Thank you to Oldbroad76 for editing.
John
was worried about how this conversation was going to go, although not as worried as he was a few days ago. Having sex with Piper seemed to change everything. He was unsure on how she would react about having a sister, but he was sure she would handle it, although Mia seemed nervous.
She was sat in the passenger seat of his car parked on their driveway.
I can't believe I've had sex with both of my daughters,
he thought,
but it just felt so... right.
Mia was sitting silently, except for her leg nervously bouncing up and down.
Seeing the normally confident Mia so worried felt alien to John.
"I hope she doesn't hate me." Mia whispered.
"She won't hate you." John told her.
He wanted to just tell Mia what happened between him and Piper, however he settled on the decision that all the truth should come out together.
He reached across and held Mia's twitching hand.
"I'm right here with you." John told her.
Mia looked into his eyes, still nervous.
"Thanks... Dad." She whispered.
Dad... I like that.
They got out of the car and walked towards the door. When John opened it, he heard that the TV was on.
"Hey.. oh.. Mia!" Piper shouted when she spotted them both.
She ran up but stopped when she must have sensed something was wrong.
"Piper, we all need to talk." John said.
Piper was in tight shorts and a tight t-shirt that showed the bottom of her flat stomach. John couldn't help but see her in a sexual way, although they didn't have sex again since that first night a few days prior.
"Okay?" Piper said confused. "How come you're together?"
"Just come sit down." John said calmly.
**
Mia was refusing to look
Piper
in the eye, which only confused her further.
Where have they been? And why are they being so weird?
Piper walked silently into the living room where she sat on the sofa. John turned off the TV just as Mia sat down on a separate chair while John remained on his feet between the two.
"There is something that you need to know." John said.
Piper's ears perked up, and a million thoughts ran through her head over what he was about to say.
John took a deep breath. He looked worried, which only panicked Piper.
"A few weeks ago," John said, and Piper was twitching now, worried about whatever he was going to say, "your mother came over."
"What?" Piper said in absolute shock.
She hadn't heard from her Mum since she walked out on them both when she was a child.
And she came back? Why didn't he tell me?
"I didn't tell you because I didn't want to upset you." John told her.
"Am I going to meet her?" Piper asked.
Could I have a relationship with my mum again?
"No," John bluntly said, which crushed that quick dream. "She's gone for good."
Piper was upset. She didn't have any hope of seeing her mum again, but that one second of imagination seemed to bring years of pain onto her.
"It's better," John told her. "Your mother... she wouldn't be good for you."
Piper was so confused. She couldn't understand where this was going, or why Mia was there.
"But when she came, I found out something," John said, "something I had no idea about until a few weeks ago."
Then he turned and looked at Mia.
"Will you just tell me!" Piper begged.
Her world was spinning. John hadn't even talked about her mum in years and now this!
"You remember how I told you that a few years before you were born, your mother and I separated for a little while?" John asked.
Piper nodded, still confused.
"It turned out," John took another deep breath, making this painful for Piper, "she was pregnant."
Piper's mouth gasped open.
"The child was mine," John continued, "but she wasn't ready to be a mum, so she gave the baby up, and came back to me, and then we had you."
John smiled. He always loved Piper with all his heart.
"So, I have a brother or sister?" Piper asked. It was unbelievable. How could she have a sibling?!
"A sister," John told her. "That's why your mum left us - to raise her."
I have a sister! What? Mum left me to raise my sister?! Why wouldn't she want to raise me?!
"Who... where is she? I want to meet her!" Piper all but shouted.
"Well..." John paused, "you have met her."
What?!
His head slowly turned to the side and looked at Mia. Piper looked at her, the slightly older girl with her eyes locked to the floor.
And finally... it hit Piper.
"No," She said in pure shock, "no, no, no... you can't be! My sister?!"
Piper felt sick. The one friend she had in the world turned out to be lying to her the whole time.
"Piper, I'm so sorry." Mia said.
"You've lied to me!" Piper shouted. "This whole time!" And then something else hit her, "And we... we..." She then looked at her dad before she finished her sentence.
"Piper," John said, "I know about you two."
"What?" Piper gasped.
Her head was well and truly spinning. Not only was her best friend and lover actually her sister... but her dad knew about it!
"How... how... how..." Piper kept repeating herself.
"I caught you... a few times," John said, "but I didn't say anything."
Oh my god, he's seen me have sex with my sister!!
Piper knew it was ridiculous to be embarrassed about it, given the fact that she had sex with her dad, but it just felt... weird!
"There's something else you need to know," John said, and an even heavier sigh left his mouth this time, "Mia and I, we... we have had sex."
No. Fucking. Way.
Piper thought she was going to pass out.
"You had sex? With her?!" Then Piper looked at Mia. "You fucked my dad! Your Dad! Fuck, OUR dad?!"
"Piper!" John shouted when Mia didn't defend herself. "Mia, she's... had a hard upbringing. You can't understand what she's been through."
"I can't... I can't... I can't believe it." Piper stuttered out.
"You should understand it more than anyone." John told her.
Piper froze, but it was true,
my dad has had sex with me and my sister...
This got Mia's attention, and she finally looked up from the floor.
