I pulled my pants back up, my erection drifting back down. Completely speechless, I waited some time to collect my thoughts before swimming back. Did that seriously just happen? I couldn't be more excited about the prospect of what "I owe you one for later," meant. If I hadn't just finished jerking off I'm sure I'd be rock hard all over again. Still though, that was pretty reckless of me to just jerk off in the middle of the day like that without at least looking behind me to make sure Caitlyn wasn't still there. I guess I couldn't feel too dumb about it though, she definitely enjoyed watching me.
By the time I had relaxed a bit and was ready to swim back, the girls were all heading back inside. It was about lunch time, so I watched from a distance as Jess and Taylor and Caitlyn's hips swayed side to side as they walked away, their bubbly butts lifting and releasing with each step. Casey must have already been inside. Once they were at the porch, I swam back, grabbed my towel and dried off, then put my shirt back on and headed inside.
Once inside I saw all the girls seated at the dining table. My parents made hot dogs and burgers for lunch and everyone was already eating. The dining table was only meant for four people to sit at once, but there was an extra chair for me at the corner next to Jess and across from Casey. I walked up to the table, avoiding looking at Caitlyn entirely, as I knew once my eyes meandered her way it would be too hard to look away.
"Hey, Jess?" I asked as I stood next to her.
"Hey Andy, good to see you again!" Jess smiled.
"Could I bother you to stand up for a second so I could slide past you and sit down?"
"Yeah, no problem," Jess replied.
It wasn't until Jess stood up that I realized just how tall she was. She was probably six feet tall, maybe even an inch or two taller than that. She had a tank top on but had nothing else over her thin bikini bottoms and her legs looked incredibly smooth and long.
Once she was standing I slid past her from behind, unable to avoid brushing up against her. As I did this, it was almost as if she subtly bent her knees to press her butt back into me. I didn't think much of it though, it was probably an accident.
"How's the weather up there?" Casey called out to Jess in a teasingly distant voice.
"Oh you're just jealous I'm the best spiker in our entire division," Jess replied. "You wish you were this tall," she said. As Jess sat back down, her straight orangey-red, shoulder length hair bobbed left and right while she laughed.
I took my seat in between Jess and Taylor.
"Hey Taylor," I said.
"Hi Andy," she replied. I had only met Jess and Taylor once before, but I knew that "Hi," was probably all Taylor was going to say. She was extremely introverted and shy, and a typical bookworm with big black, thick rimmed glasses. She almost seemed out of place with the other three girls, but Casey had told me once she was the fiercest volleyball player on their team, and that she really opens up once you get to know her.
When I sat down I favored the side to Jess, not wanting to make Taylor feel uncomfortable with being so close to her. Being a bit of an introvert myself, I felt she probably preferred a little more space, while I didn't mind sitting a little closer to Jess. With everyone crammed around the table as it was, my leg pressed up against Jess's, and it was quiet for a few minutes while everyone enjoyed their food. I plated a burger and grabbed the bottle of ketchup, but after a few taps on the bottom nothing came out. I shook it once more, this time with some force, and a flood of ketchup poured over my hamburger bun.
"Way to go!" Casey was the first to announce while clapping her hands.
"Shut up Casey!" I said smiling back, "it was an accident."
"You think you've got enough there?"
"I happen to like this much ketchup on my burger," I proclaimed.
Casey laughed, then raised an eyebrow and tilted her head down while still looking up at me for a moment as if to say, 'yeah, ok,' but said nothing else.
It was quiet for another few moments again, during which time Jess began to tap her heel up and down, probably just a tick she was unaware of, but it got me thinking about her long silky legs as her calf rubbed against mine. While eating and pretending to look down at my plate I glanced over at Jess. Her tank top just barely covered her bottoms and it looked as if she wasn't wearing anything at all underneath. I started to imagine her bare ass pressed against the seat of the chair. I looked up slowly towards her torso. Jess was the thinnest of all the girls, and also had the smallest breasts, but like Caitlyn they accentuated her body perfectly. I could tell I was getting excited again and quickly looked away, now looking directly at my food to avoid staring at both Jess and Caitlyn now, which was increasingly difficult as Jess' leg started to rub up and down against mine with a little more vigor.
"Hey Andy," Casey said, "Could you pass that ketchup bottle? I mean, if you're done with it, that is."
"Oh hell no," I said. "Not after the shit you just gave me about it. I'm not just going to hand it over to you."
"Oh come on," Casey said. "You almost used up a month's worth of ketchup and you won't let me have a teeny little bit more?" Casey put on a pouty frown and looked through a small space she made between her fingers to emphasize her point.
"Nope," I responded. "Not going to happen. You're just going to have to stand up and try and reach it on your own."
"Fine!" Casey said as she stood up. She was clad in her bikini attire, not bothering to cover up like Jess had. As she leaned over the table to reach the bottle, I slowly inched it closer to me and farther from her. Looking up at her I noticed a wry smile on her face.
