Quick Summary: I had eaten out and tit-fucked my Aunt Julie (Ch. 01). After an emotional night I fucked my cousin Jenny up against my bedroom wall (Ch. 02), then had a naughty 69 (Ch. 03), and finally anal followed by oral with ass to mouth for both of us (Ch. 04). The night ended with anal sex in the shower before we finally fell asleep (Ch. 05).
------
I stretched as I woke, and I could already tell I had slept in late. I looked over at the clock and it was after 5pm. Holy crap where had the day gone! More importantly, where had Jenny gone?
I half wondered if it had all been a dream: a night of love making and fucking with my cousin, yeah it was 'one for the ages' I thought. Those had been Jenny's words, and somehow, I now knew what she meant.
After rinsing in the shower, I put on some shorts and a tee, then made my way into the grand room of the Lake House. Looking out one window you could see mountains, and through another there were trees down to the lakeside and a small dock.
As I entered the kitchen, I found my Aunt Julie. "There's Mr. Sleepy Head!" She was a bundle of energy and always had a smile. "Sandwiches are in the fridge if you want. Make a drink and join us outside."
And with that Julie went out back and left me standing there. As if nothing was wrong.
It was surreal, since I knew she knew what happened last night. And what had happened with Aunt Julie on their first night here... I had lusted over her magnificent tits for years. She used that to her advantage, trying to manipulate me into doing something. I played along. After all, not only did I finally get to see those tits, but also, I got to touch and play with them, to fuck them and cum on them.
But maybe nothing was wrong. Maybe that was how that was going to play out, and I was reading more into it than needed to be. It was as if we were ships that passed in the night.
The next ship was her daughter, my cousin Jenny. I had always liked her, even drew pictures of her in school. She was fun, smart and pretty. And I found out she was full of love and lust. She knew how to fuck, how to please. Pent-up desire and sexual energy had been released, hitting us like an avalanche.
I made a jack-n-coke, then went out to face the music.
"Hello everyone," I said trying to play it cool, and even that was awkward. I didn't know who knew what or where everything stood. I took off my shirt, then slipped into the hot tub, careful not to spill my drink as I lowered into the warm bubbly waters.
Then the girls glanced at each other. There was something odd in the way they were they mouthing things and making some gesture with their hands -- but I didn't know sister-speak, so I let it go.
Josie got up. She removed her towel and left it on the lounge. Then she came over to the hot tub and climbed in. She was in a yellow bikini, and it was hard not to stare as she slowly lowered herself into the water. Josie was athletic, slender and fit. She was hot and her perky breasts beckoned me.
As if on cue, Jenny did the same. Her bikini was light blue. With long brown hair and big eyes, she had the curves in all the right places. Her ample breasts looked lovely -- had she chosen that to show off her cleavage and side boob? I appreciated her either way.
Jenny climbed into the hot tub with us. "Ugh," she exclaimed in discomfort as she sat down. "I'm going to be sore for days." She looked up and winked at me, and I mouthed her a kiss.
"Oh really," Josie had a look of curiosity and admiration. "You don't say." She had an air about her, like a nosy person who uncovers a secret. She was excited, as if the game was on now.
The two were now positioned on either side of me. I was momentarily aroused by having two beautiful girl cousins in the hot tub with me. But then I was nervous. It was almost like predators closing in on their prey, trapping me between them.
"You know, I feel left out," Josie started first. "Since I'm the only one here Jack hasn't been eaten out. Yet." Josie looked at me both questioningly and naughtily, as if to say it would happen, eventually.
Aunt Julie nearly spit out her drink. "I think I'm going inside for a bit," she got up to go inside. "You two play nice with your cousin Jack." She added. Why did she need to say that?
But Jenny just looked at Josie, smiling as if to say, you can't do anything to me now.
"And it seems you two went all the way. I must know, Jack. Was it everything you hoped for?" She said this trying to needle someone. I figured it was still sibling rivalry.
I wasn't sure what to say, or if I should say anything at all. I decided I could only be honest, be myself, and let the cards fall where they may. I thought about the night we just had. And then something in the back of my mind made me remember the words she used.
"It was a magical moment in time," I was looking at Jenny. "One for the ages." She blew me a kiss.
Josie had started to say something, then stopped. Her sister Jenny then held up her index finger, looking at her sister. "Nope, not yet." Josie said, apparently to Jenny.
I wasn't sure of the significance. I took a sip of my drink, trying to figure out what was going on. I had a sinking feeling it wasn't going to be good for me.
"Jack," Josie was a predator cat, playing with her mouse toy. "Did you two, you know, do the nasty?"
"Uh," I paused and looked over at Jenny. I wanted to extract myself out of this. But I also recalled what we did, and certainly hope we would get to play all summer. Oddly Jenny wasn't stopping the conversation. It was quite the predicament.
Jenny noticed and helped. "It's OK Jack," she added. "You can answer the questions. I'm not ashamed of anything. I hope you aren't either." With that she nodded upwards, flicking her head towards her sister, and indicating it was fine to continue and answer her.
"Yeah, we went all the way."
"We knew
that
" Josie countered. "The walls made noise." Josie was oddly persistent.
"Well, if you heard us..." I suggested with logic.
"After dinner," Josie explained, "I put on my headphones and was listening to podcasts all night."
"What do you want me to say? I loved every part of her, and she loved every part of me." I gave an answer, still was hesitant to give specifics.
"Nope, I need details," the choice of words seemed curious, or was I just over thinking it. "What I mean was, did you get nasty. Did you eat her ass?" She was talking naughty and seductive. Jenny shifted, but she was sore and flinched every time she moved.
"We did lots of things," I replied vaguely.
Jenny held up her index finger again.
"Nope, not yet," Josie denied her. "I need to know Jack, did you or did you not eat your own cum from Jenny's ass?"
Holy shit?! "How the hell did you know..." my voice tapered off. What was going on?! My head was spinning, I was losing control of the situation. Maybe I never had control.
"Just answer the question, yes or no," Josie was hot now, and wouldn't be denied. I felt like I was under interrogation.
"It's OK Jack," Jenny offered. She was strangely OK with this conversation. But then, a lot of unusual things had happened lately. I had sex with my cousin in a variety of positions and locations. If I had used logic and reason, none of it would have happened.
"Yes," I gave in.
Jenny put her index finger up again, smiling in victory, unable to control the excitement.
"You really did it?" Josie was beside herself, her facial muscles contorted in amazement and disbelief.
"I did."
"What did she promise to get you to go through with it?"
"What?" I asked, confused. It was if they had talked about it already. Were the sisters really that close?
"What was the price, I just want to know," Josie asked.
"Sex with her all summer long, anything I wanted."
"Anything?" Josie asked incredulously, looking over at her sister with a knowing cock to her eyebrow. What was she getting at?
"Anything," Jenny replied. She smiled, still giggling and happy with herself.
