Chapter One: Eva
Noah's fingers inside her didn't feel the same as her father's. Noah's were clumsier, more tentative- but they still felt really good. Eva moaned into a kiss as his fingers made her more and more slippery. Noah was her first real boyfriend, and the first guy she'd had sex with since Daddy. He was a transfer student, and shared her love of art- and sex. He was always nice to her, and made her feel beautiful and cherished. Luckily Daddy approved of Noah, and as long as Eva shared every detail of their intimate time together, she was permitted to see him often.
That was one of the many rules of their rather unconventional religion- that Eva had to confess all of her sexual exploits to her father. Daddy and Father David said that it was to ensure that she was being treated well and that she was pleasing her partner properly, but Eva always saw the familiar bulge in Daddy's pants after she was done telling him.
Noah moved down her body, kissing and worshipping every inch until his head was between her legs. He licked her clit greedily, again lacking Daddy's finesse but earning a moan and a shiver nonetheless. She could feel her orgasm building, and had to remind herself that she didn't need to ask Noah permission to cum- that was only when she was with Daddy.
"Noah, I'm cumming!" she exclaimed, and leaned into the explosion coursing through her body. He looked up at her, his boyish face looking smug, her wetness still glistening on his chin. "Please fuck me," she breathed- and he did.
Eva slid into her panties and got dressed- her curfew was 11pm, and she never missed it- my, how things had changed since her and Daddy found Father David. She squeezed her legs together in an attempt to keep Noah's seed inside her, knowing that Daddy would be inspecting her as soon as she got through the door. She kissed Noah goodbye, breathing a sigh of contentment before heading home.
Chapter Two: Michael
At precisely 10:48pm, Michael heard Eva's car door shut in the driveway. He never worried about her being out- not since their summer at the cabin with Father David. While she had been unruly in her early teens, at 18 she was now a model of obedience. Michael had implicit trust that Eva would be home by curfew- she really was such a good girl.
"In the kitchen," Michael called when he heard the front door close. Eva appeared before him, her cheeks still flushed by her time with Noah. "Did you have fun?" Michael asked knowingly.
"Yes Daddy," Eva said quietly.
"Let's see."
With that, Eva removed her clothes, gingerly stepping out of her panties and handing them to her father. Michael inhaled into them deeply, all but tasting his daughter's sweetness mixed with a male musk. He looked his daughter up and down, admiring her generous curves and bashful smile.
"Hop up on the table and tell Daddy what happened," Michael commanded. Eva obediently perched her naked self on the edge of the table, sitting up straight with her hands behind her back. Michael explored her open mouth with his fingers, pressing them as far back in her throat as he could. He mentally counted to five before she coughed them out. "Did he put his cock there?" Michael asked clinically.
"Yes, Daddy," Eva confessed at the end of her cough, "and I counted to five every time."
"Good girl," Michael said as he cupped her left breast. "What else happened?"
Eva began to explain every kiss and touch between her and Noah while Michael continued with his inspection. He cupped each perfect breast, ostensibly checking for hickies or marks, but perhaps accidentally tweaking her nipples just to watch them harden.
"He fingered my pussy, and then licked my clit until I came," Eva said casually. Michael gently pushed on her shoulders to signal her to lay back on the kitchen table.
"Open your legs baby," Michael reminded her as she continued to talk.
Eva opened her legs wide, fully exposing her bare and still glistening pussy to her father. "He put his cock in my pussy, first in missionary with my legs on his shoulders. Then we switched to doggy style, and he held me by the hair. It pulled a little, but it felt good. He came inside me during doggy," she said matter-of-factly.
Michael spread her pussy lips, holding her tiny hole open to admire the milky inside. "I can see that," he said proudly, "good girl. Always make sure the cum goes inside you, whether in your pussy, ass, or mouth," he reminded her.
"Yes daddy, even if he cums on my face I make sure he feeds it to me after."
"That's my girl," Michael said. "Now go get ready for bed." With a gentle pat on her round ass, Michael dismissed his naked daughter.
He watched her skip to the shower, and then turned back to the kitchen to get a glass of water before turning into bed. He was not permitted to use or fuck his daughter outside of sanctioned church events (such as summer camp at the cabin, holiday retreats, and special events), but that didn't stop him from thinking about it. Father David said that having unrestricted use of one's daughter would lead to entitlement and jealousy, which Michael could understand- if he had permission to use his daughter whenever he wanted, he may lose sight of the purpose of the practice, which was to teach obedience, skill, and respect.
He adjusted his half hard cock in his pyjama pants as he thought about the perfect little creampie in his daughter's pussy. Inspections were some of his favourite interactions with her, so he allowed her to see Noah often. He was a good kid, and treated Eva well- plus he had a fairly large cock according to his daughter, which Michael supposed was good practice.
He tucked Eva into her bed with a chaste kiss on the forehead, reminding her that he was proud of her and thankful for her respect and obedience.
"I love you Daddy," she said sleepily.
It was that gentle sound that played through his head as he came that night.