"Helllloooo... anybody home?"
I heard the words echo from both entrances of my house as I stood in the kitchen, my mind awash with thoughts of taboo sex – most recently, of taking my eighteen year old younger daughter, Dulcie's anal virginity, but also of having fucked my older daughter, Carolyn, both alone and with her sister. Then there was Carolyn's former cheer leading chum Jeanie, who, after thoroughly teasing me from the day she turned eighteen, had joined Dulcie in a display of lesbian sex which turned into a threesome. What had kept my cock hard in my pants all morning though, was thinking about Dulcie off on a football road trip, wondering how many cocks she was consuming, or whether she was indulging her bi tendencies with the other cheerbabes. I had seen and felt enough of Dulcie's taut young body to be able to imagine the experiences she was sharing.
The only thing keeping me from pulling my prick out and jacking off to get relief was knowing that Carolyn was due home any time for a weekend break from college. My hesitation was not fear of her walking in and finding me stroking myself. Dulcie had assured me that her sister was not ashamed of our earlier antics, and that if I handled the situation properly, Caro wanted more.
Part of what needed careful handling was my ongoing lust for Jeanie, complicated by the fact that she and Caro were no longer friends. Dulcie knew that my darkest fantasies involved reuniting the former team mates, in a modified version of my threesome with Jeanie and Dulcie. I could never tell Dulcie, but sharing Caro and Jeannie would be even hotter, with their history. I knew that even trying to engineer that would likely just blow things up, and leave me with no sex.
Dulcie was away, so neither voice could be hers. I quickly assumed that Carolyn had returned home earlier than expected, and turned toward the front door, expecting my older daughter to come bounding in. Her unhappiness at school had improved since our sexual encounter, which accomplished our purpose of building her self-confidence. She had not told me whether or not she had turned this into fresh sexual encounters.
Thoughts of watching Carolyn suck cock, or fuck, or eating pussy just made my cock stiffer, which was not what I wanted at that moment. No matter how much I hoped to share my meat with Caro again, wagging a hard cock at her before she even tossed her travel bag on her bed might scare her off.
Except it was not Caro who entered. Jeannie grinned girlishly at me as she rushed over and jumped up. My arms instinctively reached up and grabbed her back as her legs wrapped around my body. Her pelvis pressed tight to my cock. Her lips met mine; her tongue forced my mouth open and caressed my teeth. Her stiff nipples were barely contained in a halter top, which did nothing to prevent their hardness from drilling into my chest.
"Oh, I can tell that you're happy to see me, but Dulcie told me she wouldn't spoil the surprise when she asked me to come check and see if you needed anything while she was away." Jeannie burbled as she came up for air, fingers caressing my hair. "I remember how much fucking went on during senior road trip, but then, I'm much more of a slut than your daughters. Maybe Dulcie would rather save herself for Daddy. Though I bet your cock is excited thinking about who she might be fucking."
Jeanie emphasized her point by running a hand between our bodies, laying her palm fingers pointed down on my bulge. She held it there for about six heartbeats, applying barely any pressure, just feeling my turgidity surging against my clothing, grinning at the unspoken desire expressed by my meat, which told her that it wanted to touch her - not merely her hand, but her most intimate flesh, her mouth, her cunt, and, though she might not realize it, her ass.
"Is this reserved for Dulcie, or may I have some?" she cooed.
Before I could answer though, I heard a shout from behind me. This time it was Carolyn.
"Bitch," she yelled. "Daddy's mine!"
A blur flew past me. An arm swung. A hand slapped Jeannie's face loudly.
"I got a ride home early to surprise Daddy. It's not fair," my daughter whined.
The shock of the attack had caused Jeannie to release me and step back. My cock still throbbed but now it was protesting the loss of body contact.
"Hold on, dear," I spoke in as stern a parental tone as I could. For the first time, the moral gap created by incest felt like a chasm. "There's enough of me to share. To be fair, Jeanie had me first, at least when it comes to bouncing on the bed. You knew that."
"But that was with Dulcie - and you knew how upset that made me!"
One glance at the tears welling up in the corners of my daughter's eyes washed my sternness away. She melted into my arms, the heat of her body filling the vacuum created by Jeannie's stepping back. My cock instantly appreciated the treat, swelling hard against Caro's flat belly. I stroked her hair like I did when she was a little girl as she sobbed on my shoulder. My other hand caressed her back, but with each stroke, I realized that I was drifting lower toward her ass. Behind Caro, I saw that Jeanie was now grinning.
Caro did not protest against my hardness pressing into her body. Instead, she rotated her hips slowly, grinding against my erection. A soft sigh escaped her lips. My hand shifted all the way down to cup her ass, squeezing firmly. She pressed harder against me, twisting so that her nipples drilled against my chest, a repeat of how Jeanie's had felt moments earlier.
