"Would you fuck me, if you had the chance?"
I actually choked on my drink! The question had come out of nowhere from Amy, my sister-in-law sitting across the table from me. She was the wife of my younger brother Wayne, and they had been married for a couple years now.
Amy was an energetic, cheery, blue eyed blond beauty. She was 21, about 5'1" with smaller breasts with a perfect ass that was most often flaunted in yoga pants that showed every curve. Despite being my brother's wife, she had been in my spank-bank for a long time. I was 32, and had been faithfully married for 9 years. The last 5 of which were pretty much just two people living together, with no real spark at all. My wife Trish and I were out for drinks with Amy and my brother Wayne, who was at the bar getting drinks and Trish had gone to the restroom...
"Uh, I..." I struggled to say anything, I was so caught off guard. I'd never had any girl be so forward with me!
"I let Wayne fuck my friend Brandi, so he said I could pick one person to fuck too. I thought maybe you?" she said.
Just as I started to try to formulate an answer, my wife Trish came back and sat beside me.
"What's up with you? Your face is red..."
Trish was a pretty brunette, about 5'7", but spent a little too much time on the couch and was around 30 pounds overweight.
"I just took a drink down the wrong tube," I said, as Amy stifled a giggle across the table from me. My brother came back shortly with drinks and we all settled into conversation as I tried to get my head around what I had just heard.
'Did she really just say that??' I thought, 'did she really MEAN that??' The rest of the evening Amy seemed to delight in keeping me flustered by sneaking me sexual gestures with her hands and mouth when neither Wayne nor Trish could see. I tried to pay attention to conversation and act "normal" but I had trouble hiding my constant state of arousal.
As we said goodnight, Amy hugged Trish then gave me a brief hug pressing herself tightly against me. She could feel my hardness against her and gave a light giggle that only I could hear, before breaking away and saying goodnight.
When we got home, Trish went straight to bed while I stayed up to watch tv. My cock was hard again thinking about Amy's words earlier. As I pictured her naked I pulled my cock out and slowly began to stroke it. I imagined what it would be like to look down at her as I fucked her, with her gorgeous legs wrapped around my waist. It only took a few strokes before I was cumming as hard and as much as I ever had. My wife and I didn't have much of a sex life, probably less than once a month and only missionary with the lights out, so to say I get pent up is an understatement!
Fast-forward about a month. I hadn't seen my brother or Amy after that night but had since been consumed with thoughts of fucking my little sister-in-law. It was a chilly afternoon and I was doing some yard work in prep for winter, when my phone buzzed. It was my brother Wayne texting to see if I had a some tools that I could lend him. I text back that I did, and he replied that he was at work until the next morning so Amy would bring his truck out to pick them up.
My pulse immediately quickened. I didn't know what to expect when she showed up, as I hadn't seen her since that evening. We had all been a little buzzed, so I hoped this wouldn't be awkward. Above all, my cock was instantly engorged thinking of her tight little ass and gymnast like body. I tried to stay busy until she arrived and dug out the tool box and the tools from the shed. Amy pulled in about an hour later and jumped out to say hi, acting like any normal sister-in-law should.
I thought 'does she not even remember what she said?' I was a little relieved, maybe a little more disappointed, but I dropped her tailgate and threw the tool box into the back. She thanked me and headed back to the truck door. As she grabbed the door handle she paused, and turned to me.
"Where's Trish?"
"She's in the house watching tv, as usual" I told her.
"I see... so?"
"Hmm?" I answered.
"You didn't answer my question, would you?"
"Umm, would I what?" I asked. She looked up at the house, probably making sure that we couldn't be seen from any of the house windows, then smirked and walked up to me, putting her arms around me and pressing her body against me.
"I asked if you'd fuck me if you had the chance. Well? Now's your chance." I couldn't even respond but my hands quickly ran down her back and grabbed her tight, sexy ass. She brought her gorgeous lips up to mine and we were soon in a deep hungry kiss as I held her ass and ground my cock into her. She broke the kiss, smiling sexily.
"I take that as a yes?"
"Fuck yes!" I couldn't believe this gorgeous little bombshell wanted anything to do with me.
"Should we get in the truck? It's a little chilly out here," she said.
"Sure" I said, glancing nervously at the house. She got in the drivers side and I in the passengers side. I was trying to talk some sense into my self, but having a hard time finding a downside. Amy didn't give me time to debate right or wrong, as she came across the bench seat and began kissing me, her hand immediately finding and fondling my cock through my jeans.