Sibling Truth or Dare Club

The next morning I woke up tingly from head to toe. Did that really just happen? Did we watch a video with an incest scene? Did my brother cum in my mouth after? Am I a bad person? Is it too early to start drinking?

Probably. It's probably too early for a drink. But it's not too early for coffee.

Jeremy was getting a bowl of cereal as I walked into the kitchen.

"Morning."

"Oh hey. Morning."

"Jer?"

"Ya Ange?"

"Are we ok? Like after last night, do you hate me?"

"What? No. We're great. Everything is fine." He said as he walked over and gave me a kiss on the cheek and then sat down to eat his cereal."

I poured myself a bowl and then sat down across from him.

"So. Got any plans for the day?" I asked.

"Nope. You?"

"Nope. Um...would you be interested in seeing if Caleigh and Kyle are interested in a quick game this afternoon?"

"When are mom and dad coming home?"

"Not until later this evening. I got a text from mom this morning to say they should be home by 8 or so. So we have lots of time."

"OK sure. Are we going to tell them about last night?"

"Eventually. But not all right away. I have an idea. Just follow my lead."

"Ok. I need a shower first though."

"Ok, me too; you can go first."

* * * * *

"Hey! It's my favourite siblings!" Caleigh said, bursting with enthusiasm. "Wait, where's Jeremy?" Caleigh's keen eyes had noticed it was just me on the call.

"Good afternoon, fine lady," I replied. "Oh, he's just getting out of the shower, and I figured I'd jump on the call and get the pleasantries out of the way while he was finishing up. How's your weekend been?"

"Great! I was a little surprised to get a game request for the middle of the day, though."

"Ya, our parents are away until later this evening, so we thought it might be fun to see if the two of you were available for a game."

"We're always down for a game of Truth or Dare." Caleigh responded with a big grin on her face. "So...I have to ask. Did you complete your homework?"

"Yes! What the fuck, Caleigh!" I said, poorly attempting to sound upset about the dare. "That was the craziest movie I've ever watched. And I can't believe you made me watch it with my brother of all people. We've really been enjoying all these games of Truth or Dare, but that was some next-level stuff."

"Want to hear something even crazier about that movie? It's just a rumour, but it's still wild." Caleigh asked.

"How much crazier could it get?" I asked. I couldn't imagine it could get much more intense than that.

"You know the one couple in the movie that never really does anything with each other? There's a rumour going around that they are actually brother and sister in real life. Like the actors are siblings."

"Holy shit! That's super crazy. I'm not totally sure I believe that, but with how crazy the rest of the movie was, you never know."

Just as I finished saying that, Jeremy came and sat down next to me.

"What's so crazy?" Jeremy asked.

He didn't believe it. He said there was no way the filmmakers lawyers would ever let something like that happen.

"We ready to play?" Kyle asked.

"Whoa, someone's eager to get things moving." Caleigh said teasingly.

And so the game began. The first couple of rounds were all focused on what all of us thought about the movie. Jeremy and I commented on watching it for the first time, and Caleigh and Kyle told us why it was their favourite movie of all time.

Jeremy and I were playing it cool while describing our reaction to the movie. I could tell Caleigh felt she wasn't getting the answers from us that she wanted, so she just asked us directly.

"So, I have to ask. As siblings. Sitting next to each other on the couch. What did you think about the final scene?"

"It was a little awkward, but the actors were sexy enough, so I just tried to focus on them as actors and ignore the plot."

Caleigh sighed, and her eyes rolled back in her head. That wasn't quite the answer she was looking for. I almost laughed a little when she did that but managed to keep it together.

"Ok, let's get to some action. I didn't think this was a film club. I thought we were playing truth or dare. So, truth or dare Caleigh?" Before she even had a chance to respond, I interrupted her, "Dare it is! Great! Ok. I want to see those tits in action. Caleigh, I dare you to let Kyle tit fuck you for 5 minutes."

"Okay okay. Sheesh. Someone is eager to get right into the action. Dear, are you interested in fucking these perfect, beautiful, luxurious, pillowy soft tits with your rock hard cock?" Caleigh said to Kyle before whipping her head around and staring directly into the camera.

"You don't have to ask me twice." Kyle responded as he stood up and started removing his clothes. "I get the feeling I won't be needing these for the rest of the afternoon."

