We reached Michelle's apartment and she asked me if wanted to come in and have a glass of water. "What about Heather?" I asked. She told me she was going to the library to work on a paper that was due in a week or so. I agreed and we entered her apartment only to find Heather sitting on a chair. Michelle was startled and loudly said, "I thought you were going to the library?" Heather responded, "I was but I'm still a little hungover so I decided to work on some other homework."
Heather had a mischievous look on her face when she asked where had been? Michelle responded, saying "we went for coffee and we walked around the park." Heather chuckled and said "that sounds romantic." Michelle looked at me as I was looking at Heather trying to figure out what her motive was to all the questioning. Michelle looked back at Heather and asked "what's with all the questions and silly faces you are making?" Heather stared us both down with a smirk on her face and asked me why I came back to the apartment instead of going on to my dorm? My answer was short and to the point, "to get a drink of fucking water." "Oh, is that all?" Michelle turned and we looked at one another, taking our eyes off of Heather for a brief moment. As we turned back to Heather my eyes grew big and Michelle said "where the fuck did you get those?" Heather was delicately holding up my black cum stained silk boxers.
Michelle went off on Heather, calling her every name in the book, including the most hated words by all women the dreaded "C" word and Heather just sat there and smiled. After Michelle finished her tirade, Heather explained how she came into possession of the boxers and said that Zoey the cat had brought them out from your room Michelle, which got me curious, so I got up and looked into your room and noticed that there were no blankets on the floor in your room and your bed looked as though more than just you had been in it. So by putting things together the puzzle of who I heard fucking were, in fact, you two who as you know as well as I do are cousins.
Michelle dropped to her knees and started crying. I kept my gaze on Heather and just stared her down. Heather looked at me and asked if we wanted to explain what had happened last night. After a few minutes of complete silence other than the sound of Michelle's sobs I told Michelle to walk over and sit in the chair next to Heather while I sat in the chair next to the computer furthest away from the two of them.
Michelle looked over to me and I nodded yes as to indicate to her that I was okay with her telling Heather what had happened. Michelle began to tell Heather how we ended up in bed together detailing the events leading up to it: When you stood to go to the bathroom you fell back onto the couch, spilling your drink and causing the other girls to spill theirs which is why the couch the looks the way it does. Joe and I got you into the bathroom and got you cleaned up and changed and put you to bed. We cleaned up the place and it was late and raining. I didn't want Joe to walk home in the rain and so we ended up in my room and yes in my bed. What you heard last night was Joe and I orally and using our hands and fingers to pleasure each other. I did grind my pussy on his cock when he still had his boxers on and I still had my thong on but that is the closest we came to fucking.
Heather glanced in my direction as if looking for confirmation so I got up, walked over to Michelle, who now had tears running down her cheeks put my arm around her and told her that everything she just told you is the absolute truth. Now if you don't mind don't ever speak of this ever again.
Heather began to speak and said "this is not quite over." Both of you saw me naked in a very vulnerable state so I think that it is only fair that both of you strip out of your clothes so that I can see you naked. I stared her down and told her "she was out of her mind to even have ever thought that was going to happen." Michelle spoke up and said "you see me naked all the time living in this tiny apartment, we do only have the one bathroom and when we both have to be somewhere at the same time we do share." Heather spoke up again and said this is different. The two of saw me naked together now I want to see the two of you naked together. After calling her a "bitch" I walked to the kitchen to get Michelle and I our water.
Michelle, with tears in her eyes asked "that if we do this will you please promise to leave this and us alone?" Heather agreed but only if we would re-enact the bathroom scene with us being the ones who were naked. I heard this entire conversation from the kitchen and when I entered the main room join Michelle and Heather again I said again "there is no
fucking
way this is going to happen and you both are out of your
god damned minds
." Michelle looked at me and said "if we do this she will never speak of it again and we can get on with our lives. I looked at Heather and told her to get her clothes she wants to be changed into then we will do what she asked. "No, that's ok, I'll stay naked as well" Heather said.
