I know it sounds weird, but I was living out a fantasy. After a strip tease show in my living room, my older sister Cindy came on to me. My friend, Mitch, and I were having a sleep over at my house. My parents were away, and my two older sisters, Christy and Cindy, decided to do a strip tease for us. We're all adults - Christy is 22, Cindy is 20 and Mitch and I are 18. The show got both Mitch and I pretty hard and apparently it showed.
The next day when Christy had gone to her and Cindy's apartment to fuck Mitch, Cindy stayed behind. I was playing a video game when she approached me about the show the previous night.
Truth was, after they'd stripped down to their underwear, I started fantasizing about having sex with my sisters, especially Cindy. While I was admitting that to her, my dick starting rising again - something she noticed.
She asked me if I wanted her to touch my cock and I readily agreed. That led to her taking my virginity and letting me lick and fuck her in all her holes over the next 24 hours. I was having the time of my life and loving my gorgeous sister's body. Cindy is about average height, olive skin, dark short hair and a bald pussy. Her tits are amazing - small but with big nipples that are super sensitive.
I made her cum multiple times, even on our parent's bed!
She admitted to me that she'd been in a lesbian relationship with Christy for about a year and that our older sister might also be interested in fucking her brother. Christy had invited Mitch over to take his virginity the same day Cindy and I fucked. Now Cindy invited me to return to their college apartment for a potential threesome. I was psyched!
"Are you sure about this?" I said as we pulled into the apartment complex. Cindy and Christy shared the apartment while attending the same college - one I was also going to attend this coming fall.
"Well, we'll find out!" Cindy said optimistically.
I admit I was really nervous. Christy was the eldest sibling. She was confident and could even be a bit bossy. Yes, I was turned on by her body - long dark hair, curvy figure, tits that often poked out of her bra. But I was also intimidated by her.
Cindy let us in the apartment. I'd been there once before, helping them move, but not since.
Christy was not there. I wasn't sure whether to be disappointed at a lost opportunity or relieved not to have to face a possible rejection.
Cindy grabbed beers for us from the fridge. Christy was over 21 so kept them stocked on booze. We sat on the couch and waited.
"I texted her, but she's not answering," Cindy said, looking at her phone.
The beer helped calm me down, and I noticed that Cindy also loosened up a bit after drinking hers.
"You know," I said, touching Cindy's leg as she sat next to me. "We don't have to sit here and do nothing, waiting for Christy."
I must have had a naughty expression on my face because Cindy smiled slyly and came in for a French kiss. Kissing my sister had always seemed like such a taboo thing, and certainly putting my tongue in her mouth was way beyond the norm. But I have to admit, it was sensual, exciting, and got my dick hard pretty quick.
Pretty soon, Cindy was putting my hands under her blouse so I could caress her small tits. I went under her bra and started tweaking her nipples.
"Oooh, yeah, that's good!" she said. "Play with my nipples!"
I used my other hand to reach between her legs. She was wearing a short skirt and a thong underneath. I had no trouble getting my hand under the fabric and felt her wet and warm slit.
Cindy reached over and started kneading my cock, which was getting big and hard fast.
We were just about to start taking clothes off when we heard the door lock open. Surprised, we both sat up and started arranging our clothes as Christy walked in, carrying a bag of groceries.
"Shit, guys!" she said, setting the bag down on the kitchen counter.
"Sorry, Christy," Cindy said, pulling her blouse down.
Cindy walked over and stood above us. I wasn't sure if she was going to scold us or what, but it didn't help my nervous feelings at all!
"Well, get your act together because I brought wine to celebrate!"
With that she went back into the kitchen and produced a very expensive bottle of wine and three glasses. We got up as she poured and clinked our glasses together.
"What are we celebrating?" I asked after taking a sip.
"What else but two guys who are no longer virgins!" she said, raising her glass in the air.
"So... Mitch?" Cindy asked.
"Mitch and I had a great time last night," Christy said. "He stuck his cock in me more than once - let's just say he's going to be an excellent lover!"
She looked us over and said, "And you two?"
We both nodded.
"You fucked your younger brother?" Christy said, looking directly at Cindy.
Cindy smiled and took my hand. "He's fucking amazing, Christy!"
She turned her gaze to me, sizing me up, then smiling herself.
"Good to hear. Good to hear," she said, setting down her glass. "You know, Cindy, I realized I forgot to buy cream at the store. Could you run out and get some? We're totally out."
She said this while looking at me, not Cindy. She winked at me, or at least that's what I thought it was. Very subtle.
"Um, sure," Cindy said, grabbing her keys. "I'll be right back."
"Take your time," Christy said, still looking at me.
Cindy left, leaving Christy and I alone in the apartment.
"So, you're an amazing lover, eh?" she said, picking up her glass and guiding us to the couch.
"I have no idea," I admitted. "It was my first time. But Cindy was very gentle with me. She showed me what to do."
We sat, each taking sips of wine before setting our glasses on the coffee table.
Christy turned to me and put a hand on my thigh. "You never told me what you really thought about our little show the other night."