Caleigh had retrieved some oil from the bedside stand and began rubbing it all over her chest. Her tits were amazing! She laid down on her back, and Kyle straddled her stomach. He didn't need any time to work up to things as his erection was already in full force. Caleigh squeezed her perfect tits together, and Kyle worked the head of his cock back and forth through the middle of her chest. Tit fucking was never something that I was a huge fan of myself, but watching it was hot as fuck. I totally forgot to set the timer, but Kyle wouldn't have lasted the whole five minutes anyway. He started bucking his hips wildly and yelled out that he was cumming as he splattered Caleigh's chin and face before rolling off and laying beside her for a few minutes to catch his breath.

After taking a few minutes to clean up, they were both back in front of the camera.

"OK, little miss, eager beaver," Caleigh sneered. "Your turn, truth or dare?"

"I'll take a dare." I stated confidently.

"Well, I guess I won't make you let your brother tit fuck you as a form of revenge." Caleigh stated as I felt a surge of electricity run through my pussy at the mere thought. "I do want to see your tits, and you are going to play with them for us. I dare you to massage, suck on, pinch, twist, and anything else that feels good, your tits for 5 minutes. If you're able to make yourself cum by just touching your tits, I'll give you a little bonus that will be worth your effort."

"Is that all you got?" I responded confidently. Maybe I shouldn't poke the bear, but the bantering back and forth was one of the best parts of the game.

I pulled my shirt over my head, revealing that I wasn't wearing a bra. I figured why put it on when I got out of the shower. I had hoped the girls were going to come out to play during this game and I was not disappointed. I began kneading my tits with both hands. Working them as best I could. I lifted my left tit up to my mouth and sucked on my nipple. Then I decided to see if I could fit both nipples in my mouth at the same time. Much like my fisting attempt in the showing, I guess you could technically say I did it, but it wasn't the most pleasureful thing I have ever done. But fuck my nipples were pretty sensitive this afternoon. I really liked having my tits played with roughly, and I didn't hold back with my little show. I looked over at Jeremy at one point, and I could tell that he was rubbing his erection through his shorts, but it was well below what could be seen on camera. Seeing him touching himself right in front of me again really got me going, as visions of last night ran through my head. Holy fuck did this feel good? I could feel my body responding; it was really starting to get good when I heard.

"Time."

Shit.

"That was fucking amazing and so sexy to watch. But I guess we'll have to save the bonus for another time." Caleigh stated.

It was our turn again, Jeremy's turn specifically. He asked Kyle, "Truth or Dare Kyle?"

Kyle chose truth.

"Wimp." I teased.

"Have you ever done anything sexually with another man?"

Ooo, brother, nice question.

"Yep." Kyle responded without hesitation. "I've sucked a few cocks in my day. And even been fucked by a few here and there. I've never been on the giving end of anal sex with another guy, but I'm not opposed to the idea."

Caleigh jumped in next and asked Jeremy which option he wanted to choose. He chose truth as well.

"Same question as you just asked Kyle." Caleigh stated.

"I kissed another guy one time, but that's about it. But I'm not opposed to the idea at all. And I've messed around by myself a little bit."

"What do you mean messed around by yourself?" Caleigh asked.

"Well, I did the dare you guys asked me to do the other day where I had to cum on my own face. But I've also fingered myself a few times while masturbating. Just to see what it was like."

"Fuck that's pretty hot." Caleigh responded.

And I had to agree with her. I would love to see Kyle and Jeremy go a few rounds together in person.

"My turn." I jumped in. "OK, this one's a little bit of a secret dare." I said. I had sort of been planning this all along. I might have "forgotten" to fill Jeremy in on my little plan. But I had a hunch he wasn't going to be too upset about it.

"OK. Here's the dare. I dare the two of you to turn around and look away from the camera. Jeremy will tell you when the two of you can turn around. Do not peek, or the game is over."

"Um, ok." Caleigh responded clearly, a little confused. "Not the most extreme dare I've ever been asked to do."

They turned around, and I quickly set my plan into action. I quietly told Jeremy to stand, and we positioned the camera so our full bodies were in the shot. I grabbed Jeremy by the shoulders and positioned him right where I wanted him. He looked at me with a confused expression; he had no idea what I was about to do. I stuck my finger in front of my lips, giving him the shhhh sign. He shrugged in agreement. I leaned over and whispered in his ear. When I tap you on the leg three times. Tell them to turn around. He nodded in agreement.

