That Girl Next Door

***Legal Disclaimer***

The following is entirely a work of fiction. Any similarity to real persons, alive or deceased, including but not limited to names and/or personal descriptions is purely coincidental. Nothing in this story is intended to be defamatory or metaphorical. This work was produced entirely with the intent to entertain the reader. Nothing more. All characters in this story are assumed to be at least 18 years old at the time the story takes place. This is an original work of fiction and the author retains all rights to it. I want to emphasize again that THIS IS

FICTION

. Therefore, the aeronautical instruction and checklists are NOT intended for actual use. They are there only to add flavor to the story. Limited license is granted to 'Literotica' for publication according to their requirements and conditions. Copyright © 2022 by Scottish Texan.

***Acknowledgments***

My sincere thanks to shakna, NWX217, Sinthet, and Lady_Lierin for their valuable time, suggestions, and for just putting up with me in general. Editorial credit goes to NWX217. Thanks, buddy!

***Preface***

This is the second installment of a multiple chapter story. It is not written to stand alone and the author strongly suggests that you start at the beginning in [Chapter One] before reading any further. Travel at your own risk! Also, I would like to note that I made a change to the story that was not reflected in the first version of Chapter One. I originally put the main character in a Cessna Skyhawk, Model 172M. During the writing of this chapter, I felt compelled to upgrade him to a Cessna Skylane Model 182R instead. Once I complete the rewrite of Chapter One and it replaces the current version, those changes will no longer be evident.

In order to help the reader picture the various characters in this chapter in their own minds, think about Robert Urich when he was about 25 years old as Jason. Think of twenty year old Jennifer Connelly (as she appeared in Career Opportunities) to play his sister Jessica. Think of Emily VanCamp at eighteen years old (as she appeared in Everwood) to play Melanie. And finally, Rebecca would be played by Carol Decker of the musical group T'Pau (see the music video for 'Heart & Soul').

_______

***Chapter Two***

...Melanie's brain finally gained purchase and rebooted, but even so she let her hand remain inside of Jessica's panties. She was surprised with herself. She found that touching her best friend in this intimate manner was very pleasant. It somehow brought them closer, bonding them in a special way. Jessica's girl juices had a soft silky smoothness that in itself was pleasing to the touch. But the situation at hand

HAD

to be addressed.

"

FUCK, JESSICA

! What the fuck was that? What in the hell did we just do? What in the hell have you done to me?" Melanie slowly withdrew her hand from Jessica's underwear as Jessie quickly rolled off of the bed and retreated to her desk chair. She was suddenly afraid of the consequences for her brash decision. She was deathly afraid that Melanie was going to storm out of the room right now. Melanie may even cease to communicate with her and end their friendship reaching back twelve years or more.

Melanie stood up and began pacing the room. She assumed her 'thinking pose' as she walked back and forth, placing her thumb under her chin and draping her index finger across her upper lip. She did not immediately realize that it was the same hand that was liberally coated in Jessie's cum until she simultaneously smelled the scent and felt the wetness on her upper lip. Her pacing suddenly came to a screeching halt.

'Okay...that doesn't actually smell bad at all,' Melanie thought to herself. She brought her fingers to her nose and inhaled deeply. While rubbing her thumb and finger tips together, she played with the cum. Almost as a knee-jerk reaction, she sucked on her fingers without actually intending to do it. "Mmm," she moaned. Realizing what she had just done, she was shocked with herself. But being no hypocrite, she also admitted, 'I like the taste too. It's light and heady. What the actual fuck?!'

"Oh my God, Jessie! You've turned me lesbian," Melanie said in a loud voice that was just short of shouting.

The thought struck Jessica funny for some reason. But in spite of her currently panicked state of mind, she giggled. "I'm not a lesbian and I'm pretty sure that you're not one either." Melanie jerked her gaze in her direction. This caused Jessica to bow her head and looked at her feet. She could not bring herself to look directly into her best friend's eyes after what she had just done to her.

"Oh, really?

Girlfriend?!

I just pushed my hand down inside of your underwear and I played with your pussy! Even more than that, I can't deny that I really had fun doing it! I can smell your cum on my upper lip right now, and I actually kind of like it! I just sucked my fingers clean of your cum and it tasted good to me. I could probably get used to the taste well enough to convince myself to try oral sex with you. So you tell me just how you figure that I am not turning lez right now?"

