This story was originally written on my another account. But I can't seem to delete the story from the original account and repost it here.
*****
Where to begin? It's hard to write up about an impossibly complicated fling that began two Springs ago that made my life very tricky. It started with the visit of my wife's sister Monica and her daughter Michelle on a warm Southern California Spring day. I opened the door after hearing the buzzer go off and found Monica with her delicate green eyes and auburn hair and bright smile waiting on the other side. She was dressed in a sleeveless milky linen blouse and rustic brown corduroy jeans. A golden necklace loosely bounced around her delicate collarbone with golden earrings dangling from her soft lobes whose faint hairs caught the sun's rays.
"Sid! How wonderful to see you!" She exclaimed as she pressed forward with a warm hug, her hair fell into my face and my chin brushed against her ear.
"Oh, just look at you!" She said. "My sister really found a stud, didn't she?" To which I chuckled.
"Sam!" Monica practically bellowed in my ear as she pressed her next hugging attack on my wife.
Sam closed here eyes in a loving sisterly embrace with her lighter, nearly blond, straight hair falling onto Monica's shoulders. Sam wore a soft cream single piece nylon suit that balanced between athleisure and fancy.
Standing shyly behind Monica was the taller and slender Michelle. Similar green eyes and auburn hair to her mother, but her face was somehow more refined and beautiful. Her bare shoulders were freckled with sunspots, as was her nose. Her skin was creamy smooth. Her face uniquely feminine with big eyes and long eyelashes and full red lips. A beauty still in her cocoon of teenage adolescences but nearly fully blossomed into her young womanhood. She smiled at me with an almost ravenesk sharpness as if she just noticed me for the first time. I reached forward and pressed my strong arms around her for an embrace.
"Welcome to our place, Michelle." I said as I hugged her. I could feel her slender frame pressed against tight at first and then relaxing. Her body was firm and well toned like a volleyball player.
Sam turned towards Michelle. "Look at you all grown up!" She said as they embraced. "I can't believe you turned 18 this year. I remember when you were just a slender little girl. Always tall though!"
"Oh Sam, cut her a break. She's not a little girl anymore," I said.
Michelle flashed me a warm smile.
"Well wonderful to see you two!" She exclaimed.
We all convened in the leaving room chatting with Monica and Michelle's luggage hanging out on our doorway rug. Monica and Samantha were in a fast catch-up conversation leaving Michelle and me to pleasantly stare at each other trying to catch up awkwardly. A slow banter began.
"How's school going for you?" I asked. "Almost done, huh!"
"Oh, it's boring," She sighed. "Dreadfully boring." Like she was a 1950's movie star.
"But college will change all that," I responded.
"Sure, and there will be new people to hang out with. New boys to meet," She said said staring off with a smile.
I'm sure she was tired of all the boys looking how she did. She was simply drop dead gorgeous. I tried to pry more but eventually she changed the topic.
"Do you workout, Sid?" She asked asked after a pause and eyeing my arms with a smirk hiding behind her lips and eyes. A strange question that made me shift uneasily in my chair.
"Yeah, I have a routine. But look at you!" I said trying to change the focus off of me. "You must be doing some athletics in school yourself. Are you on a team?"
Her long legs, bare below her emerald pleated skirt, displayed strong calves, smooth and almost shinny. They didn't get like that just sitting around dreaming of boys.
"I used to do gymnastics for my first three years of high school, but I find myself just running these days," she said as she stroked her left arm softly with her other hand's long slender fingers and toned slim arms. She was still filling out in that teenage slender quality where she shot up faster then she filled out. Still she had those womanly curves already present.
"I still have the flexibility of course," She remarked with a smirk. "Still able to reach my legs behind my head or do the splits."
I smiled unsure of how to respond.
"Impressive. Wish I had that kind of flexibility. Well you look great, don't quit now! There's really nothing better then physical movement. I try and keep up with yoga and the gym. Moving the body keeps me happy." I felt really silly saying such generic things, but it was hard to talk with teens sometimes.
"I bet it does," She said slyly as she glanced at Sam. "Don't worry, I don't plan to stop being physical either. Of course I'm still learning all about it." She went on. "Did you say yoga?" Her delicate thin eyebrows raised in questioning.
"Yes, no better way to get to know your body."
Why was I still in this part of the conversation. I felt weird talking with my wife's niece like this. What if Sam or Monica took notice?
"There are some better ways I can think of," She said as her eyes scanned me up and down. I wasn't sure how to respond to that, or what she really meant. Was she flirting with me?
"Maybe in the morning you can show me some yoga." She smiled at me with eyes digging deep.
Oh shit! What could I say. Somehow doing yoga with my wife's teenage niece seemed inappropriate but I don't know why. An image of this young girl in tight yoga pants and a tight crop top stirred up a feeling of lust. I could just imagine going red in the face accidentally staring down her tank top at her young perky cleavage as she pressed her butt to the sky in downward dog. Or staring at her long slender leg as she bent over in a forward fold. Did she say she could reach her legs behind her head? But perhaps my wife would join and it would all be a bit more innocent.
I tried to shrug off these thoughts. After all she was very young and related to my wife, and I was happily married. Sam was also a drop dead gorgeous women who usually had a health sexual vigor, so I was't lacking in that department. Being married never stopped my stray mind though. How I pondered flings with the women I met or saw from a distance. Always imagining the dirtiest of encounters. I had tried to stop these thoughts for years. The guilt poured in, but they always came back. Eventually I felt that they were harmless as long as they remained in my mind. Although I always wondered what would happen if a beautiful women cornered me while my wife was out of sight or out of town. Would I cave if given the ability to fuck a stranger without Sam ever finding out? I always wondered.
"Sure, every morning at 7am," I said to throw off this probably late sleeping teenager.
"I wouldn't miss it!" She said smiling without missing a beat. "There are beaches here too aren't there?"
"Of course, it's California."
"Hmm, perhaps you could take me one of these days. I'd love to get into a two piece and sunbath on the sand. Or maybe you could teach me to surf!" She said in a bubbly voice of delight. Her bare knees pressed together in her delight and her posture straightened as if she were more alert.
"That's a big-art of why I wanted to come here. I'm really looking forward to the beaches here."