I got down on my knees in front of my brother and reached up to grab the hem of his shorts. He instinctively grabbed my hands, and his eyes shot wide open. I flashed a huge smile back at him and brushed his hands aside as I regrabbed his shorts and, in one motion, pulled them and his underwear down around his ankles. His erection sprung forward and almost hit me in the face. I looked up at my brother as he mouthed, 'What are you doing?'

I gave him the shhh signal again and wrapped my hand around his rock-hard shaft. It felt so warm. I had wanted to do this all day and couldn't believe I had the courage to go through with it. I moved my head forward and caught the head of his cock between my lips. I slowly opened my mouth and took the rest of my brother's penis as deep as I could. I started slowly working my head back and forth, running my tongue around his head each time I pulled back. I couldn't believe I was sucking my brother's cock. I was giving him a blowjob, and it was going to be the best fucking blowjob he's ever had. I really started to get into it and was about to see how much I could take in when I heard Caleigh speak from within the computer.

"Um...guys?"

Shit, I almost forgot this was a show I was putting on and not just something I wanted to do. I tapped Jeremy on the leg three times. But he didn't do anything. I looked up at him making eye contact and slapped his leg quite hard this time.

"Oh shoot. Ya. Ok. You guys can turn around."

As soon as he said that I leaned forward and took the entire length of my brother's cock into my throat, I didn't stop until my lips were touching his stomach.

"WHAT THE FUCK?" I heard Caleigh and Kyle scream out in unison.

"Oh my god, oh my god, oh my god." Caleigh kept screaming.

I would have probably burst out laughing if I didn't have a cock buried in my throat.

"I fucking knew you guys liked that movie more than you were admitting," Caleigh responded.

"Uhgh...fucking hell." Jeremy interrupted. "I'm not going to last that much longer."

Good. I wanted to taste his cum again so badly. I sped up my efforts, but my neck was starting to get tired. I reached back and grabbed both his wrists and placed them on either side of my head. It took him a second to figure out what I was suggesting, but when he realized what I wanted, he started to fuck my face with all his worth. OMG, I couldn't believe I was sucking my brother's cock. I was doing it while another couple was watching us online, and now he was fucking my face, and I was loving every second of it. I reached down and started rubbing my clit furiously.

"Fuck Ange. Here it comes. I'm going to cum. I'm going to cum in your mouth again." He screamed.

"Again?" Caleigh responded.

And with one last thrust, he pushed his cock deep down my throat and unloaded a huge torrent of cum. It felt even bigger than the one the night before. This time I had no problem swallowing all of it. I wasn't going to miss a drop. Jeremy let go of my head, and I slowly released his softening penis from my mouth. I stood up, faced the camera, and bowed.

Both Caleigh and Kyle lept to their feet and erupted into cheers and applause.

"Bravo, you magnificent slut. What a show." Caleigh yelled.

Caleigh and Kyle took their seats, and Jeremy and I rearranged ourselves so we were sitting back in front of the camera again.

"Ok, you two. That was the hottest thing I've ever seen while playing Truth or Dare. Explain yourselves." Caleigh demanded.

"OK. So we might have enjoyed the movie a little more than we let on. We were watching the movie together. Neither of us could believe what we were seeing on the screen. And we were both extremely horny. We had talked a little before the movie started and had worked out that we were both adults, and adults could watch porn, talk about sex, and play Truth or Dare online, and it didn't have to get weird between us. And when the movie was over, we were both really horny and admitted that to each other. Jeremy said he was going to go up to his room to 'take care of things', and I'm not sure why, but I interrupted him before he could leave, and I dared him to do what he was going to do right there on the couch. And so he did. And I joined in too. But by myself, on the opposite side of the couch. And he was about to cum but had nowhere to finish. And not wanting to get it on the couch, I took inspiration from the film and leapt into action. I got there just in time, and Jeremy came into my mouth. But that's it. That's all we did."

"What do you mean, that's it? You masturbated in front of each other, and he came in your mouth, and you don't think that's a big deal?"

"I guess it was a bigger deal than either of us realized. But this just now, this was all my idea. I thought about it this morning while lying in bed. I brought myself to orgasm just thinking about it. I thought it would be a fun surprise for you, and if I did it right, an even more fun surprise for Jeremy."