Jessica began to hope that she could salvage the situation. Melanie had not yet bolted out of the room and just now had opened up a dialog with her. With her heart blooming, Jessica addressed her new lover. "Let me answer that by killing two birds with one stone. When we were playing around just now, you said that you had someone specific in mind that you were saving your cherry for.

It's pretty obvious that this is your first girl on girl encounter judging by the way that you reacted just now. And just for full disclosure, I have never even so much as kissed another girl until just now. So that makes you my first girl too.

But getting back to your cherry, you are obviously saving it for some

guy

. Assuming that nothing has changed, that alone indicates that you're not a lesbian, so 'nuff said on that score! But here is where I need some answers of my own. You and I have

ALWAYS

shared all of our secrets with each other.

ALWAYS.

But this is the first time that you have ever mentioned that you have made specific plans concerning your virginity. So,

Girlfriend!

Who is the guy? Hmmm?"

The room grew very quiet for a moment. You could have heard a pin drop. Melanie assumed the classic 'deer caught in the headlights' look. The gears shifted and clicked in her head, giving her a response to try and deflect the subject. "I can say the same for you, dear. You just revealed the same secret that you have not shared with me either. So you tell me who your guy is and I'll tell you mine!"

Jessica looked down and stared at her feet again mumbling something that Melanie could not quite make out.

"Say again?" Melanie asked.

Jessica finally found the courage to look her best friend in the eye, but she didn't repeat exactly what she had just said word for word. "I said that I can't tell you because you will probably think I am a sick disgusting pervert and hate me for the rest of your life. I don't think that I could handle you hating me very well. My family would probably have to put me on a suicide watch if I lost you forever like that. You're my best friend in the whole wide world. Even more than that, you're the sister that I never had. Please don't make me tell you who I'm crushing on. Please..."

Melanie's brain was still firing on all cylinders at that moment. Adrenaline coursing through her system had her brain and senses hyperactive. The word 'pervert' triggered a thought. She had always just accepted Jessica's mood swings around her brother as something routine. But in a moment of sudden clarity, a very distinct possibility that she had never before considered suddenly crashed into her brain. She staggered over to the bed as if Jessica had suddenly hit her with a hard right-cross. Melanie moaned and sat down with a thump.

"Ooohhh! Oh no! Oh...My...Freaking...God! Oh no, Jessie! It's Jason, isn't it? You have a huge crush on your own brother!" Melanie looked her best friend in the eyes. It was quite obvious that she had just scored a bullseye. "Geezus! How long, girl?"

Jessica winced and didn't immediately answer. She was mortified that Melanie had correctly guessed her secret. For the moment, she tried to think of some way to push her best friend's thoughts in another direction, but events were unfolding too fast and none of this was in her original plan. Damage control was the only option at this point. Then she looked Melanie straight in the eyes and was surprised by what she saw. She found a look of sincere compassion. She could tell that Melanie was stunned, but she didn't see any signs of revulsion. Summoning more courage, she forged ahead.

Jessica sighed. "Several years at least. When I was twelve, I used to daydream about us getting married once we grew up. I have been crazy, stupid, head over heels in love with Jason for a long, long time. After this long, it isn't some silly phase that I am going through. That's pretty much what caused our fight a few minutes ago. But it gets more complicated than that. Jason loves me too. He is every bit, just as much in love with me as I am in love with him. He basically admitted it, but he's trying to

'do the right thing'

by me. I put it all together tonight when I opened up his gift. It just suddenly all made perfect sense to me. He moved away to go to college to get some distance between us. But here's the rub, he isn't just in love with me alone. There's also another girl that has his heart tied up in knots. Melanie, I know that you probably hate me now, but please don't leave me." Tears began to form in Jessica's eyes and one rolled down her left cheek.

"Fuck me sideways!" Melanie exclaimed. "Damn, girl!" Melanie paused for a moment to collect her thoughts. "Okay, I'm uh...[cough]. Okay, look. You and I are still good. This is shocking to say the least. It isn't enough to ruin my feelings for you. But damn it to hell, seducing me? I mean, I get the thing about you having the hots for your brother. I think that somewhere in the back of my mind I have always known. I should be surprised by it, but I'm really not."

