All characters are fictional and are over the age of 18. The setting is Summer 1994 Burlington Vermont. This is a slow burn story, because that's how I wrote it. If you want to get straight to the sex, read something else. Author's note: This is a continuation from The Movie Room -- Part 1. Notes, Q&A, and news of upcoming stories will be available by checking out my profile. You keep liking, rating and comments on these stories, and I'll keep cranking them out. I wrote this story in a few hours; I'll further proof read and edit in the future, time permitted.
Chapter 5
If my brain was a Television, it was only tuned in to one channel: Jess.
It had been an hour since I had slammed Jess against the movie room door, my hands up her skirt, suspending her in the air with both my hands under her ass, exploring her mouth and breasts with my own lips and tongue. The hour we were away from each other felt like only a few minutes had passed, and time was standing still, at least for me. Everything tingled. My face was still hot where she grabbed me by the neck and gripped me tight, I could still smell her scent on me, her arousal and Bath & Bodyworks perfume. Every attempt to change my thought process to something else was absolutely doomed to come right back around, thinking of my beautiful sister, her hair, long tan legs, her perfect smile. I had it bad, and I knew it.
I could hear the girls laughing from time to time outside the movie room, and I wondered if Jess was in the same state as me. We didn't have much time at all to talk about what happened, to explore the benefits or consequences of the situation. It had just happened... so quickly. I willed it to happen, and I wanted to do something crazy that I knew we both wanted. Her mix of alcohol and my sudden anger manifested it, but they were suppressed feelings we both knew were there for quite a while now. My guts were tearing themselves apart with nervousness, of what we had done, and what we still might do. I'm not an overly religious person, but deep down inside, in a far away place in the back of my mind, I know that kissing and touching your sister a certain way is wrong, and that having certain feelings of affection for your sister is wrong, and any of these actions could damn me to hell. I have a feeling I'm going to find out if hell exists or not, because no matter how torn I 'am about what transpired, two things are true: I am in love with Jess, and she is my blood related sister.
I heard a phone ring somewhere in the distance, breaking my ruminating trance-like impure thoughts. Brandy's voice boomed through the house.
"Chris, it's for you! Caller ID says Daaaaaaan."
I stood up and before I walked out of the movie room and did a cursory check to make sure I didn't have an obvious erection, and quickly looked at my face in the mirror behind the bar to see if I was in any kind of obvious distress. The girls were all sitting at the patio furniture off the pool deck, and Brandy was inside the house, her ass sticking out of the fridge, getting some beers.
"Phone on the table." Brandy pointed to the dinner table.
"Thanks." I picked up the phone and heard a familiar voice right away.
"Chris! Is that you? You son of a bitch."
I walked to my room with the phone and closed the door behind me, so I could speak in peace, and so I wouldn't have to yell over the girls laughing. I plopped down in the computer chair, and thumbed through some tapes I had out, so see which one I wanted to play.
"Sounds like a fucking day care at your house."
"The girls are being loud; they are always loud. Not to mention they are drunk."
Dan laughed. "Brandy, drunk? You don't say!"
"They all had a little to drink. You know Brandy is the ringleader though. She put the moves on me in the movie room."
Dan laughed again. "That movie room is legendary. We all got some action in there didn't we? Shit, I remember this one time..."
Dan and I talked for about 20 minutes, about old girlfriends, times in high school, getting in trouble, you name it. It was really good to talk to him and catch up; it's amazing how your mood can improve with a little socialization. Dan told me he was going to visit home in two weeks, which was exiting, and of course we planned 10 different things to do while he was in town. Before we hung up, Jess entered the room. I fell silent for a second, and the door clicked behind her as she shut the door.
"Dan, I got to go."
"Don't let me keep you. See you dude. Get on AOL later if you're not... busy."
"Yeah, right. See ya."
I clicked end on the cordless phone and looked up, to see Jess sitting on the edge of my desk across from me, legs slightly parted, straight faced. She reached over and took the phone from me, and I let her. I must have noticeably gulped, because she looked at my throat and back to my face again, putting the phone behind her. I could not get a read on her, the face that was staring back at me was almost totally motionless. Her eyes once again darted to my neck and back to meet my eyes again.
"Hey." I managed to croak out the word. My throat was so dry.. again.
"I can see where I had my hands on your neck. It's faint, but I can see where my fingers were."
I touched my neck and looked to my reflection in the computer monitor. My skin was still tingling where she had grabbed me roughly before our encounter. I had replayed what we did in that movie room a hundred times already.
"I'm sorry for being so rough." She added, smoothing her skirt out slowly, curling the ends up with her fingertips.
"It's okay. I'm fine."
"That's good."
The silence was practically roaring in my ears. The only thing I could hear was the sound of girls talking outside my door periodically. Jess took the initiative to break the ice.
"Is it strange, that I kinda like seeing my marks on you?"
I laughed uncomfortably. "Y-you do?" Was I stuttering now? Yes, yes I was.
Jess stood up and closed some the distance between us.
"I know we have to talk about what happened, and before you say it, I know it was wrong. I know it was wrong when you kissed me."
I nodded, and kept eye contact the best I could. My heart was hammering in my chest all over again. She took another step closer and put her hands on my shoulders. I couldn't take it.
"I know it was wrong, but I don't care. In the moment it felt so perfect. I wanted it to happen so bad. I was in denial. I didn't think you had it in you to kiss me." There was a pause as she studied my face for any kind of reaction. I was sweating now.
I swallowed and tried to convey what I was feeling the best I could. I tried to take it slow and pick my words wisely, but I did not have the chance. She spoke first.
"When Brandy kissed you, it stirred something up inside of me. I was so jealous. I didn't think I would be... I don't know what came over me."
I nodded in agreement. I don't know how I would feel if another guy kissed Jess in front of me, and I didn't really want to find out either. I found the words to speak, finally.
"What happened in the movie room was obviously wrong, we are brother and sister. We both know this..." Jess frowned slightly, and her eyes started to get red. "...But it felt right to me. I couldn't control myself." I wiped my forehead. "I didn't want to kiss Brandy. I think it's obvious what I wanted to happen and who I wanted to kiss."
I paused, again looking for the right words, then started talking again, a futile attempt to keep the anxiety in check.
"It's impossible for me to look at you like just a sister anymore after that."
Jess looked up, averting her gaze for a moment, but it was easy to see what I was saying was penetrating her emotional barrier she had put up. Her body language and mannerisms were telling me she was feeling much the same way.
"Chris..."
She was struggling to make eye contact with me at this point, and to be honest, I don't know If I wanted her to. I had to get my thoughts out.
"...I'm not done Jess, listen to me. The reaction I had in the movie room, it was not just physical, it was emotional as well. I really felt something. I feel nuts for saying it."
I coughed and looked at the ceiling. My mouth was so dry, the anxiousness of the situation was starting to take a firm grip over me.
"Please... please, Jess. Please tell me you feel the same way." I managed to get stammer out.
Jess sniffed and stood up, pacing around my chair in a full circle, slowly, chewing her thumb nail. After three full complete revolutions, she stopped and looked at me again with her hands on her hips.
"I felt something too." She chewed her lip after she spoke.
I felt like my heart was full to bursting when she said that. I know it was hard for her to say, and even harder to admit to herself. I wanted to jump up and kiss her right then, but I held off, I had to.
"This is real, right? Me and you? It feels crazy."
She was still looking into my eyes, unblinking. Her beautiful face, her hair, everything about her in that moment was perfect to me. I could feel my hands start to shake in anticipation of her answer.