This is a continuation of my previous story "The Jocasta Society". If you haven't read it, it would benefit you to read that story first.
Like my other story, this is a slow burner. Yes there is some sex, but my emphasis is on the development of why and how the main characters came to the situation they are in, and what they'll do about it. Thanks in advance.
NOTE: On the first posting I uploaded the wrong version that had 'italic' mistakes, throughout. I thought I had proofread better. I apologize for this error.
In front of Madeline I confessed what transpired with Seth and me, interwoven with moments of giddiness from describing the pleasure he'd given me, and moments of tears from the doubt and guilt I felt. What had I done to Seth? Whatever made me think this was right? What would happen now? Have I traumatized him for life? Then the tears would subside as the thoughts of how he made me feel loved and attractive once again, something I hadn't felt in years. Thoughts of what he did to me sexually. How erotic it all was. Thoughts of what it was doing to me mentally. Then the tears would come again.
"Sara, it's normal to have the up and down emotions, but you haven't done anything wrong. I know you think you've broken some law of nature, but you haven't. What you two experienced was the most beautiful thing. It feels wrong because society has made it feel so wrong."
"I just can't get it. No matter what I think is good about it all, no matter how good and right it felt, the thought of it being the worst thing I could ever do, that I could ever do to Seth, keeps blocking everything else."
"But, Sara, Seth wanted it first. How could it be wrong, if Seth wanted it too? You did not force the feelings he had for you on to him."
"Didn't I? He's just a kid! My kid! I should protect him, not use him for my own demented desires!"
Maddy came and sat in front of me at my feet, holding my hands. "Sara, let me have you talk to some women from the Society. They're the elders of our Region. One of them is a psychologist. She can explain it much better than I can." I nodded my head to agree to her offer. What could it hurt? I stood and gave Maddy a hug as she told me she would contact me as soon as she heard when the women could meet with me.
The walk back to the cabin, a mere five minute stride, seemed to take an hour as my thoughts bounced around the inside my head like a little ball on a roulette wheel. The panicky feeling I felt when I left Maddy's resided as I walked until I opened the door to the cabin and saw Seth. The overwhelming doom I felt earlier returned.
"Hey." I said.
"Hey. Everything alright?"
"Yeah. I just went down to Maddy's."
"And?"
"I just... I was just talking to her..." He knew what we talked about. What else could it have been?
"What did she have to say?"
"She was happy. Happy... for us."
"Good. Good." Seth's voice tapered off in resignation.
"Seth. Are we OK?"
"Yeah. Yeah we are fine. We are great." He walked over and placed his hands on my upper arms. "I love you."
"I love you too, honey. I just don't think we... should have done it."
"Why? Why? It was amazing! It was wonderful! Was it something I did? Did I do something wrong? If it's about what I did to your backside with my mouth-"
"No! No baby." I cut him off trying to assure him, finding that what he thought was the problem to be sweet. "No, it's not that. THAT was amazing."
"Then what is it?"
"Seth... you KNOW what the problem is. You know."
There was a long pause. Seth moved away from me, trying to hide his expression. He then turned back to me, frustration in his voice.
"I don't care. I don't. I don't give a fuck what the world thinks. The world is fucked up as it is. All I know is I've had these feelings for so long. I've never wanted anyone as much as you."
"Baby... baby I know but... you know as well as I do, what we did was wrong. It was wrong by all accounts. It's not natural, not to mention illegal. We could go to prison for what we did."
"Mom that's where the Society comes in-"
"Fuck that Society! I keep hearing from you and Maddy how this Society is going to be the savior of us all. How the fuck is this Society going to help us? It seems all it has done is wrapped us up in this perverted-"Seth held his hand up to stop my rant.
"If it was so perverted, so wrong, then why, WHY did you do it? You came to ME last night. You know you wanted to do it. You wanted it like me! Tell me you didn't want it. One minute it's all you want and the next we're the greatest abomination to mankind! Which is it?! Look me in the face and tell me you don't want me!" I began to tear up again. I tried to speak but all I could do was choke on my words.
"I can't. I can't baby." I leaned my head into Seth's chest as he wrapped his arms around me. "I do want you. I do. I'm just not supposed to want you like that." Seth cradled my head tight against his chest as I sobbed loudly. He rocked me softly, patting back.
"It's OK. It's all OK." Seth attempted to soothe me as best he could. He led me to the bedroom, where I at first assumed his intent was to initiate sex, but he told me to lie down on the bed and close my eyes. He covered me with a blanket and said for me to get some rest.
About an hour later I was awakened by the sound of Seth in the kitchen. I got out of bed and found he'd prepared lunch. He wasn't much of a cook, but was able to muster up a couple of grilled cheese sandwiches and bowls of tomato soup. I rubbed my face to assist in waking me up and sat down at the table as he poured a couple of glasses of milk.
"You know I'm no gourmet. Best I could come up with." I smiled as he sat down across from me at the small table. I picked up one of the sandwich halves and it reminded me that Seth's father, Stephen, loved grill cheese and this in turn made me question where he fit in this conundrum. I knew if he found out he would kill me. He'd bring the wrath of Hell down upon me, not to mention how he'd ostracize Seth for the rest of his life. I could only imagine his reaction, which no matter how brutal, would be justified.
"Something we haven't brought up this whole time, even from the first time it was mentioned, is your father."
"I've wondered about it. You know, it's no secret you two aren't close anymore." I hated that Seth was aware of how his father and I were distant, but how could he not know?
"That's beside the point, Seth. Can you even begin to imagine what he'll do when he finds out?"
"He can never find out, mom." That was obvious, but I knew Seth wasn't considering the magnitude of this situation. "Will you divorce him?"
"What? No! I'm not going to divorce him." I covered my forehead with the palm of my hand. "I don't know. I just don't fucking know."
"How will we... I mean... will we just try to keep it a secret?"
"Seth... you're assuming this is going to continue, and-." With that Seth slammed his spoon down against the table top and stood up. My response was to shudder, as this was not usual for Seth.
"Dammit! Are we or aren't we? One minute you want to and the next you're crying that it's some horrible thing!" He ran his hands through his hair as he turned toward the sink. "FUCK! JUST FUCK IT ALL!!!"
And with that he stomped off to his bedroom, slamming the door.
I sat there, staring into space. Again my eyes teared up. He was right. Last night I was all over him. Yes, I was hesitant at first, but once we started, I couldn't get enough. I wanted all of him I could get. It was the most aroused I'd been in years, possibly ever. Lying in bed afterwards I felt so serene. I wanted to lie next to him forever. I got up with a smile, and couldn't wait to tell Maddy. But once I heard myself saying the things he and I had done, it stirred up all the doubts and concerns I had been previously feeling and began to overcome me like a tidal wave. He had a point: were we or weren't we? Was I in or out? Did I leap without thinking, or did I finally just succumb to the inevitable? I had to make a decision, and live with it.
I had moved to my bedroom, which had huge windows on three sides that overlooked the woods, and sat in chair, weighing everything. The snow started to fall again in small white specks that slowly floated down to the ground. I became almost hypnotized watching it when my cell phone rang. It was Maddy.
"Hey Maddy."