Current Crush Ch 03

Chapter Three: Doubts and Debauchery

Annabelle, like always, was stunned by what she read on her screen. The app had simply told her that she had to select one of the three people she deemed 'attractive' to have sex with. These were complete strangers to her and she had never been one to get into the usual dating app 'hookup culture.' This was too far... she had to do something. Maybe if someone helped her she could get this damn wristband off. Riley. It was obvious, of course Riley would understand, right? All she had to do was tell Riley about it and she could help her tear off this damn thing somehow.

Annabelle walked out of her bedroom, forgetting she said she was going to change, and back into the living room where Riley sits on the couch, setting up a movie. Riley looks up at her with a cute, welcoming smile. But as Annabelle looked at her, she suddenly lost her determination. She remembered the events of the previous night. Just for simply saying that she didn't find it hot that she saw her own brother naked, the app sent Riley a video of her masterbating. What else could it send her? The picture Annabelle just took of Riley's ass? The fact she admitted to wanting to have sex with Riley? Or maybe even just the fact Annabelle felt attracted to Michael. It was too much to risk. Riley's gaze turned slightly confused as her friend stood in silence, looking at her. Riley asked, "You sure you're alright? You didn't change, babes."

"Oh... uh, right. Sorry, just give me another second. I just had to grab... something."

Trying to brush off the strange encounter, she walks to the kitchen to grab the first thing she sees- a banana. Riley gives her a skeptical look, but Annabelle laughs awkwardly and retreats back to her bedroom. She defeatedly pulls her phone back out and looks at the unchanged app screen. The three people she selected before are all laid out as options- Hank, Jen, and Luna. What choice did she have right now? She had to pick one of them.

She found all three people attractive, but it had been two years since she had as much as kissed someone... and now she was expected to fuck one of these people she has never even met? As she tried to think, she started undressing to put on her pajamas. She threw all of her clothes off until she was just sitting in her panties, then sat on the end of her bed. There wasn't time to stall or consider... she just had to choose one. The one she found the most attractive was Jen. But she had never really had sex with a woman before. The idea was... intimidating. Hank was also very attractive and, based on the video evidence of it, he knew how to fuck. However, who knows what kind of person he is. Meeting up with a random man to have sex could be a very bad idea. Last, was Luna. Luna was every bit as attractive as the others, but was still a woman. However, at least Luna had a dick, right? She would be the first woman Annabelle would ever have sex with, but at least there would still be some familiarity. With that in mind, she clicked on Luna's profile, still not fully certain in her own decisions.

"Great! We are glad you made your decision! Luna is very horny and agreed that she wants to fuck you tonight! Would you rather go to her house or bring her to you?"

Tonight? That is ridiculous! What was she supposed to tell Riley? But as if on cue, Riley knocked on the door and entered the bedroom. She gasped, "Oops, sorry, didn't know you were still..."

She trailed off, her eyes blatantly staring at Annabelle's exposed breasts. Annabelle, noticing she is naked still, quickly brings an arm up to cover her boobs. However, her E-cups still spilt out around her arm as it just covered her nipples. Blushing, she says, "No, it's... okay. Sorry I'm taking forever. What's up?"

Riley, trying not to stare at her friend's almost entirely naked body, sits beside her on the bed to say, "Come on, something's going on, girl. Talk to me."

Annabelle thought for a moment. This could be her chance to figure out how she is supposed to sleep with Luna tonight. She quickly comes up with the best lie she can, and says, "Umm... that video I sent you last night. It... was for someone I've been talking to and they... she really wants to have sex tonight."

Riley gives a slight smile and responds, "She, huh? Well she's a lucky girl. You know you don't have to hide that from me, right?"

Annabelle shrugs, "I know but I just... feel weird talking about it. I've never been with a girl."

Riley scoffs, pretending to be offended, and says, "Oh so you just completely ignored what we did, huh?"

Her face turns bright red. Riley was right... there was more to her lust for Riley than just that first time they touched each other. But Riley was the one that suggested they shouldn't talk about it again. Annabelle's arm unconsciously moves away to stop covering up her body. Her boobs fall down slightly and catch Riley's eye. Not noticing, Annabelle says, "I'm not ignoring... that. But I didn't think that really counted."

Riley subtly moves closer on the bed and says in a quiet voice, "I count it."

