All characters in this story are at least eighteen years old.
I woke up the next morning with Sharen lying next to me. She looked so peaceful sleeping. She reminded me of her sister almost as much as Jamie did. I lay back down and replayed the events of the day before in my head along with the conversation that I wanted to have with Jamie. As it turned out I needed to have a conversation with both Jamie and Sharen since they planned everything together.
Sharen was lying on her stomach with her head facing me. I kissed her on the cheek and while still under the covers, I climbed on top of her. Thinking about fucking the three of them the day before got me worked up and I wanted to have Sharen before I got up to make breakfast for everyone.
While bracing myself with one arm, I used my other hand to brush my cock up and down Sharen's slit, hoping to get her wet. My hopes of slipping inside her before she woke were broken when she opened her eyes and turned slightly to look at me.
"Ready to fuck me already, are you?" she said.
"When have I ever not been?"
She spread her legs open just as I felt moisture at the head of my dick.
"Then fuck me, babe," she whispered.
I did as she requested and slowly slid inside her, inch my inch. I exhaled when I was fully in her and began to slowly fuck her. She moved her arms so that her head was resting on her hands, still looking the same way.
"Sometimes it's nice to just sit here and feel your cock, slide in and out of me," she said.
"I like this position. I'm also an ass man so, that helps I guess."
"You? An ass man?" she asked sarcastically.
I snickered and quickly buried my cock deep in her pussy before fucking her hard and fast for a bit. She grunted loudly.
"Fuck me hard, little brother," she whispered with her eyes closed.
"I am sis!"
I had to admit, the role play turned me on even more. I kept going until I felt the cum that had been building up in my balls give signal it was on its way.
"I want to cum on your ass, sis!"
"Do it, baby brother. Shoot your cum all over my ass," she said, looking back at me again.
I pulled out of her pussy and stroked my cock, pushing the head against her asshole.
"Coat my asshole with your baby juice!"
Just then, I released. It splattered all over her asshole, but some managed to jump out and make little pools in the small of her back.
"You have a powerful shot, little brother. I think some went in my ass," she told me.
"I would guess I did if that was the case," I said, laughing a little, "I'll get you a towel then I'll go make breakfast for everyone."
I handed her a towel, then got dressed in my pajamas. I felt that day was going to be a lot like the day before, so I didn't even bother getting into regular clothes. I swung by Jamie's room to see if they were up. The door was open, and they were both sound asleep. It seemed they were either playing around all night or they had been as worn out as I was. I continued to the kitchen to make pancakes and eggs.
Sharen was the first one out. She came up to me and kissed me before fixing herself a cup of coffee.
"What did you want to talk to Jamie about?" she asked as she poured the creamer into the mug.
"Well, I want to talk to both of you. I don't want an answer now from you, but I'll ask you both what your intentions are or maybe were when you developed this plan. Maybe you had one intention when you started, but another now? I don't know but what I do know is that I can't just keep fucking the three of you every time I get turned on," I said.
"I actually have all of those answers." She said, sipping her coffee.
I turned around and looked at her.
"I'm not sworn to secrecy, and we honestly have no further plans. I don't know if she planned to ever talk to you about it or not, but I assumed she would now that every part of the plan worked out."
"Do you think she would want you telling me?" I asked, neglecting breakfast.
"Flip those pancakes. I'll tell you the story, but you have to promise to at least give her until tomorrow before you broach the subject with her."
I turned around continued prepping breakfast when Sharen came up and stood next time.
"I asked her the same question when she first asked to have sex with me. That was when she was sixteen and she didn't have an answer. I asked her again that night we talked for hours. That was the same night she shared that she would maybe one day approach you."
"Okay, so, she had a plan the second time?" I asked.
"Yes. So, her plan didn't start off that far-fetched," she said, "and remember, you promised not to say anything today!"
I nodded at her, and she continued.
"She wants to marry Katerina," Sharen said.
"That's it?" I asked, feeling like she wasn't done.
"No. She hinted at us getting married."
"You and her?!" I asked, turning my attention away from breakfast again.
"No, dummy, me and you," she said, looking at me, trying to judge my reaction.
"Okay," I said, "that's not way off base like you suggested."
"I'm not done," she said, still staring at me.
I put the utensils I had on the table, faced Sharen and folded my arms.
"Spit it out."
She stared at me for a few moments before speaking again.
"She is bisexual, but she is in love with Kat. She wants a child one day, but doesn't want - "
"Stop right there!" I demanded.
She didn't press the conversation, but continued staring into my eyes, looking for something. In my heart, I knew what she was about to say but I spent a long time going over every other possibility before I allowed myself to feel something about what I knew she was about to tell me. When not another possible outcome presented itself, decided to resign myself to what I knew was going to be said.
"She wants me to get her pregnant?" I asked, hoping it wasn't true.
Sharen looked around the room for an appropriate response. She sighed and looked back at me, then sipped her coffee.
"Remember, you didn't hear it from me. I hope she comes to you about all of this," she reminded me.
I returned to breakfast right as Kat walked in. Jamie was shortly behind her. They had the best and worst timing that morning. I had to contemplate everything in my head until she came to me about it. I put the food on four plates as Jamie approached me. She turned me around and hugged me and I noticed Sharen staring me. Her eyes were wide, and she was gently shaking her head, seeming in a panic that I would confront Jamie about what we talked about. I nodded slightly to try and reassure her.
"Good morning, Daddy!" she said, kissing me on the cheek before going to sit.
"Morning, baby. Do you want bacon or sausage?"
"Bacon for me. Kat wants bacon, too. We could smell it all the way in my room. That's why we came out here."
"Sharen?"
"Just pancakes for me, please," she replied.
I finished filling the plates and brought them to the table and sat. It seemed almost an awkward silence. I occasionally looked around for a bit before striking up conversation.
"Kat, will you be here again for dinner?"
She looked at Jamie, then back at me.
"No, I've got some work to do at home tonight that I've been putting off. Wish I could, though!"
I looked at Jamie.
"What about you? Have anything planned today?" I asked, feeling a little weird acting the role of a father after what happened the day before.
"Nope, no plans. Thought I would just hang out with both of you," she said, looking between me and Sharen.
"Sounds good to me. I didn't have anything planned either. Might mow the lawn, but that's all that's in the cards today," I said.
I looked over at Kat and she looked a little restless.
"You okay, Kat?" I asked.
She looked around the table at everyone, took a bite of her bacon and just blurted out what everyone was thinking.
"So, are we just going to pretend we all didn't fuck each other yesterday?"
I snorted a little, Jamie snapped her head to stare at Kat and Sharen covered her mouth, attempting to hide her laughter. She wasn't very good at hiding it and after a few minutes, she was belly laughing but still trying to hide it. Eventually, we all joined in with her.
After we calmed down, Jamie spoke up.
"I don't think we're pretending anything. I just think we should take some time this morning and let it all sink in and maybe talk about it later?" she ended up asking, looking at me.