Michael lay naked on his bed, his erection staring up at him as though to ask how much longer until things got started. But his older sister Holly lay next to him, her head on his chest, her eyes shut, but the smile on her face belying the idea that she was actually asleep. Patience, he thought. Patience.
He'd finished a year of college and returned home for what he assumed would be a summer of painting houses, using the family pool, and drinking with friends. But Holly had turned things in a different direction.
She had found him naked in the kitchen one late morning, their parents gone away to their beach cabin. Michael being naked wasn't terribly new. When he was younger, he had frequently walked around the house nude without a word from anyone. That habit had faded away in the few years previous, but, thinking Holly had gone with their parents, he rekindled it with the goal of spending the day nude by the pool. Instead, by midafternoon, he lay on the couch recovering from a toe-curling, eye-crossing handjob courtesy of his sister.
He didn't really cross his eyes, but the orgasm left him in a another state of being. Holly wiped her hand on her tee-shirt and smiled sweetly -- something he did his best to return. Then she kissed his forehead and said she'd be right back. As she walked away toward the laundry room, he watched her lift the tee-shirt off her body, her pink panties being the only thing on underneath. When she came back, she was wearing another tee-shirt of similar length and carrying a towel, which she offered him.
She crouched down next to him as he lay there and said, "I'm glad we did that. I liked it."
"I did, too," he stuttered, causing her to smile like one would at dope who had stated the glaringly obvious as some kind of revelation. She kissed his forehead again, said she was going to take a shower, and then ran upstairs.
He sat up, using the towel to wipe himself off, and suddenly seemed to comprehend what had just happened. His sister? Holly? They'd always been on good terms and he did consider her cute, but the majority of memories he had of her involved her face buried in a book. She was going to go to grad school to study literature. She knew about genres and authors from the 1700's. He didn't (to put it lightly). However, he now knew that his sister gave amazing handjobs. That's just not something I should know, he said to himself.
But, despite his misgivings, he had to admit that he wanted another one. He had no idea how to go about it. Even after what had just happened, he couldn't imaging just outright asking his sister for a handy. Or making a move on her. When she came downstairs after her shower, she was dressed, said she was going to meet some friends, and left with a friendly goodbye. For his part, Michael showered and then called some friends to come over. He put on some shorts, and spent the rest of the afternoon and night by the pool with buddies drinking beer. A couple of them crashed on the couch. The next day, by the time everyone cleared out and he and Holly got the place back in order, their parents arrived home.
For like ten days, it was like nothing had happened. His interactions with his sister went on as they always had. They each just went about their lives and jobs. He painted houses, she worked a temp job in an office. He started to think that maybe nothing had really happened after all. At least nothing that would leave a permanent mark.
Then came a Tuesday at 2 AM. He lay in his bed in the dark having woken up for no reason it seemed other than that his eyes insisted on not shutting. The door quietly opened, and in the mixture of streetlight and moonlight that filtered through the window curtain, he could see it was Holly wearing one of the long tee-shirts she slept in. He slept nude. Always. She lifted the sheets and slipped into the bed next him.
"You're awake," she said softly.
"Yeah."
"I checked on you last night and you were out cold," she said. Her hand slid under the covers down his torso to his penis, took hold of it, and began massaging it. It responded quickly, stretching out and getting hard. He turned his head to her, and she said "Shhhhh, don't want to wake them," meaning their parents sleeping in the bedroom at the end of the hall. He nodded and turned his focus to the sensation of her fingers loosely holding his hard cock and sliding along its shaft. Her warning that they needed to keep quiet muted not only his spoken words but everything he said internally. Granted a woman's hand on his penis had always been something of a brain eraser, but his mind went entirely blank, maintaining his breathing being all it could handle. In the History of Handjobs, the one she gave him that night would receive no accolades nor even a footnote, her hand moving silently but rapidly as though she, too, felt the need to get it accomplished before some unwanted knock on the door.
The denouement arrived with a shudder and a squirt. No curled toes. No crossed eyes. Just that squirt and some dribbling. Instinctively, he reached for the tissue box on the nightstand and handed it to her. She took one, wiped her hand, kissed his forehead, and padded out of the room.
His thoughts returned to him as he lay there after cleaning himself. A shudder and a squirt. Maybe, he thought, just maybe that first handjob wasn't all he made it out to be. We make such an opera out of sex. It could have been just the timing, the circumstances, the fact that she's his sister combining into some aria that kept playing in his head when, in reality, they had really just hummed a tune. A shudder and a squirt. The handjob that had just happened was like the disappointing sequel that brings down the original with it. That squirt might have been the dose of reality they both needed to move on. Let what happened remained fixed in the past to never be spoken of or thought about again. He rolled over on his side ready to doze off and let it all fade away.
Then it rained the afternoon of the following Thursday.
An hour after lunch, the boss told everyone to go home. They'd done all the busywork. As he got in his car, Michael got a text from Holly asking if he was done for the day. He replied that he was and was heading home.
When he walked through the door from the garage to the kitchen, there was Holly dressed for the office. Both their parents were lawyers, and their mom took dressing professionally very seriously -- something she pressured Holly to do, as well. Though that pressure wasn't needed. Holly liked formal attire. The girl with the sweetly unkept bedhead and body swimming in an overlong tee-shirt could, in the space of a half-four, transform into the professional woman with her hair pulled back, makeup done, lips crimson, and wearing a linen skirt, blazer, button-up shirt with the top two unbuttoned, and the shoes to match.
That's who sat at the kitchen table when Michael walked in. Her skin looked fine china.
"What are you doing home?" he asked.
A cup of tea rested on the table in front of her. "I said I felt unwell and needed to come home."
"You're sick?"
"No," she said. "Mom and Dad have meetings all afternoon and then a client dinner. With the rain and you being free, I thought I'd come home."
"Just to hang out?"
"No," she laughed. "I thought that, after you take a shower, you could meet me naked down in the rec room, and I'd give you a handjob. If that meets with your approval."
And, thus, all of Michael's thoughts about sexuality being an overwrought opera composed primarily in memory from the rudimentary materials of a shudder and squirt augmented with ritual and fantasy that conjures a untrue narrative of events that could just as well be allowed to recede into the ether -- that all fizzled away to an "Okay" and a two-minute shower.
He tromped down the stairs and then down the stairs again to the rec room, where he found Holly contently kneeling by an old blanket she had laid on the carpet, a pillow on top of it, and a small jar by her side. She still wore the blazer, but had unbuttoned another button on her top, the black fabric of her bra showing through. She patted the blanket as a way of telling him to stop standing there naked and gawking. He laid down on it and put the pillow under his head, his right elbow to her knees.