open beer while still shaking her head. "I can't believe you really fucked them both on the same day. She even took your virginity!" She said as she walked to the bathroom, right in front of my bed.

I figured she would shut the door, but no, she didn't. She unbuttoned her shorts and slid them and her panties down as she sat on the toilet.

"Wow, no shame in your game tonight huh?" I called out, shocked, as I turned my head.

"Really? You really just said that after your little stunt at dad's?"

"Well, yeah, what else should I say? You just pulled your clothes off without shutting the door, I had to come up with something. Awkward!" I sang as I turned back to face her.

She waited until I was looking at her to spread her legs, shorts and panties at her ankles, to grab some toilet paper. She stared right at me, eyes like lasers, as she slowly reached between her legs, raising one up on her tiptoes, and wiping herself. She bit her lip as she scooted her toilet paper covered hand up her sex, almost as if she were enjoying it.

"What the fuck are you doing?" I asked her, no more laugh or joke, serious as I could be.

She winked and burst out into laughter, breaking the awkward silence and stare she had on me. She grabbed her shorts and pulled them up before she stood up, concealing herself as she got dressed again, although she had a hard time with the top button because she couldn't stop laughing.

"I couldn't help it. I had to play on that, see if you would make a move on your real sister while she was all vulnerable and naked on your toilet!" She howled.

"That was fucked up! You missed a button." I said as I reached out toward her shorts as if I were going to button them for her.

She froze and took a couple steps backward, no more laughing, serious look on her face now, almost concerned. She just stood there, studying my face, thinking hard.

"You really would huh?" She finally said after her thoughts cleared.

"Would what?" I was confused.

"You really would make a move on me wouldn't you?" She said in a serious tone.

"Fuck no, I could never do that, you're my real sister, I couldn't do that!" I said, meaning every word of it too.

"Uh huh..." she said in a mocking tone.

"What, you don't believe me? Seriously? Tammy Nicole how dare you!" I said as I stood up. Two can play the middle name game.

I walked back to the kitchen to throw away the empty bottles ans get another beer, my head fuming, if it were any colder I would physically be steaming. "Want another beer?"

I listened for a response but never heard one. I turned around to look, seeing if she was taking a drink or lighting a smoke and shaking her head, and almost dropped the beer I got from the fridge.

Tammy had quickly stripped naked and was lying on my bed, legs up, and stroking her bald pussy as she looked at me from between her legs and breasts. My mouth was wide open, I was stunned. I had really never looked at my sister, being from the south, we got made fun of enough for the stereotypical sister fucking so I never had a thought to look.

She was really into this, rubbing herself and lifting her hips off the bed to meet her hand. "I've always wanted to play with you. I used to sneak into your closet and sit there, waiting on you to go to bed, so I could see you jerk off. I watched and played with you, I just never could bring myself to go any farther." She cooed while now rubbing her clit hard.

I couldn't speak, I just stood there. I was shocked. I couldn't believe my little sister, even though she was 20, was talking like this and masturbating in front of me. I blinked and swallowed, as I took a big gulp of my beer, thinking carefully before I spoke to reply. She just put herself all the way out there in front of me, I couldn't crush her like that. Plus, fuck she was hot and I never realized it.

"Wow, I don't know what to say sis. I'm literally in shock." I said, staring at her now as I walked in the room.

She kept rubbing, intent on cumming now, as she picked up the pace of her hand assaulting her own clit. I could sense her climax approaching, her breath heavy, moans now escaping her lips. I walked to the edge of the bed, standing over my naked masturbating sister, as I touched her knee and started rubbing her leg.

"You are a dirty little girl, spying on me in my closet. Were you playing with yourself like this? Were you rubbing your little bean uncontrollably, begging to cum?" I said softly, giving her the extra push she needed to send her over the edge.

She writhed in ecstasy as wave after wave darted throughout her body, the throes of orgasm possessing her wholly now. I let my eyes wander, shifting down to her hand over her pussy, my mouth watering with anticipation, longing to taste her juices.

I set my beer down on the bathroom counter and returned to the edge of the bed. Tammy's orgasm had yielded, she was back in control of her body, as I kneeled down at the edge of the bed, eye level with her now leaking and pouting pussy. I slowly leaned forward, maintaining eye contact, as I lightly kissed the top of her foot. She shuddered when my lips touched her skin, I moved over a tiny fraction, kissing lightly again.

She broke our stare by closing her eyes and inhaling deeply. As she slowly exhaled, she spoke. "Please don't be playing a joke on me right now. I just put my darkest desire out there. Come lick my pussy please!" She pleaded.

I took my hands, lifted her foot off the bed, and took her toe in my mouth, lightly sucking and swirling my tongue around the bend of it. She arched her back as she moaned "God what are you doing to me? Stop playing with my fucking feet already you perv, put your tongue in my cunt!" She called out, louder with each word.

I disobeyed, slowly kissing and working my way along all of her toes, up her foot, to her ankle. She moaned in disappointment, "fuck seriously?" as she slid her hand down to her cunt. I caught her movement out of the corner of my eye and stopped her, grabbing her hand and pulling it away from her tanned body. "WHAT THE FUCK?!" She screamed, frustrated.

"Patience, we have all night, just sit back and feel." I mouthed into her calf, loud enough she could hear me. I released her hand, trusting her to do as I asked. I kissed to her knee, and began tracing my tongue along her thigh, her body trembling with anticipation. I felt her grab my hand, pulling to her pussy.

"You said I couldn't use my hand but you never said anything about yours!" She said as she pulled my hand firmly to her mound, using her finger to press mine into her clit as she sighed dramatically.

I smiled as I continued kissing my way up her thigh, to the bend of her leg, to the crease leading to her ass cheek. I never noticed, but damn she had a nice ass as I rolled her onto her stomach, taking in the picture. I resumed my tongue licking the crease along the bend of her leg as she pulled her knees under her to get on all fours.

"God stop teasing me already and tongue fuck me!" She begged. I guess I had put her through enough torture, so I obliged by sticking my tongue out as far as it would go, making it stiff, and shoving it into her wet awaiting hole.

"OOOOHHH FFFUUUUCCCKK!" she cried, as she instantly came on my face. Her body shuddered as I bent my tongue inside her cavern, her walls contracting around my tongue as I continued my assault.