If you read my first MILF Mom Manor story you will remember that I left the story in the hands of my followers to help me with my dilemma. I would strongly suggest reading MILF Mom Manor to get the backstory for what took place before you find out what happens next.
I wanted to complete MMM2 as quickly as possible and I got a pretty good feel for the direction my followers wanted me to take from their comments.
However, before moving forward, here is what happened before that lead me to the moment of my dilemma.
My 19 year old buddies and I had been staying at a villa resort in Cabo for 5 days with our 50 plus year old mothers. The resort was very similar to the resort used in the popular reality show called MILF Manor.
At all of our mother's request we were helping them revive their swinging lifestyle that they once enjoyed with our father's who for various reasons were no longer part of their lives.
My 3 buddies and I had spent the 4 previous nights fucking each other's moms at their request. This was the fifth and last night of our swinging vacation.
The moms had made it clear from the beginning of our swinging relationship that nothing was off limits with our sexual interactions except for one thing. They told us,
"Boys, we want you to enjoy having sex with us and keeping us sexually satisfied, however under no circumstances are we giving you permission to have sex with your own mother. That would be taboo and unacceptable."
Well, it might have been clear and unacceptable in their minds, however we felt otherwise. Of course we did not tell them that. We were getting the best pussy of our lives and we were not going to do anything to ruin it.
However, we lied through our teeth. We fully intended for fuck our own mothers very hard, very deep, and with a nasty edge. We decided to trick them and we had a brilliant plan called Surprise Night.
We set them up. They were all getting royally fucked by their sons on Surpirse Night. They just didn't know it, and they never would.
On Surprise Night I had been using and abusing my mom's MILF body for hours fulfiling my boyhood fantasy of fucking my own mother without her knowing.
Over the last couple of hours I had tied her up, blindfolded her, stripped her out of her bikini, teased her by sucking her toes, licked my way up her body to her tits, sucked her nipples, milked her mature tits and abused her nipples with nasty ribbed nipple clamps.
She had given me a tongue ball washing with my swinging balls in her mouth. I gave my mom the taboo pleasure of unknowingly sucking her 19 year old son's thick, hard cock.
She had pretty much been moaning, screaming, sweating and climaxing for over two hours.
My three other buddies were also fulfilling the same fantasy with their mother's at the same time in different rooms at our vacation villa in Cabo. We would meet the next morning for breakfast to share our individual Surprise Night stories with our buddies.
Let me be clear, this wasn't mom rape. It was semi consensual. Our moms invited us to fuck them but we just went a little off script.
That brings us up to the moment.
My 19 year old teen cock was now buried in my mom Jeannie's 51 year old pussy from behind. She was under the impression that the cock that was now pounding balls deep in her pussy was that of one of her friend's sons.
She had no idea it was me. She was on her knees on the bed, blindfolded with her hands tied over her head and tied to the headboard. I was standing on the bed sweating and hammering her MILF pussy from behind the same way I do with my 18 year-old teenage girlfriends.
I had joyfully put her through 2 hours of pleasure and pain. She was worn out and starting to whimper and cry. It was time to finish.
All the moms and sons had earlier agreed that the son's would not unload our young potent jizz inside the mom's pussies. Even though they were in their 50's nobody wanted to deal with a potential unexpected brother or sister.
That is an easy promise to make, but a difficult promise to keep when you are a 19 year old teen with your cock swimming balls deep in your mom's snatch while she is on her knees moaning and screaming with her pink asshohle staring you in the face.
I was in a nasty, out of control mood, and at that point I had every intention to pull out and dump my load in her pink lady asshole.
However, at the last second I thought to myself,
"Fuck it. This might be the one and only chance I ever get to fuck my own mother."
It is a very erotic moment when you have your cock buried up in your mom's pussy about ready to cum just like your dad had done many, many times before.
I was overcome with aggressive anger and nasty rage built up over the years for all the crap she did to me and all the shit she put me through growing up.
My thoughts were spinning in my head, "Do I pull out or let her have it?" Do I pull out or let her have it?" Do I pull out or let her have it?"
Despite everything that she had told me, and everything I had promised her, I mumbled under my breath, "Fuck it," and I unloaded my blueball special right in her MILF mom pussy.
I came so hard in her snatch that I lifted her hips and knees off the mattress and suspended her in the air with her hands still tied to the headboard. I fucked her like she was a toy ragdoll. I had never cum that hard in my life.
My mom Jeannie was crying and screaming and yelled, "Oh god, not in my pussy, no more, please not in my pussy." She could feel my warm load filling her pussy.
Her pleading made me even more aggressive. I lifted her off her knees pounding her with every deep thrust that went on for minutes.
I was draining my balls hard and deep. If there was any chance she was going to get pregnant I was going to make sure it happened right then and there.
She collapsed on her stomach with me on top of her with my cock still buried in her pussy. She tried to squirm and shake my cock out of her cum filled pussy but I was having nothing to do with it She was wimpering saying,
"Not in my pussy. Your promised me not in my pussy." That pissed me off even more. I reached over and grabbed the leather strap and slammed it down three times on her lilly white ass cheeks just to hear her scream, cry and moan one more time.
I pulled my lubed up jizz covered cock out of her pussy and shoved it up her ass. I rammed two fingers up her mom pussy and wiggled them deep and brought her to a squirting orgasm while she was laying on her stomach with her face buried in the pillow screaming and begging for mercy. She was pushed to her limit.