The girls look into each other's eyes for a long moment, until Annabelle breaks the silence with an awkward chuckle, "You are the one that told me not to talk about it, you know."

"Yep. And now I'm telling you it counts. So... what I'm getting at is you should sleep with this girl. If you want to, I mean."

Right, Luna. Annabelle had almost forgotten about that as she stared at Riley. She looked back up at her eyes, but noticed Riley's eyes looking down at Annabelle's boobs. This time, she made no effort to hide them as she felt herself becoming aroused by the sight. But despite her feelings right now, she had no choice but to fuck Luna.

"You're right. You are still tipsy though, you should spend the night here. I can head over to her place."

Riley smiles in response and finally looks away. She shrugs, "Finish the movie marathon after you get off work tomorrow?"

"Sounds like a plan to me."

Riley turns back to her and stretches out her arms to pull Annabelle into a hug. Annabelle's breasts press tightly against Riley's, with only her tiny shirt separating each other's skin. As they embrace, Annabelle can feel herself getting turned on. Despite her best efforts, all she can think about is the night they were talking about. The first time Annabelle really experimented with a woman.

--

It was the first semester of Freshman year in college and Annabelle and her boyfriend, Martin, had temporarily broken up for around the tenth time. She had gone to Riley for comfort about it and was eventually convinced to blow off some steam by going to a bar. In addition to the two, Riley's older sister, Rebecca,. also came with (and provided fake IDs). Rebecca was three years older than them and a Junior in the same college. Riley and Annabelle always looked up to Rebecca and, especially as young kids, would follow her anywhere she went. She was not only cool, but she was incredibly beautiful and openly a lesbian. Rebecca looked very similar to Riley but with sharper features and boobs that were almost double the size of her sister's. Annabelle and Rebecca liked to jokingly flirt with one another in front of Riley to annoy her. A few drinks deep, the three girls sit in a booth shaped in a half circle with Annabelle sitting between the two sisters.

"Annabelle, that loser didn't even buy you flowers for your birthday! He's not worth your time!"

Rebecca nods in agreement and adds to Riley's words, "You're also way too pretty for that weirdo."

Riley rolls her eyes, but Annabelle grins widely at her words and responds, "Aww, you think so?"

Rebecca leans closer to say in a seductive tone, "I'm not blind, am I? You're sexy as fuck, baby."

Annabelle moves closer to match her and says, "Not as sexy as you."

Riley loudly groans and complains, "Can you two get a room?"

Rebecca laughs, "I would love to get a room with her. What do you say, Annabelle?"

"That is a great idea! I can try out the new lingerie I bought."

Riley elbows Annabelle in the side playfully, before a server approaches them to hand all three of them more drinks. Annabelle grabs her margarita and downs it in seconds. Rebecca places a hand on her arm and asks, "Woah, sure you should be going so fast?"

She shrugs in response, "The point was to have fun tonight, right? So let's have fun!"

The three continue drinking for another hour, until Annabelle is about six drinks deep. Rebecca's arm wraps around Annabelle's shoulder as she rests her head against her chest. Rebecca holds her against her own body, with Annabelle's face inches away from her cleavage. Riley watches them closely, her arms crossed across her chest. Rebecca speaks casually, saying, "My roommate is out of town for a few days while he stays with his boyfriend. I keep telling him he should just move in with us too."

Annabelle looks up and notices Riley's closed off posture. She asks, "You okay over there? You look grumpy."

Riley scoffs, "Well my sister is all over you, kinda hard to ignore."

Annabelle smiles playfully and lifts one leg up to lie on Riley's lap, unknowingly giving her a view up her skirt. She teases her, "You jealous? You know I love you too, baby."

Rebecca laughs as Annabelle is moved even closer to her boobs by the adjustment. She places her hand on Annabelle's stomach and teases her sister, saying, "Yeah, Riles! There's plenty to go around! You wanna come cuddle?"

Riley rolls her eyes, laughing slightly and says, "You suck, Becca."

