We sat in the chairs at the funeral home catching up on the last ten years or so. My cousin Cathy sat in the row in front of us and Jen and I sat with one chair between us. We formed kind of a triangle sitting there at my uncle's funeral. Cathy and I had grown up together and we had always been close. We haven't stayed in touch as much as I would have liked but life seems to turn out that way sometimes. But here we were, laughing and smiling and just trading stories about our kids, our jobs, our relationships and just everything that has happened since we last spoke at any length. It was going so well that I barely realized that we hadn't really spoken to anyone else throughout the entire wake. When it was time to leave, we said our good-byes and hugged tightly. I knew I would see her tomorrow at the funeral so it was short and sweet.
Then something odd happened. Jen, my long-time girlfriend and sexual soul mate asked me something.
"So Cathy...did you have sex with her?"
I had just started my truck and was about to back out of the parking space when I jerked my eyes up to meet her gaze.
"Excuse me?" I asked surprised.
"You two have a history, I can tell. Don't be upset, I'm not mad, I just want to know."
I backed out of the space and dismissively told her, "She's my first cousin."
"I don't believe you", she said with conviction.
"She turns completely toward you, her legs are open, she makes total eye contact and you lean in so close that it is obvious that you two are into one another."
I thought about that for a second as I felt her eyes penetrating my uncomfortable silence.
Let me explain a little history that Jen was not aware of that took place about 10 years ago. Cathy lived just down the block from me and we were the same age. Her father and my mother were brother and sister and so they were always over at our house. We had a Nintendo back then and nobody else did so she would come play it once in a while with me. I would always sit on this little padded bench to play and one day, I had her sit, straddling the bench with me between my legs and I wrapped my arms around her so that the controller was in front of her and my arms were around her waist. She leaned back into me and it was very arousing for a boy like me. It didn't bother me at all that she was my cousin then. I remember smelling her hair and feeling her sexy young body against my own. When my turn was over, she took over and my hands fell between her thighs. At that age I had no idea what to do with them and they would sometimes rest on her tan thighs and other times I would just wrap them around her waist and hold her. I was an 18 yo boy who had only had sex once before. She was barely 18 and I had no idea if she was still a virgin or not.
This happened more and more often and I got more and more brave each and every time it occurred. One day, I remember squeezing and massaging the inside of her thighs maybe 2 inches from her young pussy. I know she felt my hard on against her back and I was very disappointed when she had to leave. I had to wait for some time before I could get up and walk back into the family living room. There were times when I was able to grab her young ass and I even, a time or two, grabbed her wrist and forced her hand behind her back and between my legs where she rubbed my hard on through my shorts. But we never took it farther than that.
Back to that night at the wake. Jen and I have had an open relationship for years and she loves to role play with me often. I have been many guys she has desired and she has been even more women I have desired. That night, on the drive home, she told me that she wanted to be Cathy and asked me how I felt about it. I have to admit, I was rock hard when she mentioned it and I managed to agree in a way as if I was doing it for her.
Yeah, right!! I have always been excited by the prospect of having sex with my cousin but I would never expect anything to happen. That night, Jen pretended she was Cathy and I told her everything! I told her about the bench and about how I had all but forced her to rub my cock when we were both younger. She was so hot and she got so wet that by the time I got out of the shower and got my cockring on, she was naked on the padded bench at the foot of our bed.
We sat exactly like I had with my cousin all those years ago but this time, I got to have my way with her. I whispered in her ear how badly I have wanted to touch her for the past 10+ years and told her how I couldn't wait to feel my cousin's pussy squeezing me. I took her shirt off and played with her nipples as I kissed her over her shoulder and spoke "Cathy" as often as I could fit it in. I told her to stand up and I took her shorts off.
"Cathy, your body is so sexy", I reassured her.
"Joe, we are cousins, we shouldn't."
I pulled her to me and she instinctively straddled the bench and me. I immediately slid into her dripping pussy and I passionately told "Cathy" that nothing was stopping us now.
"Joe, no. Joe, stop. Joe you're my cousin."
She pleaded with me to stop and I loved her every word.
I fucked Jen all over our bedroom and in every position you can imagine all while she played the part of my sexy cousin Cathy. It was the most taboo thing I had ever done with her.
We smiled so big seeing Cathy the following day at the funeral through our tears. Afterwards, we attended a huge family dinner in town and we sat with Cathy and her husband. The conversation was really mundane and they ended up leaving early. Slightly disappointing but that is not where the story ends.
Fast forward two weeks and I get a text while I am at the gym.
"Your cousin is coming up this evening to go out with us."