StepDaughter's Plan Pt3
Maddy asked, "So, how do we tell Mom? I don't mean just about us eating each other out, but that we can't keep our legs together around you, John?"
Both girls looked at me.
"What? Tell your mom, are you crazy?" I said.
"John, you don't expect to sneak around behind her back all the time, do you? That's crazy; she would eventually find out anyway." Meg said.
Maddy said, "Don't forget Meg, you are not allowed to spread those luscious creamy thighs of yours and show John your sweet little pink cunt unless I say you can, got it bitch?"
"Yes, Maddy, I will make it up to you for being such a bitch to you and Tasha, I promise," Meg said shyly.
Listening to the girls discuss how to tell their mom, my wife Amy, that I was screwing them or more, they were fucking me silly, the reality of what had gone on the past few days came crashing down on me. What was I thinking? That's just it; I wasn't thinking; my cock was doing all the thinking. Christ, I was in some deep shit here.
Amy and I had been in the lifestyle for a few years, and one of our rules was we were never to sneak around behind each other's backs; not only was I doing that, but I was doing it with her two daughters and at the same time no less.
"John? John, are you listening?" Maddy said.
That snapped me out of my thoughts, and I tried to refocus on the issue at hand. Damn it, why are these girls so damn beautiful, especially sitting here completely naked?
"John, I think we should be upfront and tell Mom that we love you and are sexually attracted to you just like Mom is; she can't get mad about that," Maddy said.
Meg chimed in sarcastically, "What do you think, John? I think Mom will blow a fuse. Wonder if she will be madder at you, John, for sticking your big cock in her sweet innocent daughters ("making air quotes with her fingers when she said innocent) or at us for not being able to keep our legs together around you."
I said, "Oh, she is going to be extremely mad at me; one of our rules, when we started swinging, was, NO playing without both of us being there."
As the words came out of my mouth, I knew I was divulging too much, but I couldn't stop my mouth.
Meg stood up and slapped the table, which caused her big full titties to jiggle, and then said, "I knew it. I knew you and Mom fucked around with others. Jane has hinted to me that I would be surprised how open-minded my mom is sexually."
Maddy looked at me with a slight scowl on her face.
"You and Mom fuck other people? Is Mom bisexual? I mean, it would explain why Meg and I love eating pussy." Maddy asked.
Maddy was standing now, and her sweet little pink snatch was at eye level; my cock did not let it go without reacting. Between realizing I was in a world of hurt with Amy and looking at my two gorgeous young naked stepdaughters, I was tongue-tied.
I started wondering what Amy was going to be most upset about, fucking behind her back, fucking her daughters behind her back, or that I had told her daughters that she was bisexual and that we explored the swinger lifestyle.
"John, are you going to answer?" Maddy said, very forcefully.
"Listen, girls, oh what the hell. Yes, your mom is bisexual, and yes, we are open to sharing each other with the right couples, OK?" I said.
Maddy laughed and said, "Wow, you go, mom."
"Meg, mom, is such a horny badass," Maddy said to her sister Meg.
Meg was still processing this new info when she asked, "So have you two fucked Jane? Brent too?"
I just looked at Meg and smiled.
Meg said, "fuck I knew it. She knows way too much about Mom's body AND yours, for that matter. Jane would say things to me like, I am sure he has a nice fat cock. She knows you have a fat cock first hand. She always asked me if I was attracted to you, and if I wasn't, I should be. That sneaky bitch."
Since I was sure Amy was going to be castrating me when she got home and found out about the girls and me, I spilled all the beans.
"Meg, Brent doesn't know that Jane spends nights with us when he is out of town, and you two are at your dad's house, so you need to keep that a secret," I said.
Meg, laughing, said, "Shit, I should have been able to figure that out. Every time Brent went out of town, you and Mom made Maddy and me stay at Dad's. I would ask Jane if I could stay with her instead, and she always had some excuse as to why I couldn't. She was here getting fucked by you and eating out my mom. That horny bitch."
Maddy honestly looked stunned with the information she was finding out about her mom. I couldn't tell if she was impressed with her mom or if she thought less of her mom now.
"Maddy, are you OK, sweetheart?"I asked.
"I don't know what to think of all of this, to be honest. I think all of this was a huge mistake, and my horny pussy and desire to give you my virginity may have ruined our family." Maddy said.
Maddy's eyes were filling with tears, and she was starting to shake as she stood in front of me naked. Her perfect perky tits were jiggling as she stood there, trying to make heads or tails of our situation.
Meg moved over to her and hugged her. Watching Meg with her spectacular naked body cuddling her tall, lean naked sister, my cock immediately jumped to attention. Fuck, what is wrong with me, I thought.
