"She calls me Kitten." I said. I wasn't going to talk to her about this, any of this, but I had to. I had no one else to tell. I wasn't going to see her again. It seemed like a reasonable way to wrap up our relationship.
Dr. Madrigal was forced on me years ago. I hadn't wanted to go. I threw a tantrum, going so far as to scream at my father in his car in the parking garage outside of her office. He won the battle of wills by sitting there with the car turned off as the temperature rose. I told him I was going to call CPS. He just sat and glared at me. He could do that. He was stubborn.
Most of our sessions were fairly mundane with me complaining about those things that seem so important to a teenager and her telling me to grow up. I would, on occasion act out, throwing my best petulant teen act at her and getting nothing but her patient smile and the same admonishment. "Grow up." Sometimes I would ask a question. Not so obvious as, "My friend has a problem..." but not too much more clever than that really. She answered questions with questions, asked me what I had considered the consequences might be and left it to me to see the foolishness of whatever scheme or plot I had in mind.
The Thursday after my eighteenth birthday was different. We sat for a good long time not saying much of anything. I passed many of our sessions doodling, sketching her face. I had at least forty pictures of her. It was interesting to me if for no other reason than to measure the development of my skills as an artist. I would never be great but I wasn't bad. Even she had said so. I was adding detail to her face. I was working to add the small lines around her eyes without making her look 100 years old when she decided to point out I was now an adult. Not that she had been sharing much of what we talked about with my parents but at this point, unless I confided in her I was going to commit a crime, she was obligated to keep it between her and me.
I cried for the rest of the session. I did not want to be a grown up. I was not prepared for it. I didn't know how to be an adult. I confessed to her it pained me to pretend I was as insipid as my friends and I wept at my inability to be as smart as my parents asked me to be.
"Then don't be either," she said. "You are remarkable. You will be exceptional just being you. Don't ruin what you are."
I struggled to focus through tear soaked eyes until I could make her out, that smile of hers looking across at me. If asked, I would describe her as pretty but older. For just a moment I thought of her as something entirely different. If she found me to be exceptional, I found her to be exquisite. I left, regained my composure, and drove home imagining I was in love with her.
During our last five sessions I had kept my new lover a secret. I imagined her disapproval of having seduced an older woman and allowing it to develop into something more. I reflected at the horror that would grip her if I admitted to her the affairs incestuous nature. I feared disappointing her. Worst of all, I had created in my mind a bond that was far deeper than that of patient and doctor. I imagined a time that she could be more than a mentor and a confidant. I think it was the depth of this feeling I held out for her that finally caused me to confess. I had something to ask her and I couldn't ask her without her knowing.
"Kitten?" the Doctor asked for clarification.
"Yeah, Kitten. God I hated it. Isn't that silly? It was just a pet name. God, and it was so appropriate. The first time she used it, we were lying in bed. We had just, well, we had done it."
"Done it?" she interrupted. She did this. She was forever trying to make sure I spoke in the same terms I thought in and, at least with her, stopped pretending to speak the way my friends did.
"We had just made love. We were lying in her bed and I was resting my head on her chest. She is so soft. I was curled up, no different than Mr. Kitty, ya know? She was petting me. She was just running her hand over my back. She meant to be sweet. 'That was really wonderful, Kitten,' she whispered. God. I am so stupid."
"Why do you think you are stupid?"
"You won't believe what I did."
"What did you do?" She hated it when I got side tracked. She had been really good for my writing.
'I scratched her."
"Scratched her?"
"Yes! Right here. It was a long scratch, kinda deep too. It drew blood. Not a lot, but little drops of blood."
"Natalie!"
"I know!"
"Why would you do that?"
"She called me kitten. Like I was a little baby cat. Why didn't she call me Lynx? Why did I have to be a kitten? I don't want to be a kitten."
"This woman. She is older?"
"Yes?"
"Much older?"
"I don't know. Kinda?"
"Precision." She scolded.
"Twenty? Twenty-two maybe?" My therapist relaxed. I felt surprised it didn't bother her and then thought about my answer again. "Twenty years older. Not... you know... Twenty years old total."
"Natalie."
"I know."
"And you two are intimate?" she asked as if I had been overly vague.
"Yes."
"And where did she come on to you? Does she work at your school?"
"It wasn't like that."
"No?"
"God, not at all?" I stared at her. It was harder than I thought. "I came on to her."
"Natalie!"
"Doc. Stop. I'm not... I'm not a virgin. We've talked about that. I'm not concerned, you know, with conventional boundaries. She was beautiful. I've known her for, god, forever. I just found myself looking at her and wanting her, so I took her."
"She never should have let that happen."
"She was drunk."
"Natalie!"
"What? I wasn't drunk. I mean, I had a drink or two but nothing crazy. She was drunk. She's allowed. She is, god, like forty. I didn't plan for anything to happen, I just found her there and you know, I did what we - like - do."
"What exactly did you do?"
I walked her through the first night. I told her about the "move." That is what we call it. We made it up together. We experimented and got better at it. I don't want you to think that all volleyball players are lesbian or anything but some are. I guess that's obvious. I stammered a bit as I got through the part of the story where Elle - Ellie, Aunt Ellen, I call her Elle - did what she did to me. We didn't do that, the team, we had "the move." I told her how I lost control when it happened. By the time I was done Doc Maddie had set her little notebook aside and had inched forward in her chair. She now sat leaning towards me, her elbows rested on her knees.
"She introduced you to cunnilingus?"
"Yeah. Oral sex. She went down on me. You know, I mean, I've told you. Stasia, Kirstyn, Sydney, we mess around. We kiss. We - um- finger? But none of us ever - cunnilingus. That is what she did. Damn!"
"And your Mother and Father, they walked in on you? I would have thought that's the sort of thing your father would have mentioned to me."
"He doesn't talk about it. He doesn't even talk to Ellie anymore."
"Your mother? What was her reaction?"
"Oh god. Don't get me started."
"She has been rough on you?"
"She just wants to talk about it all the time. She likes to take me to lunch and ask about it."
"The affair?"
"Oh, fuck no. She only knows the one night."
"But its been going on for a while?"
"Yeah - Kind of."
"Frequently?"
"What's frequently?"