This story doesn't contain any sex. If you want to read a story with sex this might not be the right one. All characters are over 18. Author is not a lawyer, do not rely on this story for legal advice. Author is not a doctor, do not rely on this story for medical advice. Author is not a priest, do not rely on this story for any kind of accurate descriptions of religion.
This story contains a lot of religious themes that many readers may find inappropriate. Rather than cut it out to make a super sexy story I have decided to leave it in as an honest exploration of the character's feelings and motivations.
As always, constructive feedback is always welcome.
Chapter 1 Two men in the chapel
Martin Luther Collins was on his knees in the chapel. No words would come and he only felt empty and disillusioned. They'd lied to him. The whole thing, it was all a lie.
"Ha, ha, ha." the voice of the school administrator laughed.. Martin would not turn. "You homophobes always come here as if there's a God that can actually help you."
"Do you mind? I'm trying to pray." Martin said as the administrator came forward enough for Martin to see him from the corner of his eye.
"I do mind. You're going to have to learn that you have no rights or privileges unless it is something that I give you. Maybe you think you're smart. Maybe you believe that God will help you think of a way to save yourself. But writing a letter here or making a phone call there, it will all make no difference. Who is the Church going to believe, my twenty years of service versus someone who lied in order to gain admittance."
"I did not." Martin defended against the accusation without turning to look at the older man.
"Your file says you did. Look, it's right here, written down. A week after you entered we discovered your lie and you confessed. We graciously forgave you and allowed you to stay. See, it's right there."
"It's a lie. You know it's a lie." Martin insisted as he refused to look at the folder that was being shown to him.
"Doesn't matter. It's in your file and it wasn't like we just put that in there in the last ten minutes. We put that in there a week after you entered and it's in every version of your file from here to Rome. Also, all these incidents of you breaking the seminary rules. Look. My, my. And all this gay porn we've caught you watching and you making sexual advances towards other students."
"You fabricated an entire file on me?"
"What's in the file is all that matters. That's in the file so it must be true. Just like how we caught you stealing and using drugs. And every time we caught you, oh, you confessed and swore to us that you'd do better and each time we wanted to give you the benefit of the doubt so we let you stay but our patience has begun to run thin."
"All this just because I actually studied." Martin said and then he finally looked up from his prayers.
"You think you're special. Every student here has to be judged by the same process. You can scowl at me with your eyes all you want but I know the secrets of the church that you do not. Dear boy. Martin. Please. Why fight me on this? You could have a good life. A good career. A guaranteed salary for the rest of your days and access to so much more. Unlimited income. Think of it. Millions of dollars to take trips and buy boats or do whatever you want. And also you could help us do some actual good in the world instead of giving people false hope. You could help us bring about the change that your mother died fighting for."
"She died because she was stupid enough to try and rob a bank."
"But don't you believe it was for a good cause? One more step to the revolution. Capitalism must die for mankind to be free again. You've been here a year, have you learned nothing?"
"I did learn but not what you wanted. The church is not what you teach it to be."
"And what do you know of anything? You're not even baptized. Ah, yes, we know. We know all about it. You can't say you didn't lie about that."
"I asked to be baptized. I asked you and Father Kurtz."
"It's a pity things have gone this way. I had such high hopes for you. You seemed a perfect candidate. Shame. You know what your mistake was? You took all this fluff too seriously. There is no Jesus. There never was. He's a figment of someone's heat stroked brain out in the desert. If he did ever actually exist he'd be someone like me not someone like what you imagine. What do you think it meant when the gospels say he loved John." The man smirked. "There is no heaven. There is no hell. There is no sin. We live and then we die and that is all there is. It's a shame you let all the magical thinking infect your mind. We should have intervened earlier. That was my mistake, I suppose. You would have been one of my best lieutenants. But you had to go and think that you could actually become a real priest and be a traditional one at that. Martin, listen to reason. There are no priests who are the way you think they should be. We are called to something better, ... higher. Any idea that you have in your head to just play along and keep your head down and get ordained so that you can then go and be some tradition thumping zealot is fantasy. In the real world you only have two choices, follow me or leave. That's it. Nothing else. And in case you're still not convinced I'll let you in on one of the many fascinating secrets that I keep. Even if we did ordain you, it wouldn't mean anything. Ordination does not give you some magical powers to go out into the world to do whatever you want. So to make that clear to everyone we changed all the ceremonies. All the rites are now what the rigid bigots would call 'invalid'. Have been for decades. St. Paul VI of happy memory made sure of that. There isn't a single validly ordained priest or validly consecrated bishop in this country and perhaps not even in the entire world anymore. Even if it had been a real thing it doesn't matter anymore because the chain of apostolic succession has been broken. Suppressed and snuffed out. Do you see now? Even according to their own rules the traditionalists have been beaten. The faith doesn't matter. It was always just a myth to lure people in. Only the authority of the Church matters and if you are not with us then no one will take you seriously. Get it yet? Don't you understand that? The institution is what's important. Being in the church, having membership; regardless of what we say we believe; is what matters, not an invisible man in the sky who doesn't exist. We could change our beliefs over and over and endlessly contradict ourselves but it would never matter so long as we hold together in the church. Your kind of Christianity is gone. It has lost. The gates have been taken. There are no more Christians left and we, ... We are what remain, a force for actual good in the world. Join me and help me make the world a better place. End poverty. End capitalism. Free the people of their archaic superstitions. Join me and you can have all you desire. If you want a girl on the side from time to time we can even arrange that. Perhaps you want to get back together with that Anderson girl. She seems charming."
"You wouldn't say that if you'd met her."
"Actually I have met her and she eagerly did exactly what I asked her to do. She filed many police reports informing the authorities that you were violent and abused her."
"More lies."
"Doesn't matter. You confessed it all to us and we wrote it down. It's all there in your file for us to keep from the police only for them to raid us and find the documents which support her story and then they arrest you. You see. You will be fucked. Now, if you don't want to be arrested and convicted then you're going to go back to my office and serve me. You're going to suck my dick when I tell you. You're not going to whine or complain about how much it hurts when I gape your cute little ass cheeks and unload my cum down your rectum. And really, wouldn't you rather I do this for you than having it done to you in prison? That is the choice, let me be gentle or suffer all the scrapes and cuts and STDs that prison has to offer. It is inescapable. It became your destiny the moment you came to us."