My sister, nearly in tears, had buried her face in my chest.
"Is something wrong with me, Tony?" she asked between shaky breaths. I held her as we sat on her bed together, patting her shoulder, comforting her like a big brother should.
"No, Emma, no. There's nothing wrong with you. So you're attracted to women, too? You experimented a little? So have millions of others like you. There's nothing wrong or right about it. It just is."
"But the Church says—"
I cut her off, gently. "Now come on, sis. You and I agreed before that the Church has no business telling anyone what to think about any of this. Not with their record. You're not going to buy into that now, are you?"
"But Mom and Dad do. What if they find out?"
"But that's not going to happen, is it? You don't have to tell them anything. They'll never hear about it from me, I promise you. Unless you want to tell them, and then I'll stand beside you all the way."
I had come back to visit my family home to try to explain to everyone why I was not going to be married anymore, after five years with Dianna. As if I understood it myself.
And now I had walked into a different crisis. It would have been almost a relief from my own, were it not my baby sister in distress.
"Look," I continued, "not saying you should necessarily, but suppose you decide you like guys more. You're going to have plenty to choose from this fall. Then this never has to come up at all. Only you and I will know, and I would rather die than reveal a secret of yours.
"Yeah I know, you'll have plenty of women to choose from too. If you want to date them, and you want to be open and honest with the world about it, that's the time you will want to tell Mom and Dad, and I will be with you. You just call me. The world is changing, Emma, and even they will have to admit it's for the better. Don't give up on them. You might be surprised."
She sighed and lifted her head to look at me. Her curly blonde hair fell back to the sides, revealing the beginnings of a smile returning. "You make too much sense, Tony. It's hard for a girl to get a good cry going. Thank you. You are the best brother anyone could ask for."
Then she leaned in to kiss me quickly on the lips, in her familiar way. It was always just a quick peck, a sweet sisterly gesture. I think she started doing that when she was thirteen and I had just graduated from college. Maybe it was at my wedding. But now she was eighteen and this time was different.
This time she kissed me for long seconds, as her soft lips bloomed against mine.
When she pulled back, she said, "I'm sorry Tony, I didn't mean to do that, I mean, I did mean to kiss you, but I guess I must have been thinking of someone else. Don't think I'm bad, please."
"It's all right, sis," I told her. "I can imagine your feelings being all mixed up right now. I remember being your age. It was simpler for me, but I was still a mess sometimes, just over which girl I wanted to go out with. Don't sweat it, and I won't."
"Okay, big brother. Thanks again. I'm gonna stay here and think things over some more. See you at dinner?"
"Sure."
I got up, releasing her from the embrace I suddenly realized I had kept her in for a good minute. I gave her a quick wave at the doorway, left her bedroom and walked down the upstairs hallway toward my own. How could I explain to anyone, even myself, why her kiss had started a flame burning inside me? Should I ask the world not to think I was bad?
I've loved her since the day she was born.
Dad woke me up that night before driving Mom to the hospital. It was one in the morning and I was supposed to stand watch over the house while they were gone. What I was going to do if anything happened during the night was a mystery to me. I was nine. I suppose they wanted to feel like someone was there, and I was the oldest.
So I sat at the venerable, scarred oak dining table and played the radio, softly, and read some. When I tired of reading for a bit, I tuned across the AM band and listened for stations from far away. They were distinguished by the way they would fade in and out, sometimes slowly, sometimes so rapidly, like a guitar tremolo, that I could hardly make out what the program was. Sometimes two or three stations could be heard on the same frequency, their programs mixing together into a jumble, with strange whistling sounds that I later learned were caused by the mixing of their waves with those on adjacent frequencies. It was a thrill when a station identified itself as being two, three, four states, or even half the continent away.
The sun was up, the signals had faded out, and I had gone back to reading when Dad returned.
"Mom hasn't delivered yet," he said, and was gathering up some things to take back with him.
My brothers were up, having been awakened by the sun and Dad's arrival. There was Matt, eight, and Scott, six, both with Mom's blond hair. They came downstairs and looked at me, silently questioning.
"Mom's at the hospital having her baby," I said. "Dad had me stay up all night and watch for you guys."
"What for?" asked Matt.
"I guess if you got sick or something, I don't know."
"I hope we have a sister. There are enough of us boys," said Scott.
"You think you should have been a girl?" Matt taunted him.
"No, butthead.
You
should have been a girl."
"All right, knock it off, you guys," I said, exercising my great authority of nine years. "I'm going to take a nap. Try not to beat each other up and wake me up if you get sick or something."
Mom brought Emma home two days later. For the first time I was old enough to be allowed to hold a new baby. Mom showed me the right way to do it, making sure to support her head, and placed her onto my waiting arms.
She was the most beautiful thing I had ever seen. Her tiny face with its perfectly formed features, topped by a wisp of golden hair, almost made me shiver. I thought of this infant in my arms growing up to become a running, playing girl, then later a woman. I thought about myself having started out this way, as a bundle that would fit on someone's lap with room to spare. I was filled with awe for the few minutes I held her.
When she started walking, Mom and I would help her practice. Mom would stand her up on the living room carpet, Emma dressed in her pink onesie. I would sit on the floor five feet away and hold out my hands. She would let go of Mom's hands and start off, a little unsteadily, one step at a time, across the gap. When she reached me, she would grab my hands and laugh with joy. Once she started talking, she quickly learned all our names and would say, "Tohhhh-nee" when she reached for me.
Two years after she was born Mom and Dad gave her a sister, Janie. It was exactly like they decided she should have someone closer to her age to bond with, after six years since the last boy. I have often thought that the original coining of the phrase "don't ask, don't tell" was to describe the practical Catholic's attitude toward birth control. They may believe, as they are taught, that children are a gift from God, but many a couple, just between themselves, aren't shy about asking God to hold off just a bit with the next gift. Just a few years. What the Pope doesn't know won't hurt him.