"And you've assessed all applicable case law?"
I'm on zoom, talking about an important case with my paralegals. Lockdown has just begun, our entire state is shut down. Usually I manage a team of law staff at the office, now we're having to do it online.
"Yes."
"I'm not hearing confidence in that 'yes'. Go back, ensure that we have watertight precedents that this article was not defamatory."
"Sure."
"By 9am tomorrow I want better details."
"No problem."
"Get on it."
We end the call. I don't have the greatest confidence in my staff, but the confidence I do have is shattered by having to conduct our case online. Usually I'm in the room, going over the law and previous cases. I'm in my smart black business suit and heels, my paralegals can feel the consequences that will come down on them if they miss anything.
But now, at home, I don't have that authority. Online is too distant, it lacks that team spirit where I inspired, with toughness and understanding, the most successful law firm in the state.
I get up and go to make myself some coffee. Immediately my day is made worse by the sight of dirty dishes. Just before lockdown my son Matthew dropped out of college. He was studying law, I was his role model, yet it's only freshman year and he's out. Couldn't handle it he said. But I know he's a bright kid and had the potential to be where I am. Now it's just us at home, for who knows how long, and he has no prospects.
I'm going to shout. "Matt get down here." No answer. I go up to his room and try to open the door. It's jammed, I bang and shout again.
"What?" I hear.
"The kitchen's filthy. Clean it now."
"One minute."
"No now." If I allow a minute it won't be done today. I continue to bang loud enough to annoy him. When I hear the rug being moved to unjam the door, I start to go downstairs.
Matthew comes down after me. It's a shame because I look at him and I feel such a mix. The overwhelming love of a mother is there as strongly as when I held that newborn - my only child - on my chest. Yet disappointment threatens to cloud that love. He has potential he's not fulfilling. Not that it matters so much in lockdown but his facial structure is classically handsome and his blue eyes shine. He could attract a beautiful girl, yet he's letting himself become one of those, I think the expression is, neckbeard incels. He was always smart. Elementary school Matthew topped all his classes, but high school Matthew sank into indiscipline and aimlessness.
Despite my efforts the loss of his father at a young age affected him, but perhaps I spent too many hours at the office. At least now we have this time together, I want us to find closeness again and put his life on the right path.
He starts washing the dishes and I make myself a coffee.
"Hazelnut latte?" I ask him.
He shakes his head and keeps washing.
"No thank you." I say, in my manners-maketh-man voice.
"No."
"No thank you."
"Mom no."
I see there's little chance of getting more out of him, so I leave him to clean. As he finishes, I ask "what you doing in there."
"Just a game."
"Which one?" Perhaps if I'm friendly, he'll open a little and I can get through to him. It doesn't work so I lay down rules.
"Thirty minutes then stop."
"What?"
"It will be time to cook dinner then. And you're on it enough."
"Everyone else is on it more."
"Not the ones who are studying."
He rolls his eyes at me and goes back upstairs. I'm going to stick to it, thirty minutes I want him to help make the lasagne. Then clean the bathroom. If he won't study he can work.
I wait the half hour, then repeat the fight with the rug, the banging, and the negative energy that emerges. I tell him to come downstairs, we're going to cook.
"I'm not hungry."
"You will be in an hour when it's ready."
"Can't we order pizza?"
"No we eat healthily in this house. Come."
He comes down. I ask him to take the canned tomatoes out. He grunts. Then I ask him to grate a block of cheese. He grunts. But he does both of these things.
I try and make conversation "any girls you're playing your game with?" But I just get a head shake. He's not emotionally articulate my Matthew. So I leave it, I let the awkward silence marinade the atmosphere until the lasagne is ready to go in the oven.
He was helpful, I'll give him that, I just wish there was a way to bring back passion for something other than gaming. As I place the lasagne in the oven and turn it on, he goes to leave the kitchen.
"Where are you going?"
"It takes an hour."
"I said enough screen time. We're going to clean."
"Clean what?"
"Clean the house we live in."
"Mom no."
"Someone has to do it and we can't hire anyone while we're all at home."
"No."
He turns back round to go upstairs but I won't let him. I walk up to him and grab his left arm to pull him back. He tries to shake me off.
"We've got cleaning."
"Later."
"Now." My voice gets louder and slightly deeper, I feel something of what I do when I'm in the office.
"Just one game."
"No now." I pull at his arm again, he pulls me off, but as he does he turns round to shake himself free. The buildup of annoyance is too much, the frustration of lockdown combined with his dropping out, then his refusal to clean - I can't keep my annoyance in check. With my right hand I slap his left cheek as hard as I can, slightly scratching him with my nails.
Shocked, he runs upstairs. I don't chase after him. I tell him "I'll say sorry once you've cleaned." As he gets in his room I hear furniture being moved. No doubt he wants to keep his door barricaded from his mother.
I sit down in the lounge and think about what happened. Was it wrong? We're told nowadays physical punishment is abuse. But if that's true haven't I already failed? I have a dropout with no prospects for a son.
Yet I won't doubt that part of me enjoyed the slap. How often I've longed to do the same to my paralegals when they mess up. Discipline, chastisement, myself in the position of power and ability to punish - I like it.
After an hour the lasagne's ready so I call down. No answer. But I know I'll win, no man's stubbornness ever beats his hunger. I eat my share and wait for him. It takes another hour but I hear again the furniture move. A door upstairs opens and Matthew comes down.
I watch him go to take his lasagne. He puts some on a plate and I can tell he's about to leave the kitchen.
"Where are you going sit down." He knows we don't take plates upstairs.
"Can I just chill?"
"Finish your meal first."
"I just want to eat in peace."
"Do that here."
I notice Matthew's face turn red. Anger and annoyance at my rules is welling up. My expression shows I will not budge in this, his exasperation boils over. He smashes the plate into the wall, spraying lasagne everywhere. He's messy, the kitchen's messy, luckily I stayed back.
This does not get sympathy. "Clean it."
"Why are you so in my face, always fucking telling me what to do?"
"Somebody has to take care of you."
"Why did it have to be you? Cancer got the wrong parent."
He says it, he says it strong enough to mean it, but I know from the tiny waters in his eyes he regrets saying it. He steps back, mumbles, then says "I'm, I'm sorry."
"Clean it and we'll talk."
I go to the lounge. I hear him throw the bits of plate in the trash, spray the walls and floor, even mop. He comes in looking apologetic and I tell him "Good boy."
He sits down across from me. He looks down, ashamed yet I feel as if he wants to open to me. I sense he won't speak first so I start.
"If I'm strict it's partly because I want a nice house but also because I'm upset that you've dropped out."
"It's my life."
"But mine too you're living off me."
"I'll get a job."
"Doing what?"
"Streamer maybe."
"Are you even streaming?"
He shakes his head.
"Baby I just tried to support you."
"Yeah great job mom. You were never here."