This story isn't in my typical wheel house but a reader requested it, provided me with intriguing details, and here we are...
As always, comments are appreciated. Anonymous trollish comments are not and will be deleted.
*****
Janette 38
Jennifer 35
Lisa 30
Heather 28
Jessica 21
***
"Shoot!" Janette Browning threw down some clothes in disgust. "I can't believe our medical bag is missing."
"Don't worry about it sis." Her youngest sister, Heather, said as she gave Janette a soft punch in the arm. "Who needs the pill? It's Sisters' Week. We'll just make sure none of us will jump our husbands for a week when we get back. As for aspirin or anything. Well, they have pharmacies here."
Janette blushed and Lisa, the middle sister, laughed. At that moment, Jessica walked in. She saw Janette blushing and ducked her head down and blushed.
Heather took charge. "Oh my god, you two blush more than a virgin on her wedding night! Let's hurry up and unpack so we can have some fun."
Janette returned to the bedroom she was sharing with Jessica and the two continued to unpack. Janette, Jennifer, Lisa and Heather had been taking weeklong vacations for six year running. The sisters had always been close, but now that they were all married, it was harder to find time together. Sisters' Week had been Lisa's idea and they all loved being able to take a break from their family life to lie around in the sun and gossip.
This time, their circle had been expanded to include Jessica. Jessica was Janette's niece and she had just turned 21. She was always so quiet at family gatherings that Janette had felt a special place in her heart for the young woman and had invited her in hopes of getting a chance to chat with her.
Even though Janette was the oldest, she had always felt a little timid next to her three more extroverted sisters. But she didn't mind. She liked being the one behind the scenes and could tell Jessica was the same way.
For this year's Sister Week, they had booked a private house on the beach at St. Martin's. The Caribbean waters lapped less than fifty feet from their door.
"Wh-what were the guys laughing about?" Jessica asked softly.
Janette turned and shook her head. "Just about birth control pills. The bag that had our supply is missing."
"I - I can't even use them." Jessica's face turned a bright red. "I'm allergic to the pill and to latex as well."
Janette looked down at her niece. Jessica was a tall, sweet looking woman. She was about 5'9", long brown hair and the good looks of a girl next door. And the body to match, Janette admitted to herself. Flat stomach, perky breasts (maybe a C cup?) and wide hips. She sighed and touched her own stomach that wasn't as flat since she had her first child seven years ago. "Must be tough being a newly wed then."
Jessica looked up at that and smiled. "Well, we've been careful, making sure it's the right time of the month. And we're meeting with a doctor next week to discuss some other options."
"What are you two doing in there!" Heather yelled. "Get your suits on. It's time to swim."
Janette and Jessica quickly put on their suits and joined Jennifer, Lisa and Heather outside. The sun was bright and the water was a deep blue that slowly faded to a bright, emerald green as it rolled onto the beach.
Of course Lisa and Heather were wearing bikinis. Lisa got divorced three years ago and had since become an avid work runner. She was already tan and had long slender legs that made her seem taller than her 5'6" frame. At 30, Lisa said she was in the best shape of her life and she looked it. She was flatchested like all the sisters, but had a cute smile and eyes that shone with laughter.
Heather was most beautiful of the group. At 28, she had never been married and accentuated her beautiful face with fashionable makeup and the latest clothes. She was also the tallest sister at 5'9" with long hair with highlights. Her ass was her best asset, and her thong bikini showed it off.
Jennifer was more conservative and wore a one-piece. At 35 and a mother, she couldn't quite compete with Lisa, Heather and Jessica. But she had a maturing beauty about her. She was maybe 125lbs and 5'6. Her suit was conservative, but her long nipples were hard from the water and strong legs flashed in the water.
Janette smoothed her own one-piece over her stomach. Her husband always insisted she was beautiful, but next to her sisters... well, at 38 she had self-confidence in a strong marriage. She wasn't as skinny as her sisters, but men always complimented her smile. And she had noticed one of the grocers checking her out when she was buying supplies for this trip. She smiled at the thought. Even though she shouldn't have, she had bent over a little longer when she realized what the boy was looking at.
All thoughts washed away as she splashed into the warm water.