Her ass rotated faster under my palm, her cunt rubbing against my erection, separated only by thin layers of clothing. She broke the kiss, pausing briefly to bite my lower lip before panting for air, the warmth of her breath invading my throat as she stayed close.
"Damn, Daddy, but don't you just turn me on so much that I can't stay mad at you." Caro's voice was barely a whisper. "In fact, I want you so much that if you take me, I'll do anything you want – things that bitch Jeanie would never dream of."
My daughter snaked her tongue into my ear as if to illustrate her point, then spoke again."Things that my little sister would be shocked if you try them with her after I go back to school."
Over Caro's head, I could see Jeanie slumped against the counter, breathing heavily, one hand inside her panties, the other massaging her boob, fingers toying with her own nipple, grinning , her brain obviously filled with evil thoughts.
"Oh, I doubt there's much Jeanie wouldn't do," I chuckled, "and Dulcie is more corruptible than you could possibly guess."
I watched Jeanie's eyes open wide, her hands pausing as she waited for me to feed her fever with more details.
"No way she'd let you fuck her ass," Caro guessed. "and I would."
Since Dulcie had taken my cock up her poop chute, I'm sure my blush gave us away. Caro took a half step back, looking up and me, puzzled.
It was Jeanie's to fill the void, upping the ante. "Heck, ass fucking is almost vanilla these days. All the gals like a little sausage in their casing. If you want to be really kinky, you have to drink the cum out of an ass."
My cock throbbed, loving the idea, but my head was still in charge. "That would mean anal sex with no rubber – very unsafe."
Jeanie pouted theatrically. "But, Daddy, I bet Caro's ass is virgin. So the thrill would be worth the risk. If you want, I'd lick your stick clean afterwards."
I started to protest, not wanting to set a bad example for my daughter, but Caro moved quickly, placing a hand over my mouth as her other fingers moved to undo my pants.
"I think it would be a huge turn on. I'm soaked just thinking about it, and like I said, anything Jeanie dreams of, I'm willing to go beyond - so first, I want you to fuck her ass while I lick your balls. Then while you fill my bowels, I'll eat your seed out of her, before she gets her turn."
Her hand was massaging my shaft. My pants puddled around my ankles. Jeanie was simultaneously tweaking her nipples and slinking closer, her eyes locked on mine, her tongue wetting her lower lip. Common sense was about to lose another argument.
Jeanie pressed tight to Carolyn's back, making my daughter meat in a sensual sandwich. Jeanie ran her tongue along Caro's neck before raising her lips to meet mine. The sweet flavour almost made me believe that I was virile enough to come twice in enough quantity to fulfil their perverse plot.
"Let's make out and get him properly prepared," Jeanie stage whispered into Caro's ear, the tongue which had just teased my tonsils darting into my daughter's aural canal. One of Jeanie's hands had slithered up between bodies, and was under Caro's bra, doing to my daughter's nipple what Jeanie had just been doing to herself. I mentally pictured Caro dropping to her knees and taking me deep into her throat, in a seamless swallow, but with a hand firmly grasping my root to prevent accidental ejaculation.
By way of silent answer, Carolyn pivoted without releasing her grasp on my helmet, and cupped her other hand behind Jeanie's neck. Rivalry abandoned, at least for the moment, Caro locked her lips tightly onto Jeanie's mouth. I could see my daughter's tongue bulging in her frenemy's cheek. Four hands explored tits and asses as Caro quickly abandoned her stimulation of my organ. So much for my predicting how this ballet would develop.
The girls' next move was so smooth, it could have been choreographed like ballet, but likely simply reflected their years of cheerleading practice. With no apparent discussion, they executed a pirouette and somehow Caro elevated up until she lay on the counter top, her legs draped over the edge, Jeanie in between.
I watched Jeanie caress my daughter's inner thighs with delicate movements – far from the aggressive attack I had expected. Her fingers flowed in circular motions, eliciting ever deeper moans from Caro, until Caro's hips began joining in the dance, lifting up from the counter top as Jeanie's right thumb gently grazed Caro's labia.
Jeanie's nimble fingers tested Caro's willingness. She must not have known about my threesome with both daughters, and how Caro had played with Dulcie. I just assumed that Jeanie, being a proud slut, had played before and after her episode with Dulcie which had ended up with my seduction. Jeanie knew the location of the most important bits, and how to please a woman.
"Is this okay?" Jeanie asked with uncharacteristic gentleness in her voice.
"Ohmigawd, yes, better than okay." Caro moaned. "I don't think I've ever been this turned on in my life."