Meg said, "Maddy, I will take care of all of this, OK? Don't you worry? I know exactly what to do; I will tell Mom it is all my fault."
Maddy, still trembling, said, "How do you see that happening, Meg?"
Meg said, "I will tell mom that I know about her and Jane, and I made John fuck you. I was sick of hearing about you being a virgin, and I fucked John because I am a slut. John didn't want to, but I told him if he didn't, I would tell Brent, John has been fucking his wife, and so has our mom."
I looked at Meg in a different light all of a sudden. Maybe there really was a sweet girl inside the fantastic body of hers.
Maddy laughed through her tears and said, "mom will see right through that, Meg. Mom knows about my crush on John. Hell, she has walked in on me fucking myself with little John. And trust me, she knew right away what it was I had buriend in my spread open legs."
Now my head was spinning. Amy knew Maddy was fucking herself with a copy of my cock, and she didn't stop her or bother to tell me? Well, not telling me was probably for the best, come to think of it, I thought, which caused me to chuckle a bit too loud.
"What's so funny, John," Maddy said.
"Well, your mom has been telling me for several years that you had a crush on me. I told her she was silly; you were just a sweet young girl that liked to flirt. Your mom clearly knew more than she was letting on. Especially if she had seen you masturbating one time with the copy of my cock." I said.
Maddy's face perked up, and she said, "Oh, it wasn't just one time she caught me. I wanted her to see me fucking myself with your cock, and moaning out your name. I made sure she walked in on me."
Meg was still holding Maddy loosely in her arms. Then she pointed at my cock and said, "Maddy, look, no sense in stopping now, right? Mom will be upset whether we let John fuck us one more time or thirty more times."
Maddy looked down at my cock, which had grown to its full length as I listened to Maddy tell Meg about wanting her mom to see her masturbating with the copy of my cock.
Maddy smiling now, said, "Sister, I like your thinking; we can deal with the mom issue in four days when she comes home. Until then, I plan on getting fucked until I can't walk."
Maddy walked over to me and straddled me. Looking down at me, she said, "What do you think, Daddy, do you want some more of my tight young cunt? It is hot and wet for your big fat cock."
She reached down and aimed my cock at her opening, and just as she started to lower herself, Meg said, "Hey, what about me? Let's take this party up to bed. Maddy, you can ride that big cock, and John can eat my cunt at the same time, hopefully making me squirt again while seeing stars."
Maddy jumped off of me, and I watched my two naked stepdaughters as they headed for the stairs, holding hands and giggling as they went. When they got to the stairs, they both turned and looked at me and said in unison, "you coming, your daughters need some loving from their daddy."
My cock was in control now; if it weren't, I would have stopped myself, but like Meg said, Amy was going to be madder than a wet hen whether the girls and I fucked one more time or thirty more times.
The girls continued upstairs, and I took a few minutes to clean up the kitchen. Putting the food away and then heading up to have some fun with my two horny stepdaughters. When I got to the stairs, my phone rang, and it was Amy.
"Hello babe, is everything OK?" I asked.
"John, you know how we have that rule of only playing with others when we are both together?" Amy said.
My first thought was, Oh shit, she knows about the girls and me, but odd, she is asking about our only playing together rule.
"Yeah," I said.
"Well, Jill has implied she would like to explore further than what we did back in college. Would it bother you if she and I played around this week? If you say no, I will wait until the three of us can play together," Amy said.
Amy was in Tahoe with her three closest friends from school; all of them were cheerleaders together back in the day. Sarah, Clare, and Jill, Jill being one of Amy's closest friends. They both went to the same college and explored their bisexuality with each other back in the day. Amy said it never progressed past much more than kissing, caressing, and some sucking of each other's tits. But now, it sounded like Jill was open to exploring further. I am sure Amy was hot to trot, as Jill was precisely the type of female Amy lusted after, sexy petite brunette with big breasts and curves in all the right places.
Jill is a knockout; she could be Selma Hayek's twin sister. She is a real Latina hottie. Jill has never married; she enjoys her independence is all I could figure. Over the years, she has spent a lot of time with Meg and Maddy, and they refer to her as Aunt Jill.
"Sure, babe, it is fine with me, but you know I am going to want to hear all about it when you get home. Photos too if you have them," I said with a laugh.
"You horny bastard, and of course, I will tell you all the details. Oh, I already have some yummy photos of Jill, but you will have to wait to see those; I don't want you hurting yourself while I am away," Amy said, laughing.
Then she said, "Need to go; Jill just walked out to the hot tub naked. Babe, her figure is even more beautiful now than when she was nineteen. Got to go, oh, you have fun too and don't feel guilty, it's all good, enjoy yourself." Click the phone line went dead.
