*** NOTE: This is the second part of a continuing series. For character development to make sense you may need to read Chapter 1. Also, everyone in this story is over the age of 18***
Mrs. Duffy meandered down the stairs still drying her hair after the shower she just took. Despite the day's previous tryst, Mrs. Duffy still felt like a bitch in heat. Now however, she was going to try to make sure her daughters did not graduate High School as inexperienced as she had.
"Where did you sister go?" Mrs. Duffy asked in a puzzled tone of voice. It was still pouring outside and Anna did not have access to a vehicle at the moment.
"She went for a run." Erin responded. Erin was still lounging in her green and yellow cheerleader outfit, apparently too lazy to change. Erin had a slightly chubby body that was summed up in her thick, tan thighs. Luckily for her, most people's eyes gravitated towards her heaving chest that was measuring a 36-D by the time she had entered the 9th grade. They had not grown much since then but that had shaped out nicely, sitting high on her chest. Her plump butt was another favorite fantasy for the boys at her high school as she often sported tight pants that did little to hide the jiggling.
"Why would she go for a run in the rain?" Erin's mom asked.
"You know how she gets when she's angry."
"Well, why is she angry?"
"I was making fun of her diary. I found it the other day in her bedroom and I could not believe some of the stuff that was in there...some of it was disgusting." Erin mocked while sticking her tongue out, "Anyway, she was super-embarrassed and got all pissy. Then she went out running."
"Well, shoot. Come upstairs with me then. Show me this diary. "
Meanwhile, I was sitting in the upstairs living room trying to read a Stephen King novel. I was having trouble concentrating as all I could think about was Mrs. Duffy's reference to her daughters at the end of our sex-capade earlier in the day. I was getting a little nervous that it might not have meant what I had hoped, though I knew myself to be pessimistic.
Erin walked into Anna's room as her mom told her to get the diary out and to wait for her to come back. Erin was digging around in Anna's closet when her mom walked in with a bag in her left arm and a book under her right arm.
"Is that MY diary?" questioned a shocked Erin.
"Yes it is my dear. I'm not sure how you got a hold of Anna's journal but I don't believe it is right for sisters to be invading each other's privacy. You are not in charge of your sister. You have no right to read what she is writing privately. Now I am going to have to punish you but I want you to know I am doing it because I love you. If you take your punishment without too much complaining I believe you will come to enjoy it even. Now follow me."
"James, can you come into Erin's room with us?" Mrs. Duffy asked in a loud but controlled voice.
I heard Erin question her mom before being shushed as I was now sure that Mrs. Duffy's reference to her daughters was indeed sexual. I walked into the bedroom and saw Erin sitting cross-legged in manner that displayed her panty-only covered crotch. She was whimpering lightly as Mrs. Duffy stood above her and leafed through a book.
"Have a seat on the bed James. Erin, I want you to read this page aloud so we can all hear it. James, I caught Erin betraying her sister's trust so this is how I am punishing her. I hope you don't mind."
"THIS PAGE!" Erin protested before I could reassure her mom, "but this is so embarrassing!"
"NOW!" shouted Mrs. Duffy.
Erin read,
I had the dirtiest fantasy in English class today and I could not wait to cum (hehe) home and masturbate. Mr. Timmons was so hot today all I could think about is bribing him with my body for a better grade. But he would demand so much of me. I would say I would let him fuck me if he gave me an 'A'. Then he told me that if all I was offering was my pussy he could only give me a 'C'. He told me for a 'B' he was going to fuck my ass, and for an 'A' I had to let him do whatever he wants.
Erin shut the book after reading the last sentence in a childish tone. "Finish the story, Erin, all of it." her mother said in a stern voice. Erin sighed and continued to read aloud,
I told him I needed an 'A' at which point he stood up and shoved my pants to the ground. He bent me over his desk, slid his cock in my pussy fucked me hard and fast of several minutes. Finally, he took it out and slid into my ass. It hurt but I loved it. He fucked my ass until he was ready to cum. He then, pulled it out, pushed me onto my knees and moved his cock towards my mouth. I hesitated until he asked me how bad did I want an 'A'. I swallowed his dick as he exploded into my mouth. I loved every second of it...
Erin slammed the book shut as she started to tear up. "I know that was hard honey, but you know this will stay a secret between the three of us." Mrs. Duffy proclaimed.