"I can't believe you, Rachel. How could you even suggest such a thing?" I looked at my wife. Her lips were curled up in a curious expression. I would say she was feeling a bit embarrassed, but nevertheless resolute.
"Dan, I don't feel right about mother going out with these strange men. So many creeps out there, and after that last one..."
"Yeah well, it's not like you asked if I could just take her to a movie or something." Quite the contrary; to my utter disbelief my wife Rachel had just asked me to have sex with her mother.
"Dan, why do you think she goes out with these men? She's not really looking for companionship from them. She has other needs too; you know mother as well as I do when it comes to this subject."
Rachel was right about that. I'd known her mother Sylvia since I was a teenager and Rachel and I had started dating. She was a classy woman in her own way, with a great sense of style, but she was also quite the bawdy woman once you got to know her well enough. I had no doubt she had a highly charged sex drive to boot.
"That doesn't mean I'm the one who should be 'helping' her out."
"Don't you find her attractive?"
I was amazed that my wife had switched to this line of questioning. The truth was; Sylvia was extremely good-looking. In fact, I had been drawn to her like a moth to a flame from the moment I first met her; not only did she have strikingly good looks but she just oozed sex appeal, carrying that whole sexy older woman vibe perfectly. She had aged well too; after ten years of knowing her I thought she was more alluring than ever.
That was part of why I was recoiling at Rachel's idea so strongly right now. Frankly, I had always had a "thing" for my mother-in-law; I'd even had numerous sexual fantasies about her over the years. But as far as I was concerned, anything with Sylvia should remain a fantasy, a forbidden fruit. The thought of crossing that line and causing whatever possible damage to my marriage and relationship with her was too horrifying to even consider making any of those thoughts a reality. And now my wife now was trying to convince me to have sex with Sylvia. Not only was I stunned, but I was petrified.
"Well Dan, I don't see how you can't understand the logic in all of this."
"No I don't, Rachel. I don't at all."
"I think you do. It's makes perfect sense to me. For one thing, you want sex all the time, dear. I can hardly keep up with you sometimes. If I didn't know you better I'd be worried about an affair..."
"Don't even say that. You know I wouldn't do that."
"I know Dan, that's what I'm saying. But I also know your sexual needs are much greater than mine. In that sense you're a lot like mother, except she doesn't have dad anymore. I want mother to be with someone I can trust, and I don't trust anyone in this world more than I trust you. I think my solution solves both problems perfectly."
"Perfectly? Rachel, you asked me to have sex with Sylvia. Your MOTHER. If you don't have a problem with that, you should."
"Well maybe it's not the perfect solution, but it's one I can live with. I don't want mother going out with any more of those creeps, and I know I can trust you both. Not to mention, I love you both more than anything. At least think about it Dan."
"You haven't even told me what Sylvia has to say about all of this. Does she think it's 'perfect' too?"
"As a matter of fact, she does. I know she feels closer to you than any other man she knows. After dad died, you were especially caring with her. I've never forgotten that Dan, and neither has she. Mother trusts you. When I told her my idea she was on board immediately with it."
Rachel's answer threw me for a bit of a loop. On the one hand, everything she said was true. I had always been close with Sylvia. And when John, my father in law, died, we grew even closer. But I would never have guessed that Sylvia wanted to have sex with me. And yet, for as long as I had known her I had always wondered if there had always been some sexual tension between us. She was very flirty with me, even going back to when I was just a kid starting to date her daughter. A touch on the arm here, an admiring glance there, plus all the suggestive remarks... so many of my sexual fantasies about Sylvia had been fueled by the way she acted towards me over the years. Sometimes I could swear there was something real behind all of it. And now, with what Rachel was telling me, all I could think about was maybe it was true. Sylvia wanted me, I wanted her, and my wife was practically begging us to do it. Or perhaps everything Rachel was telling me now was true. I still wasn't sure what to think at this point.
"Let me sleep on it, Rachel. We'll talk about this again tomorrow."