"Uh ya. You could say I was caught off guard a little bit." Jeremy added.

"What do you think about it now, Jeremy?" Caleigh asked.

"I've never felt anything like that before. That was the greatest blowjob I've ever been given, and it was given to me by the sexiest women I know."

I leaned over and kissed him after he said that. There might have been some tongue involved. And Caleigh might have cheered us on.

"That was absolutely amazing." Caleigh stated. "You two are amazing."

We decided that was probably far enough for today's game. We thanked them for a good time and then logged off.

"I can't believe that you did that." Jeremy stated.

I couldn't tell if he was upset or just stunned. "Are you upset that I did?"

"Oh hell no. That was amazing. I do feel bad about one thing though."

"We can trust them. I don't think we have anything to worry about there."

"What...no." Jeremy responded. "Lol, that's not what I'm talking about at all."

"Oh. What then?"

"You didn't get to cum at all during our game. Only the guys did today."

"Oh. That. Um. That's ok."

"Ange."

"Yes Jer."

"Would you like me to assist you with that in any way?"

"What? What are you saying?"

"Holy shit do I have to spell it out? Angela, would you like me to eat your pussy until you have an earth-shattering orgasm?"

I almost came when he said that out loud. "My room or yours?"

"You have the bigger bed."

And we took off as fast as we could up the stairs to my room. We were both naked as we climbed onto my bed. I crawled up to the pillows and laid down on my back. With a huge grin on his face, Jeremy climbed between my legs and delivered on his promise. I couldn't believe a few minutes ago I deepthroated my brother to orgasm, and now I was lying here in my own bed with his head in between my legs eating me out with a skill level I did not expect. Holy fuck was he good. I started rough housing my tits as he kept working his tongue in and out of me. I could feel my skin turning bright red; I started to get lightheaded, and then, as promised, an earth-shattering orgasm ripped through my body. He didn't stop, though. I'm not sure how he could breathe down there, as I was leaking more fluids than I even though possible. But he just licked it all up.

He had been using two fingers inside of me to stimulate my g-spot while using his toungue to work my clit. And just as I finally felt my orgasm subsiding, I felt him slip a third finger inside of me. His hand is a little bigger than mine, so his three felt like my four. He kept working at my clit with his toungue while working his fingers back and forth. And then he did something I did not expect. He added a fourth finger. Holy fuck, I've never felt so full in my life. My pussy was on fire. But it felt amazing.

He pulled his head out of my thighs for a second and asked. "Is this ok?"

"Fuck yes!" I responded. "Keep going."

"Really?"

"Yes," I said while throwing my head back.

Was this really happening? My brother just gave me the best orgasm of my life, but now was this really about to happen? And then I felt it. He tucked his thumb in beside his fingers and slowly started pushing forward. I screamed out partially in pain but more in ecstasy. I reached down to grab his wrist. I think he thought I was going to stop him because he stopped pushing forward. But I grabbed his arm and pulled his hand towards me. He started pushing again, working his hand back and forth. It took a few minutes of trying, but eventually, with one last push, my pussy opened up just enough, and his entire fist slid right in me. Only his wrist was showing. It felt so amazing I couldn't even scream. I opened my mouth, but nothing came out. Another orgasm instantly ripped through me.

"OMG, it feels like your trying to squish my hand with your pussy Ange!"

"Just hold still. Give me a second." I responded exacerbated. "Ok, go slow, but start fucking me with your fist, Jeremy. Oh fuck, this feels so good."

He slowly started working his fist back and forth, which felt amazing. He then twisted his fist, and that felt even better. My fucking brother was fisting me and it felt incredible. He was really starting to give it to me now, and I could feel it--the third orgasm--it was coming fast.

I think I blacked out for a second because the next thing I remember was Jeremy asking if I was okay. His hand slowly pulled from inside me, and as it left, I felt so empty.

"Come here!" I demanded and pulled him up to lie next to me. We started kissing and holding each other. I could taste myself on him.

"That was quite the day. I did not expect any of that to happen when I woke up today." Jeremy said while looking deep into my eyes.

"Jeremy."

"Ya?"

"I love you."

"I love you too, Ange."

And I nestled my head into the crook of his neck. We lied like that for about an hour or so without saying or doing anything. Just holding each other.