Her eyes glance down and notice the view up Annabelle's skirt- and the fact she isn't wearing panties. She suddenly blushes, but uncrosses her arms to instead rest her hands on her friend's leg. Annabelle just sits still, feeling numb from the alcohol and enjoying the feeling of Riley's hands against her skin, and the flowery fragrance coming from Rebecca's body. She turns her head, not so subtly getting a close up view of Rebecca's impressive cleavage. She was one of the only girls Annabelle has met who has even bigger boobs than her. She moves her head so that her cheek presses against the cleavage. Rebecca feels herself growing more aroused from the combination of the alcohol and Annabelle's warmth against her body. But she looks up at her sister to respond and, accidentally, speaks with a more seductive voice than she intended.

"Yeah? Well then why don't I suck on those titties already."

Realizing what she said, she blushes hard and feels her eyes move down to her sister's cleavage with a mind of their own. She forces herself to look back up at Riley's eyes, as she has a surprised look on her face. She responds, "Damn, Becca... that's kinda weird."

But despite saying that, she feels a shiver rushing over her entire body at the sound of those words. A warmth from between her thighs grows harder and harder to ignore. Riley's eyes move to her sister's huge boobs and Annabelle's face pressed against them. Unconsciously, as she gets more aroused she slides her hands further up her friend's legs until she is slowly circling her thumb against the skin of her thighs.

"What, you scared you'd like it?" Rebecca responds in a more joking tone, but doubling down nonetheless.

"Please, as if I'd be into a hoe like you."

Rebecca laughs in response, then scoots closer to Annabelle, allowing her face to be pressed fully against her cleavage. Rebecca bites her lip and says in a quiet tone, "Bitch I could make you cum in seconds."

"Oh yeah? I'd like to see you try."

Rebecca, fully horny now, decides to be a little more bold and reaches up to grab one of Annabelle's boobs through her top. Annabelle gasps and looks up, then Rebecca says, "I bet Annie knows which one of us is a real woman, right, baby?"

Refusing to back down as she too gets wetter by the second, Riley slides one hand under Annabelle's skirt to rest on her upper thigh. She confidently says, "Yeah? Well Annabelle knows that if anyone here is going to fuck her, it'll be me."

They both look at Annabelle expectantly. She looks between the two girls, then confidently sits up, pulling herself away from Rebecca. With the alcohol steeling her nerves, she firmly grabs Riley's face and kisses her on the lips. Riley is shocked at first, but then fully leans into the kiss and wraps her arms around her best friend's lap, pulling her closer until she is fully sitting on her lap. The two finally break the kiss and stare intently into one another's eyes, the taste of each other still fresh on both of their tongues. Annabelle looks over at Rebecca, who is staring intently at them, her eyes burning with lust. Her hand sits on her crotch and gently touches her pussy through her jeans. Annabelle confidentiality gets off of Riley's lap and moves back between the two, then grabs a handful of Rebecca's breast. The two lean into each other to kiss. Rebecca is clearly more experienced than her sister and uses a lot more tongue. Riley bites her lip and watches them intently, not looking away for even a second. The two finally break the kiss and Annabelle breathes against her lips, "Let's get out of here."

The three all have an unspoken understanding as they gather their things, pay, and head out of the bar. They take an Uber back to Rebecca's apartment, barely saying a word the entire drive but sitting pressed tightly against each other in the back seat. They finally arrive at the apartment and quickly head upstairs. The second the door opens, Rebecca pushes Annabelle against the wall and passionately kisses her on the lips. Riley closes the door behind them and moves in close to kiss Annabelle's neck. Annabelle moans into Rebecca's mouth as the two girls run their hands across her body. She couldn't even tell who was who as she felt both of them take hold of one of her boobs. Another hand grabs her waist and then reaches around to firmly squeeze her ass. Annabelle reaches out to take ahold of Riley's ass, but then feels one of the girls start to slip her fingers underneath the waistband of her skirt. Rebecca breaks her kiss to bend down and pull Annabelle's skirt off, then starts to kiss her thighs. Riley moves closer to move her kisses down to her cleavage, then grabs the front of her shirt to pull her right boob out of the top of the shirt.

"Oh fuck," Annabelle moans as Riley pulls her boob out of her bra to take a nipple into her mouth. Meanwhile Rebecca runs her tongue up her thighs, and towards her pussy. Her eyes roll back into her head as the two girls suck against her skin. Annabelle digs her fingers into Riley's hair and pulls her closer, then uses her other hand to guide Rebecca's head up towards her pussy. Rebecca runs her tongue up her labia, savoring the flavor of her wetness. She uses one hand to spread Annabelle's cunt and allow her tongue to enter her and rub against her clit. Riley backs off from Annabelle's body to start undressing herself. The two make intense eye contact as she strips her clothes off and throws them on the floor. She steps forward to pull her friend once again into a passionate kiss- all while her own sister eats Annabelle out inches away. Rebecca takes notice of her sister's naked body and reaches up to grab her ass.