***
It was the fourth night of Sisters' Week and the margaritas were flowing. The five women were sitting around the table tanned and tired after another day of swimming and laying out in the sun.
"Ladies," Heather poured a round of freshly blended margaritas and lifted her glass in a toast. "I think we have found paradise. To the best Sisters' Week yet!"
"Here! Here!" The four other ladies chorused and clinked their glasses together.
"And to Jessica, the newest member of the sisterhood! And who had the idea for margaritas!" Lisa said with a wide grin. "Nice call Jessica."
And they clinked glasses again.
"Thank you for inviting me- hiccup!" Jessica slurred.
"I think we have corrupted little Jessie!" Jennifer remarked and everyone laughed as Jessica pouted.
"God, I hate being called Jessie."
"Well, a little corruption never hurt anyone!" Heather said laughing. Her smile became mischievous and she said. "How about a game of truth or dare?" Jennifer nodded, "OK, but you have to go first. Truth or dare?"
"Dare." Heather replied immediately.
"Chug your drink."
"But it's huge! OK, OK. This was my idea," Heather said and then lifted her glass in the air and then began to chug the drink.
Janette was surprised how quickly her sister got the big drink down. And down it went, though as she slammed the empty glass to the table, Heather's eyes were watering a bit.
"OK, my turn to pick." She surveyed the group while Lisa poured her another drink. "Well Lisa, since you are so eager to get me drunk. You pick."
"Bitch." Lisa joked. "Hmmm. truth."
Heather pondered for a minute then said. "What's your favorite thing to do in bed?"
Lisa blushed which was unusual and then said, "Giving blowjobs."
"Ewwwww," Janette said. "You actually like doing that?"
"It's fun." Lisa replied. "Plus, guys are putty when you are giving head."
"Don't tell my husband Robert you like that." Janette retorted. "He's always trying to guide me down there."
Everyone started laughing at that and Jennifer shook her head. "Typical man." Lisa looked around the circle before settling on Janette. "Your turn."
Janette felt a little excitable after another night of drinking. Ah, why not? "Dare."
"Hold on a minute." Lisa giggled and then ran off to her bedroom. Everyone exchanged puzzled glances. A few seconds later, she came back with the belt of her robe. It was a pink terrycloth and easily three inches wide. "You have to remain blindfolded for the next twenty minutes."
Lisa stepped behind Janette and lowered the belt over her eyes. She tied it tight and Janette was engulfed in darkness. Well, this was certainly different. Where had Lisa come up with such an idea!
"Alright, my turn. I pick Jessica." Janette's hand fumbled around. "And where's my drink?" She felt someone tug her wrist to the right and guide her to her drink. "Thanks."
"Um. truth," Jessica voice was soft and slurred.
"OK," Janette wracked her brain trying to think of a good question. Damn Lisa for blindfolding her. Well, if they were going to play that way. "When did you first have sex?" She could almost feel Jessica blush at the question.
"My wedding night."
That caused another explosion of laughter.
"Honey," Heather said. "Even big sis Janette over here didn't wait till she was married!"
"Aw, it's sweet." Jennifer said. "You just don't appreciate it because you aren't married yet."
"Lucky her, I say." Lisa joked.
"It's MY turn now." Jessica cut in, obviously she didn't like being laughed at. "Jennifer, what do you pick?"
"Dare."
Janette thought Jennifer obviously didn't think Jessica would do anything bad.
"Take off your swimsuit. You have to be naked the rest of the game."
"WHAT?" Jennifer screamed while the rest of the women 'oohed' and 'aahed' at the dare.
"You go girl!" Heather interjected.
Janette smiled and wished she could see her sister's face. Jennifer didn't like showing off her body.
"I'll get you for this Jessie." Jennifer said as she stood up and shed her suit. She sat down quickly and crossed her arms over her breasts.
"Remember Jen, no tag backs," Heather said.
"You're right Heather, that's why you get to go."
"Hmmm, I pick-" Suddenly she screamed.
***
Janette reached for her blindfold, but before she could do so, hands grabbed her arms. Roughly, her hands were brought behind her and tied tightly. "What are you guys doing? That hurts!" She cried out.
A deep voice whispered in her ear. "Don't worry baby, we'll make you feel better soon."
A shiver of fear tingled down Janette's spine. What had happened?