As we began approaching the house, Sarah said,
"Hey, I know Cassie has been teasing you and all, but try not to hold it against her, okay? She's missed you a lot since we all moved away, and she's just been really excited to see you. She likes you a lot, you know."
After processing what she said, I said,
"I see. I...didn't know. I've missed Cassie too, and it has been fun to see her, even if it has been a bit troublesome at times."
Sarah smiled.
"Good. I knew you would understand. Also, be sure to give Isabella some attention too. She may be shy, but she gets lonely just like the rest of us, possibly more than the rest of us. I'm sure she's been excited to see you too, even if she doesn't show it."
"I will," I said.
After heading inside, we saw that the girls were playing board games while my aunt and mom started on dinner. My dad and uncle were apparently in the TV room, watching football.
"Where were you?" Cassie asked.
"Taking a walk," Sarah answered, untroubled.
Cassie gave me an piercing look, and then said,
"Well, we're playing games. Wanna join?"
Sarah and I sat down and began playing board games. During the games, Cassie's foot found its way into my lap and fondled my crotch after getting it hard. Looking over at her, her mouth was slightly smiling but her eyes were fierce. Eventually, we were interrupted by dinner, and then after that we all went our separate ways. By the time that the evening had grown late, I was on the air mattress, scrolling through my phone while getting ready for bed. I wondered if Cassie would come to see me, and in truth I hoped so, but she never did, and eventually I began to nod off.
I woke up. It was still dark in the house, meaning that it must be either late night or early morning. There was somebody nestled between my legs, and there was a hand stroking my hard cock. Looking down, I could see the outline of a person beneath my blankets. Pulling off my blankets, I saw Cassie there, laying on her stomach with her hand inside my boxers while her other hand was inside her panties with her ass thrust into the air. Her red hair was in bushy pigtails, she was wearing a black t-shirt, and she was wearing red panties. She looked up at me, made eye contact with me, and then gave me a meager and mysterious smile. She pecked my dick with a kiss through my boxers and then began crawling up my body.
Upon reaching my face, she looked down at me, and then whispered,
"Hey."
"Hey," I said nervously.
"So tell me. What happened with you and Sarah on that walk of yours?" She interrogated.
I cringed.
"Why do you ask?"
"Because I can tell that something was up." She said. "Did you fuck her?"
I opened my mouth to speak, but my expression of guilt gave me away immediately. Cassie settled back, planting her ass on my dick, satisfied to have gotten her answer.
Accusatorily, she said,
"You know, when I said you could fuck my sisters, I didn't think you would run off and do it the very moment I looked away. Why did you feel the need to fuck her when I'm the one who has been teasing you since you got here? Am I not good enough for you? Can you only get off if it's with someone as beautiful as Sarah?"
As she said this, she began slowly rubbing her crotch on my dick, her mouth frowning and her expression hurt.
I sat up so that I could look her in the face at eye level and proclaimed,
"Of course not! Cassie, you're gorgeous! You've been driving me crazy since the very first second I got here! I want to do terrible, awful things to you every time I see you! But after what happened at the pond I felt like I was going to explode and you weren't around. Sarah asked me on a walk, and she told me that she had figured out what was going on and then offered to help me grant relief. Yes...we had sex...but that doesn't mean that I don't find you attractive! You might just be the most beautiful woman I've ever known!"
As I said this, Cassie's glowering softened, and she looked at me with tenderness and joy. Leaning forward, she kissed me on the lips, and then pulled back, her smile slowly turning into a more mischievous smirk.
Scooching backwards, she settled between my legs and dragged her fingertips down the underside of my erection once before saying,