The spanking had stopped and I just laid there over her lap, vulnerable. As much as it stung and hurt something inside of me still wanted more. I didn't know if I'd ever have another opportunity to be spanked like this again so I wanted to take full advantage.
I peeled myself from off of Sarah's lap. As I stood up next to her my erection was near eye level to her. Sarah couldn't help but to take notice and gave it a stare.
"Stay right there, I'll be right back." I said.
I walked into the bathroom and grabbed a flat hairbrush off the counter to the sink.
I made my way back into the living room and back over standing next to Sarah again.
"I want you to spank me with this brush. It's going to hurt and I'm going to be doing a lot of moving around but I want you to do it."
"Are you sure honey? Your butt looks like it's already pretty sore right now."
"No matter what please don't stop. I want you go on for atleast 1 full minute regardless of how I'm acting throughout it."
"Alright." she said.
I gave Sarah the brush and put myself back across her lap.
"Are you ready?"
"Yes."
And just like that the first whack of the brush came crashing down on my cheek.
"Oooooh" I screeched out.
Quickly after the first came the second. And then the third, fourth, etc.
Sarah was back in her tempo and the pain was piling back up very quickly.
"OW OW OW!"
The brush was finding its way all across my bubble butt.
"OK SARAH!"
"PLEASE! IM SORRY!"
A few swats had found the area where the top of my thigh meets my cheek. Those sent a huge jolt right threw my body and caused me to twitch my body from side to side. I tried kicking my feet in an attempt to somehow ease the blows, but it did not work. I started to sob again. This time a lot worse than the hand spanking I got earlier.
After only about half way through which felt like an eternity, there was a noise at the door. The sound of a storm door being rattled, which quickly led to the front door now opening into the room.
Sarah heard and seen the door opening as well and quickly stopped the spanking. But I had no where to go. It was too late to run and hide.
It was my Sister in law Jenna.
"What the hell is going on!" She yelled out as she stood there staring at us.
Jenna was the oldest of the siblings. She was 6 years older than me and Hilary.
She was a very attractive girl. Long dark hair, big lips, perfect nice sized breasts,
curvy legs with a big shapely ass.
I would masturbate many times to the thought of her spanking me as well, giving me blowjobs, making me fuck her quick while my wife was out busy somewhere. She was the more outgoing one in the family and had a small wild side to her in her younger days.
I jumped off Sarah's lap and used my hands to try and hide my boner.
I stood there speechless. No way was this happening. My one moment I had fantasized for such a long time and a secret I've held onto forever, was ruined.
Jenna walked into the room with us.
"Is somebody going to tell me what's going on here?"
Sarah stood up from the chair.
"Jenna, this something very private, and is only between me and John. It now involves you too, so this is now something that just stays between all 3 of us. Hilary does not know about this, and will not know. Understood?"
"Mom" Jenna was cutoff by Sarah.
"I said do you understand? I will tell what's going on but you need to tell me you understand." Sarah barked back at her.
Jenna let out a big sigh "Alright, Ok, I won't say anything."
"Now John has come to me today because he was in a very tough position."
"We sat down and he informed me that it's always been a big fantasy of his to be spanked by a female. He has tried talking to your sister about it, but she always brushes it off. You know how she can be sometimes. And you and I both know how well he treats her and the least she could do would be to suck it up and do this for him."
"Yeah I mean, I guess your right. I don't know why she has to be so stubborn and can't honor one wish for him after all the things he does for her" Replied Jenna.
Sarah continued on "He was very uncomfortable about bringing this subject up to me and gave me his trust. He asked if I would Spank him because he trusted me and had no one else to go to. He is apart of our family, so I agreed."
Jenna looked over to me as I still stood there naked covering up myself. I could have put my clothes back on but the whole time I was frozen, embarrassed, and just stood there.
"Does Hilary let you spank her?"
I answered back "Yes from time to time. It's only for just a little bit and usually when we're going to have sex. But I don't think she's quite into it as me."
"I'm sorry, I know it's hard when your partner just isn't into the same fetishes as you or won't even pretend to be."
"That girl needs a good spanking," Jenna said with a crooked smile. Sarah too giggled at the remark.
Immediately I pictured Jenna spanking Hilary's bare ass naked over her lap. Her feet kicking and crying uncontrollably being punished like the little brat that she can be while me and Sarah watched. Maybe someday I will bring this fantasy up to them, but not anytime soon.
"Well" Jenna said. "If I am now apart of this secret then I should be able to partake in this spanking as well."
No way. Was this actually going to happen? Is my sister in law now going to spank me too? Was I even ready for it as my ass was on fire from the hairbrush? It didn't matter. I had to suck it up. There was no way I could ever refuse an opportunity like this.
"Ok" I said. "Come sit down."
Jenna moved towards me and sat down on the chair. I let go of my stiff duck and it shout straight out.
"Not bad" Jenna said staring at it with a smile.