"Really? The fact that I want my own flesh and blood brother to take my virginity doesn't make you want to puke your guts out? Think carefully, because it is deeper than that. I want to date my brother. I don't want him to just pop my cherry and walk away. I want to make love to him over and over again."

"No, hun. It's okay with me. I don't think that it is disgusting at all. Not in the very least. But I hope that

you

don't puke your guts out when I tell you that I actually find it kind of hot. If you're a pervert girl," Melanie sighed. "Then I guess we both are perverts. Okay, so here goes my confession...If I were to accidentally walk in on you and Jason en flagrante, I would most likely want to stay and watch you two going at each other. I'm the pervert because I would want to jill off while I watched you two making love to each other."

Melanie paused again to gather her courage. "I have another confession that I should probably get out there right now. Since we are getting deeper into this." Melanie took a deep breath, "I have already fantasized about you two being together whenever I masturbate. Let me clarify that it isn't my one and only fantasy that I jill to, but I have used it many times. So if you two ever do it for real, please don't keep it a secret from me. Hook up with me afterwards and give me all of the juicy details. Please?"

"So, you don't hate me? You would really be okay if I committed incest with my own brother?"

"Yes babe, we're good. Like I said, I actually find the thought of you and Jason screwing each other really hot. I can totally get off on it...and I already have actually, truth be told." Melanie started thinking about her own feelings for Jason. Her heart began to ache something fierce. "So, this other girl...Jason is still pining for Rebecca, huh?"

"Uuuhhh...no. Not her."

"Oh, come on. Who else besides her could possibly make him turn his head?"

Jessica focused her gaze on her best friend and just stared intently at her. Then she arched her left eyebrow.

After a few moments, Melanie connected the dots. "Don't you fuck with me, Jessie! This isn't funny at all! Don't you

dare

fuck with me!"

"Mel, honey. Stop for a moment and think about your birthday gifts. I know what Jason bought for Becky for the two birthdays when they were together. The first one, he gave her a $100.00 gift card for Dillard's. The next birthday, he gave her a Samsung Galaxy Tab A with an 8 inch screen. Not once has he bought her a gift that even comes close to what he spends on you or me."

"And you're sure about this? You're certain about our gifts not being costume jewelry?" Melanie looked at her feet for almost two minutes before she said anything else. "You're going to kill me, Jess. Oh, God! I'm am so dead right now."

"What did you do?"

"Nothing...at least not yet," Melanie sighed. She looked at her feet and cleared her throat. "Ahem, I have more secrets to share. Things that have scared me to death. Because just like you, I just couldn't go on if you and I... if we lost one another. I would fall totally apart if you started hating me. But if we're going to come clean after several years of this building up, I'm going to spill it all. There are things that I have wanted to tell you for years and years. I just could not find the courage to do it." Then she looked her best friend straight in the eye, "You and I have both chosen the same guy to give up our cherries to."

"NO! Really?" Jessica leapt from her chair and rushed Melanie. She saw the panic in Melanie's eyes as she grabbed her. Pushing her down on the bed, Jessica kissed her full on the lips. "That's fantastic!" Jessica grabbed Melanie around her back and pulled her close, this time french kissing her with passion.

Melanie was stunned a second time. This certainly was NOT the reaction that she was expecting from her best friend just turned lover. However, she was really getting into this kissing her best friend thing. Jessica's tongue was caressing hers for almost a full second until Melanie realized that she wasn't under attack as an enemy. Jessica was giving her love in spite of her revelation. She began moving her tongue in time with Jessica's, returning her affections and kissing her back. When she managed to break the kiss she gasped out, "You mean, you're not going to try and scratch my eyes out?"

Jessica snickered, accidentally causing a snot bubble to burst from her nose. "Ugh!" She grabbed a tissue from her night stand and cleaned her face. "No, babe. I'm not the least bit jealous of you. It's pretty obvious that you have figured out my secret now. So yes, I've been jealous of every single girl that caught my brother's eye. But I have never been jealous of you, ever. I never

would

be jealous of you, not in a million years! You are the one and ONLY girl that I would gladly share my brother with. I really mean it. Honestly. Cross my heart.