Michelle stood up and took a deep breath and said "you ready Joe?" I nodded yes and we turned to face Heather. Michelle was wearing a few more articles of clothing than I was so she told me to wait a second until she removed her jacket. Hanging her jacket on the chair she was sitting in she looked at me and we both started to remove our clothes. We both started by taking our shoes and socks off then standing back up we took another deep breath and removed our t-shirts. Michelle reached her hands back behind her and unclasped the white lacey bra she was wearing and let it fall to the floor. We stood topless in front of Heather and she looked at us from her chair and slipped her hand down the front of her shorts and started masturbating in front of us. "Oh that is so hot. Two cousins, one a gorgeous petite blonde with nice little tits, and her good looking cousin who appears to be hiding a nice big cock in his shorts."
Heather spoke up and said "please continue, don't let me stop what you are supposed to be doing." I noticed Michelle's hand move to her waist and her fingers grasp the waist band of her yoga pants. I moved my hands to my gym shorts and started to pull them down when Michelle reached over and grabbed my wrist. She leaned in and whispered in my ear "I am not wearing any panties. Do you have boxers on?" I whispered back "I will take them off with my shorts so that we would be completely nude at the same time." Michelle and I discarded our remaining attire all the while eying Heather rubbing herself into a frenzy.
Heather motioned for us to come to where she was sitting. Michelle and I slowly walked over to the chair Heather was sitting in and she removed her hand from her shorts and she held it out for us telling us how hot and wet her pussy was. I shook my head and looked over at Michelle who was staring intently at Heather's wet and sticky fingers. My cock was fully erect and harder than I had ever been and was begging to be taken care of. Michelle snapped out of her trance and looked down at my cock then turned and apologized saying "sorry I fucked our lives up!" "I am as much to blame so don't ever say that again" I sternly said to her.
I looked at Heather and said "are you ready?" She nodded and said that she was. I asked Michelle if she was ready and she said "yes." I moved to the right side of Heather and pointed for Michelle to move to the left. Heather edged closer to front of the chair where my dick and Michelle's pussy was a mere few inches from her face. I took a deep breath as well did Michelle and we both reached down and grabbed Heather's t-shirt and started to raise it up and off of her. Heather alternated her stares going from Michelle's bald snatch to my engorged throbbing cock. As we raised her shirt higher her firm 36 C breasts began to come into view. My cock twitched when we had cleared her breasts and Heather licked her lips as she saw this sudden involuntary movement. Heather raised her arms up and Michelle and I lifted her shirt over her head and dropped it on the floor in front of us. "That was so hot" Heather said and began massaging her tits. I looked over at Michelle and saw that she was watching Heather kneading her tits and she began kneading her little buds.
"Do you two want to be alone?" I asked and they both snapped back to their senses and Heather caught Michelle playing with her tits and she gave her a big smile. I admit that the sight was a huge turn on but I wanted to get this over with so that I could get back to my dorm so that I could relieve the tension in my cock and nut sack.
In my mind I knew how this was going to play out and I was wishing it wouldn't happen. I moved to stand directly in front of Heather with my cock pointed straight at her mouth, Michelle dropped to her knees and I put my arms out and put them under Heather's. I lifted Heather up and did my best to avoid eye contact as I raised her to her feet. Heather giggled as she felt Michelle working her shorts off of her and then Michelle nudged the back of her thigh and she fell into me with her naked breast pinned against my chest. Michelle's hand was trapped between Heather's shaved pussy and my throbbing hard on.
We stayed this way for about a minute when Heather let out a little moan of pleasure then I felt a hand wrap around my cock and start to stroke me. Heather and I both looked down simultaneously and saw that Michelle had a finger in Heather's already wet pussy and her other hand stroking my cock.
Heather said while looking down at Michelle, "looks like someone is a little turned on." I began to say Michelle's name when Heather put her hands on my face and lifted it up where she planted her lips to mine and desperately tried to pry my lips apart with her tongue. I tried to break free of two of them but when I tried Michelle would tighten her grip on my cock and Heather put her arms around my neck and pulled me in closer. Heather broke free of my lips and said "don't fight it just enjoy the pleasure." Then she let out another moan this time louder than the first. Michelle had two fingers inside of Heather's