Chapter 4
"I get to pop her cherry." Their father said, his tone brooking no argument. Eric moaned in disappointment, but agreed. They both got up and switched positions. Suzy moved to get up, but they both told her to stay lying on her side. She obeyed and wondered what they were up to.
She felt her father spoon against her back, his cock hard again and pressing against the crack of her buttocks. He ran his hand along her hip up to her breasts and started caressing them roughly. Eric urged her to lift her leg up in the air with his hands and she complied. Her father's hand left her breasts, and she felt him positioning his cock head at her anus. A moment of panic went through her.
"No, it's too big daddy!" Suzy shook shrank away from him, but both men held her firm.
"It'll fit, don't you worry about that." Her father said, his voice thick with lust. Without waiting for her to reply, he started shoving his large prick into her anus. Suzy cried out in pain, but he kept shoving it in.
"No Daddy stop! It hurts too much!" Suzy pleaded as tears trickled down her face.
"Its alright girly, it'll hurt at first but once I get going it'll be better than you can imagine." Her father reassured her. Suzy cried out as his cock head forced its way in. Eric decided at that point to start licking her cunt, perhaps to distract her. It worked a bit, but not much. His cock was only half inside her, and she felt like he was splitting her open.
"Daddy please take it out!!" She cried, but he only pushed it in harder. Then torturously slow he started to pull it out. She was so relieved she said "Thank you daddy!" but too soon...he thrust his cock back in, and this time it went in easier, but no less painful.
"There, there sis, it'll feel great soon." Eric reassured her and continued tonguing her clit. After a few minutes of her father fucking her ass, the pain had dulled, and with her brother licking her clit it wasn't so bad. Her father's balls started slapping against her and she realized her father had managed to fit his whole cock inside her ass.
"Way to go dad!" Eric congratulated their father. He was fucking her ass hard now, and Suzy was surprised to find it was feeling good. "Ready for more Suzy?" Eric asked, but didn't wait for her answer. He lay down next to her, facing her, and aimed his cock at her pussy. She didn't bother to protest—they'd go ahead with it anyway, but she mentally grimaced at the thought of more pain. His fat cock head pushed at her opening and encountered resistance. "Damn dad, I can feel your cock inside her." Eric said and continued to push into Suzy.
Suzy was struck with how odd it felt as her father fucked her ass and her brother pushed his cock into her pussy, inch by inch, fighting for room. Finally Eric's cock went all the way in, and he paused there for a moment, feeling their father thrust his cock in and out. "I can feel your cock along side mine dad." Eric said in awe. Eric pulled his cock out just as their dad pushed his in, and they continued in that rhythm.