"Becca... can we go to your room?"

Riley speaks in a sultry voice, clearly wanting more. Rebecca stands up, still squeezing her sister's ass, then leans forward to whisper in her ear, "Only if I get to taste you too."

Riley looks surprised for a second, then confidently presses her lips against her sister's. Annabelle watches the sisters explore each other's mouths and reaches down to rub her own pussy at the sight.

Rebecca guides the girls back to her bedroom, then pushes them both down on the bed to lie side by side. They both watch as she slowly undresses- her huge, perfectly shaped tits spilling out from her top. After she has completely stripped down, she walks towards the bed with swaying hips. She climbs on top of the bed- and towards Riley. She stops between her legs, looking up at her sister seductively. Annabelle has never been more aroused as she watches Rebecca lean forward and eat out her sister's pussy. She and Riley make out as Rebecca's tongue moves with expert precision, in tandem with two of her fingers that rub against her clit. After only five minutes, Riley starts to moan loudly, and orgasm against Rebecca's face.

She lifts her head up from between her legs, then moves over to instead make out with Annabelle. The three girls lie in the bed together for hours, swapping between cuddling and kissing each other. Eventually, the sisters finally fall asleep with all three spooning each other. Annabelle lies still awake, slightly more sober than before. Her arms wrap around Riley's waist as her ass presses into her crotch. Behind her, Rebecca's pierced nipples push up against Annabelle's back as she holds her close. As she lies between the two naked bodies, her own pussy still wants more. But between the sleeping bodies, all she can do is push her face against the back of Riley's neck, and take in her smell. She smells like lilacs. The scent eventually lulled her to sleep.

--

As Annabelle's bare breasts press against Riley's body in their hug, all she can think about is the scent of her perfume. That scent brought back the memories of that night. The morning after the three slept together Riley was humiliated and demanded that they never mention it again. It was the only time Annabelle had ever been with a woman, or two. Most of the night Annabelle simply spent watching Riley and Rebecca have sex while she occasionally made out with one of them or sucked a nipple. Annabelle never counted it as really having sex and chalked it up to the three just being drunk and stupid. But over the course of just 24 hours this damn app has forced her to face all of those feelings again. And now she couldn't try to say 'technically' anymore- she was going to have sex with a woman. Tonight.

She slowly backed away from Riley and asked her, "You sure you're okay with me just... ditching you? For sex?"

"Girl, I am thrilled that you are getting laid! I've been trying to encourage this for years- of course it is okay."

They both laugh, then Annabelle asks, "Help me pick an outfit?"

The two pick out an outfit as Annabelle subtly selects on the Current Crush app to meet up at Luna's house. It provides her with an address and tells her to head over now. Annabelle puts on a matching red thong and lace bra, a pair of black leggings, and a tight white top that shows off her cleavage. After a few minutes, she kisses Riley on the cheek and leaves her to sleep off the alcohol while Annabelle takes an Uber to Luna's apartment. As she gets out of the Uber, she notices the apartment building looks strangely familiar. She looks down at the phone to read the screen telling her what to do.

"Your task is simple tonight, Annabelle! You need to have sex with Luna. Don't worry, she has the same task as you so you will not have to worry about any unnecessary foreplay (unless you want to!) In addition, for now you will not need to record the actual act of her fucking you, but we will require photo proof that she creampied you afterwards! Needless to say, that means no pulling out and both of your faces must be in the photo! Now, have fun!"

God this app sucks. She walked into the complex to look for the apartment, and eventually approached the door. With a nervous breath, she knocks on the door. After a few moments, the door opens up, and on the other side stands the woman she had only ever seen on the screen before- Luna. She looked almost exactly the same, but her hair was hot pink instead of blonde. She wore a black tank top with a band logo Annabelle didn't recognize, black ripped jeans, and a large assortment of different bracelets and rings. She had on beautiful makeup that highlighted her features and a septum piercing. She smiled warmly and said, "Hey! Annabelle, right?"