I wish I had slept that night, but I did nothing of the kind. Instead I lay bed, next to my soundly sleeping wife, and daydreamed about fucking the hell out of her sexy mother. I hadn't fantasized about Sylvia for a while, mostly out of respect for Rachel, but I couldn't help it now. Rachel was right, I did have a strong libido, and now that she had let it loose against her mother I was unable to stop the sexual thoughts from flooding my mind.
My thoughts jumped back and forth, picking out memories about Sylvia here and there, and recalling old fantasies I'd had about her. I remembered hanging around her house when I was a teenager. I'd be there to see Rachel, but often my eyes would wander to Sylvia. She worked in an office back then, and I'd see her come back home dressed in those business suits of hers. I always thought they must have had a very conservative dress code where she worked, because as professional as Sylvia looked in those suits they did little to show off her figure. And my god, was her figure amazing.
Sylvia had always managed to stay very fit, with a sexy hourglass figure. She had huge tits, probably something like F's. Whatever they were, with her sleek waistline they looked absolutely enormous. Even seeing her dressed up in those frumpy clothes, you could tell she had something special underneath. I think my curiosity about her breasts started that far back. All I could think about was how incredible it would be to see those big, beautiful tits in all their glory. After coming home from work she would start getting dinner ready before changing clothes, although she'd undo a couple of buttons on her blouse. The sight of Sylvia's exposed cleavage would drive me crazy back then, and I often fantasized that she was doing it intentionally to excite me.
I'm actually more of an ass man though, and while Sylvia's tits certainly stole the show with most men it her firm, apple shaped ass often held my attention. As I lay in bed now, my mind got overwhelmed with images of me banging against that sexy ass as I fucked Sylvia doggy style, those, F's giggling madly underneath as the big tit slut begged me to fuck her harder. I resisted the urge to masturbate to these thoughts for as long as I could, but eventually I couldn't resist the urge, making myself cum in a matter of seconds. Not that I really thought of Sylvia as a slut, but it did turn me on to fantasize about her this way. Besides all her flirting I knew enough of her past to say she wasn't the prim and proper young lady growing up. She'd been a real party girl in college, and I knew she had a hungry sex drive. Put all those elements together and it's wasn't hard for me to imagine her as being a horny slut in my fantasies.
Other times my mind wandered to more cherished moments we shared. I'll never forget those couple of weeks after my father in law died. I took some time off work to help settle his affairs and spent a good portion of it alone with Sylvia. I was her shoulder to cry on, and she was so sweet, so beautiful in her vulnerability. I didn't really expect any of that to translate sexually but on many occasions I found myself unwittingly desiring her. When that chaotic time was all over, I often found myself thinking back to those days when Sylvia and I were all alone in her house, and those thoughts eventually became fantasies. In them she'd tell me of her loneliness, of how she wished she could make the pain go away, if even only for a short time. We'd exchange knowing glances, both understanding what she meant, and soon enough we'd be holding hands on the way to her bedroom for us to make love.
I never really felt too guilty about having these types of daydreams about Sylvia. Sure, I was married to her daughter, but I always told myself that it was okay as long as they never affected my real life relationships with her or Rachel. Now my wife was trying to change all that. It was a scary idea, but I nevertheless couldn't help but be turned on by it.
Next morning came and my wife wasted little time in broaching this topic again, bringing it up during breakfast.
"Well Dan, you've had some time to think about it. What do you have to say?"
"I think I'm shocked that after all these years of faithful marriage that you're asking me to have sex with another woman. And not only that, but the woman is your mother. What the hell has gotten into you, Rachel?"
I had to take this hostile tone with her. This was a dangerous place Rachel was taking us, and I had to make sure she understood that.
"I appreciate what you're saying Dan, but it's not like you're going to have some romance with her. I think our marriage is strong enough to handle this. If I didn't then I would never have approached you with the idea. My relationship with mother is also strong enough to handle this too. I've talked about it with her and she feels the same way. You're the only one who seems to have doubts."