Think about it for a moment. When I attacked you a few minutes ago, I didn't do it out of lust. I've been crushing on you for a long time, too. Not as long as I have crushed on Jason, but still. When I first discovered that I really liked looking at naked girls, I realized that I had feelings for you similar to the ones that I have for my brother. Earlier, you said that you were worried about becoming a lesbian? Do you still have feelings for my brother after what we just did?"

"Hell yeah, obviously!"

"Okay, so explain this to me. If you love me and want to make love to me, and yet you are still in love with my brother and want to sleep with him too, how does that make you a lesbian? I'm bisexual, Mel. I have known for several years that I am bisexual. I have no doubt that I would prefer heterosexual sex with guys. But if the right girl comes along and I find her attractive, I'm totally down with jumping into bed with her. I can get a little bit girl crazy sometimes. I get totally turned on looking at Penthouse magazine. Some of those girls are totally hot! But as far as you are concerned, it goes one step even further than that. I love you, babe! I'm

in love

with you.

I know that this is all brand new to you, so you haven't had time to sort it out like I have. I first started to notice that I was attracted to some particular girls about 3 years ago." Jessica chuckled softly, "And before you even ask, the answer is 'Yes.' I do have a specific type of girl that I am attracted to. I have had 3 years to figure out exactly where I stand, sexually speaking. I know that you still need time to process all of this. But if you need me, I will be here for you and help you with your own feelings. I'm never going to break up with you and leave you, Mel. Never."

"And what if I decide that I am not really into girls at all," Melanie asked? "What if it comes down that I am only into you?"

"Hmmm," Jessica paused for a moment. "I never thought about that. But it is certainly a possibility. It just may work out to be that is how you are. A hetero girl in love with her best friend. It could happen. But here is the thing, we are both crazy about my brother, right?"

"Absolutely!"

"And you are totally okay with me making love to my brother?"

"Yes, I already said that...so where are you going with this?"

"The Three Musketeers, Mel. We put it all back together and be just as close as we once were. Closer than ever before even. How would you feel about having a threesome? A menage a troiś. You, me, and Jason together at the same time. Does that trip your trigger?"

"Whaaaat?"

"You, me, and Jason. All three of us naked and rolling around in the same bed molesting each other. I'm totally down with it. I've even fantasized about frenching you while Jason's fucking your brains out."

"Okay...uh, I don't think that I would want that every single day. But once or twice a month might be okay. Maybe more often? I don't know. This is all so new to me. I'm not sure how to answer."

"Let me ask you this in another way then. We both are in love with my brother. We have established that as a fact. So where do we go from here? What are we supposed to do about this situation? The obvious answer is that you and I have to be okay with sharing him. Since I am his sister, he and I will definitely have to keep our relationship totally secret from everyone else in the world. We have to keep our love for each other hidden from the rest of humanity, especially the parents. But there is no reason whatsoever that you and Jason can't actually be a couple in open public, right?"

"Yeah, so? Where are you going with all of this, Jessie?"

"My God, this opens up so

MANY

possibilities that I had never considered before! Mel, honey...are you okay with sharing a boyfriend with me? Totally and completely with no conditions? Both of us dating and sleeping with the same guy. Most of the time separately, but sometimes together?"

"Let me get this straight. If I understand what you are getting at, you and I are both going to become Jason's little harem? We both share him equally? With everything, including sex. But what about what just happened between the two of us tonight? Do we just forget that it ever happened? I mean, I'm shocked at what we just did and all. But just sitting here with you right now, I feel the urge to wrap my arms around you and kiss you some more. So are you and me just this one time thing?"

"No, babe! Of course not! I'm not only going to share my brother with you, but I am going to share

you

with my brother as well. You and I will get time to be alone with each other once in a while just like you and Jason will. And I'll get alone time with Jason every now and then too! The three of us are going to become one family together. Ever since we were kids, this is what we were destined to be. Okay, maybe I'm projecting...but I hope that you feel the same as I do. You always made me feel like you and I were thinking along the same lines. We have always been in synchrony together."