Similiar But Not Exact

Jessica had figured out the scheme in the first month, and set up her plan the second month. When she was ready, she asked Tomas, her boyfriend, if his brother Emil could meet them on their lunch date.

Tomas and Emil were twin brother socialites from Barcelona, and they were both Jessica's lover, though they thought Jessica didn't know that. She'd met Tomas at an elite New York club, fucked him that night, and established herself as his live-in girlfriend, by virtue of that first mouthful of cum.

Tomas treated her well; champagne, jewelry, helicopter rides to Fire Island, the works. He introduced her to his twin brother Emil, and Emil and Jessica hit it off. A little harmless flirting, a good-natured joke asking how alike they really were, and the brothers exchanges a knowing glance that Jessica noticed, but pretended not to notice.

They pulled the switch a week later, and though Jessica didn't catch it the first time, by the fourth time, she had a list of distinct differences. So she made a plan, bought a couple supplies, and fucked them both a few more times each. Then she had lunch.

Emil joined Jessica and Tomas on the balcony of their apartment overlooking the Hudson. They were dressed for an evening of clubbing, Jessica in a short black dress and matching choker. "Hello Emil, please join us. I have a little announcement."

"Hola, Jess" said Emil, pronouncing it almost like 'yes'. He sat across from his brother and crunched a celery stick.

"So," said Jessica, leaning against the balcony railing. "I'll just cut straight to the point. I know Emil has been fucking me."

The twins sat up, startled, exchanging glances. Tomas said, "Que-", but Jessica held up a hand stopping him.

"Don't bother. I know." She counted on her fingers. "Emil has hairs on the bottom of his balls, and Tomas doesn't. Emil leads with his middle finger when he's got his hand down my pants, Tomas starts with the index. When he's fucking me from behind, Emil takes a handful of my hair at the scalp. Tomas makes an impromptu ponytail, and uses it like a leash."

The brothers were looking embarrassed. "And come on guys, did you really think I wasn't going to notice the freckly on Emil's right big toe? How many New York bimbos has this stunt worked on?

"We... we mostly do it in Espana..." Thomas mumbled.

"Well in America, there's a thing called 'rape by deception.'" Both brothers began to speak immediately, but Jessica held up her hand again. "Stop! Let me finish. First, I have proof, so don't bother thinking you'd win if it's 'he said, she said'." She showed them her phone. "Here's Emil, fucking me, recorded on a time-stamped feed from a mini camera I put on your bookshelf. And here's Tomas, at a nightclub eight blocks away. Did you impersonate your brother at that party, or did you sign for the champagne in your own name?"

The twins had become remorsefully silent. Emil muttered, "Este bruja, tienenos por los jeuvos..."

"Relax, boys," Jessica told them. "That's the stick. There's a carrot part too. Do you know what that means, the carrot and the stick?"

"Si. Yes," they both said.

"Alright them here's the carrot. We keep going just as we are, except everyone knows and consents. I'll fuck you, Tomas," Jessica ran her hand through her boyfriend's hair and pushed his head back as she walked behind him. "and I'll fuck you, Emil." She lightly scraped her fingernails down the back of her boyfriend's twin brother. Then she put her hands on each of their shoulders and turned them to face each other. "and occasionally, I'll fuck you both together."

The brothers grinned at each other. Jessica walked from the balcony to Tomas' bedroom, and sat upon a love seat at the end of the bed, and spread her arms across the footboard. She smiled back at the two of them. "Now let's see if you can handle that."

Emil and Tomas joined Jessica in the bedroom and sat on either side of her. They each put a hand on a thigh and groped at her, spreading her legs and raising her skirt up over her hips. Tomas kissed her as Emil licked her neck and earlobe.

Emil's hand went north, and pulled the top of her dress down, exposing her breasts. The dress bunched up below her hardened nipples. Tomas' hand went into her panties, and as she expected, he led with his index finger, touching at her clitoral hood and the folds of her pussy lips.

Jessica gasped in delight from the twins' attention. For the next hour or more, they worked to bring her to several orgasms; as one brother's stamina began to lax, he would step back and let the other take the bulk of the work. Jessica, meanwhile, was lost in a haze of cum, her head floating. She'd long since lost track of which brother was doing what.

She came on one cock thrusting into her from behind, as she sucked another. She came in the face of one brother as the other kissed her, and both fondled her breasts. She came on someone's fingers as one brother sucked her toes and the other sucked her nipples. She arched her back and came as the brothers held her aloft, one at her hips with his cock inside her, the other at he shoulders, enjoying her mouth.

Tomas laid down and Jessica, delirious with pleasure, rode his cock. He puller her down onto him, and they shared a deep kiss as Emil approached her from behind. He considered her asshole for a moment, and decided against the uninvited entry. He nudged his cock against his brother's where it entered Jessica's pussy. He took hold of her hips and lifted a little, and a gap appeared. He placed the tip of his cock, and pushed into Jessica's pussy, sharing the space with Tomas.

The brothers had never attempted this before, but they had discussed it. Like many aspects of their lives, they'd decided they were fine with sharing. Jessica, on the other hand, had not considered this possibility, and was overcome with the new sensation. The two cocks moving inside her touched different spots at different intervals, and her mind reeled to keep up with the input. And then, finally, something synced, and her pussy clenched them hard as she came again, harder than ever.

They carefully withdrew from her, and let her collapse onto her back, staring up at the ceiling in bliss. Tomas and Emil were close to cumming, and they stroked their cocks, pumping two loads out onto Jessica's tits. She weakly ran her fingers through the semen on her chest, still caught up in the rush. Finally, she managed to say, "Wow."

Tomas let his brother use the shower first, and settled in behind his girlfriend, letting her use his chest as a pillow. She dozed a moment, then woke up and looked into his eyes. "Which one are you?" she asked him.

"Thought you could tell," he replied, smiling.

"I'm not sure I even know MY name," she laughed.