Melissa left the apartment angry and in tears. Jessie looks at me stunned. I feel like the biggest fool ever. But if Melissa hadn't deceived me this morning and later on the phone, none of this would have happened. Jessie begins crying again and I take her into my arms to try to console her. But I need my own consoling now as well. I realize just how tragic this mistake actually is now. Melissa broke up with Daniel for cheating on him. She didn't give him a second chance. What makes it worse is I fucked Melissa's sister! She saw us together, my cum on our faces, her pussy still gaping open from being fucked by me, cum still leaking from her cunt. Melissa saw all of that.
"Mark ... what have we done!"
"I just fucked up big time, Jessie ... I really screwed up things worse than I could've ever thought possible! This is my fault! I should've confronted Melissa first and then I would've known. Damn! ... If she just hadn't lied to me! ... If she had just told me where she was going! I would've understood. I might not have liked it, but I wouldn't have stopped her."
"Mark, it's my fault too. I seduced you intentionally. I wanted to hurt Melissa. But I didn't want to hurt her like this though. I thought she hurt you ... I like you, Mark. It wasn't all to get back at Melissa ... I wanted to be with you tonight ... I wanted to have sex with you. It went from revenge to really caring about you, wanting you. I shouldn't have tried to seduce you though ... at least not tonight. I knew I could seduce you ... I took advantage of both of you! I wanted to hurt Melissa ... for a number of reasons ... "
We both get up and clean ourselves up silently; words are useless. We shower separately. I change the bed, which was wet in a number of spots from our intense sex earlier. We both get dressed and sit together in my room quietly, both hoping that Melissa would come back or at least call. We know we need to somehow try to overcome the hurt we've caused, on all of us.
I doubt that Melissa will stay with me now. I've hurt her badly with my actions. I'm not sure we have a relationship left. She lied and deceived me today. She didn't cheat, but she hurt the trust and faith I had in her.
My biggest concern now, other than myself, is Jessie. There are obviously some unresolved issues between her and Melissa. I could see the venom in both of their eyes for the other earlier. But I could also see a sisterly love beneath all that was said. Jessie didn't want to hurt Melissa for no reason. That is why she became so upset when she realized Melissa hadn't been cheating with Daniel today. But I saw a real satisfaction in her face when Melissa discovered us. It was like she had evened the score somehow. I wanted to ask Jessie about this. But I thought it was best to leave this old wound untouched tonight.
The quiet is almost deafening. Just a few hours before we were screaming out our orgasms and pleasure. We were also screaming with Melissa not long after that. Now we find it difficult to say anything to each other. The bond between Jessie and I kept her at my apartment though. I know she's concerned about Melissa. My fear is that Melissa will do something stupid. I'm not concerned that she will intentionally harm herself. But I'm afraid she might do something in anger that she will later regret.
The phone startled both of us. We stare at each other for a moment before I pick up the phone.
"Hello."
"Mark? This is Caroline, Melissa's mother. Is Jessie still there?"
"Yes, she is."
"Let me talk to her please."
"Hold on, I'll get her."
Putting the phone on mute, I tell Jessie who is on the phone.
"It's your mom. She wants to talk to you."
"How does she know that I'm here?!"
"I'm not sure ... but I have a feeling she has talked to Melissa."
"Pick up the other extension and listen in ... so you know what she tells me."
I un-mute the phone and hand it to Jessie.
"Hey mom."
"Jessie, your sister just left here. I know what happened there earlier today."
"Mom ... it's all a big misunderstanding ..."
"Jessie, fucking your sister's boyfriend is never a good thing ... even with what you thought happened today. Melissa is your sister and always will be that. She is very angry right now at you and Mark."
Jessie says to her mom, "She was really upset when she left here. I guess she went straight to you."
"She came home because she didn't know where to go. She didn't want to talk to me. It took some time to get her to open up to me about what happened."
"I know what I did was not right mom. I was just trying to console Mark was all ... "
"Jessie, don't try to sell me that load of shit ... you saw an opportunity to hurt your sister and you took it. I don't understand what the problem is between the two of you ... this goes beyond a normal sibling rivalry though."
"I wouldn't have ... fucked Mark if I knew she hadn't cheated on him ... you have to believe that mom!"
"I believe you, Jessie. But you shouldn't have fucked him at all. Not until they had talked things through and broke up."
"I'm sorry mom."
"Jessie, I'm not the one you need to talk to. Melissa is on her way back over now to talk to both of you ... the two of you need to solve whatever is going on between you. I don't know how she is going to handle Mark ... she is still very upset but she has calmed down somewhat. She is hurt and angry ... I can't blame her either. I get the feeling that she has some fault in all of this too. I suggest that you and Melissa figure out what it's going to take to put this rivalry to rest ... I told her the same thing just before she left here."
"She is on her way here now?!" Jessie says looking at me with fear.
"Yes, she left here about five minutes ago. She probably will be there in about thirty minutes. I strongly suggest that you and Mark be prepared for her ... Jessie, Melissa is your sister ... you will treat her as a sister. Settle your differences and let's move on from this mess."
"OK mom ... I will, talk to you later."
Hanging up the phone, Jessie looks at me almost trembling.
"Mark ... should I stay?"
"We both are going to have to deal with her wrath sometime ... we might as well deal with it together. I have no illusion that she is going to stay with me after all of this ... I guess I hope you two can get over this at least. Like your mom said, you two will always be sisters. If you don't mind me asking, what is the problem between you and Melissa?"
"It's difficult for me to say. It's really personal. I don't know if I can tell Mel myself. She hurt me but she doesn't even know it herself."
"I hope you can work it out, sooner or later."
"I guess we'll see soon enough," she says.
Waiting for Melissa to get here was incredibly difficult on both of us. We had no idea what type of mood she would be in. We know she will still be angry though. Then we both heard a knock on the door. We both figured Melissa wouldn't use her key this time. Although I'm sure she knows she won't find the same thing she did before.
As I open the door and she walks inside, I can tell she has calmed down quite a bit. But her mood is very serious.
"I see your lover is still here ... actually, I'm glad you're still here, Jessie. I think we all need to talk."
Obviously, Melissa is still quite angry about everything. But at least she isn't yelling at us anymore.
Melissa says, "I think we all need to deal with what happened today ... together. Let's go to Mark's room so we can have some privacy."
Melissa begins walking down the hallway. Turning to look at us, we follow her as well. As Melissa enters the room ahead of us, she notices that the linen on the bed has been changed.
"Thanks for at least cleaning up," she says sarcastically.
