And the saga continues. Fan fricking tastic.
Emma and I did continue the night Sarah stayed in that hotel. We continued well into the early hours of the next morning. I think both of us knew it was over after that. We couldn't keep doing that to each other - it wasn't fair to Sarah.
We both love her too much for that. But god the sex was good. And every time I see Emma's ass I get to think back to that night. That's good enough right? Right? Okay. Who am I kidding. I'd love to sleep with her again if my god-dammed conscious would allow it.
Cue - today - when - you guessed it - my conscious will once more fail me. Sorry to ruin the ending but don't worry I'm sure there's some twists and turns you'll enjoy. You'll enjoy them a hell of a lot more than I do.
You know that feeling you get of panic and anxiety that's somewhere between your gut and your neck and just sits there when you know you fucked up? That's how I feel, but enjoy. Enjoy my total state of regret and misery.
-----------------------------------
"David are you ready?"
Am I ready? Am I ready she says.
"Of course. It takes me like five minutes."
"And yet, we're always waiting on you in the end."
Sarah pokes her head out of the bathroom as she says this. I'm still in bed and most certainly not ready.
"Well, I'll be ready by the next time you check if I'm ready how about that."
The toothbrush goes in her mouth and we air shake on it.
A few people are coming over. Emma (whom you've met already), Alli (a childhood friend of Emma and Sarah's), and Jess (the only college friend of mine that Sarah likes).
It should be fun. It should be a fun game night. We've each got a game planned and hopefully I don't end up fucking my sister in law again! Jesus. What have I become?
Ding Dong (not my dick, the doorbell).
"Babe! I'll get the door! Hurry your pretty ass up!"
"Babe!"
A lot of nervous chuckling for me. It's been that way since it happened... And then since it happened again... And then again... And...
At the door is Jess! I breathe out a sigh of relief as Jess launches forward to hug me.
"David! Long time no see! I found someone else wandering around your front yard too. Some stray." We laugh as Alli walks into view, and shyly hugs me.
Just a moment to objectify these two gorgeous women, Alli is the definition of a petite hourglass figure. Her black hair drapes over her C cup tits to her hips. Her ass is to die for too. Her face is probably her worst featutre, but even that's at least good looking. She's the whole package. Today she's wearing tight blue jeans, and a loose blue plaid shirt. Then theres Jess, her face is easily her best feature. Any time you've ever seen a gorgeous girl pull off a sexy scarecrow costume for Halloween? She was made for that. Her straw blonde hair gingerly tickles her B cup boobs. Her ass is bigger than Alli's but smaller than Emma's. She's truly just a gorgeous young woman. Today, she's wearing a purple frilly dress that clings to every inch of her body.
"Come in come in!" I exclaim as I drool over these gorgeous girls. God I'm not the hero of my own story am I? I'm the villain of theirs. "So what games did you two bring?"
"I brought a trivia game!" Alli beams as she presents a well worn box.
"I brought cards against humanity." Jess lazily flops the new box onto the table, she's not a huge fan of games that aren't drinking games.
"I brought Twister!" What the shit? When did she come in? There's Emma standing in the door frame with a loose flowing mini skirt and a tank top. Ugh I wish she'd wear something that hugged her ass... I mean
"Hey Emma. Twister huh?"
"Oh yeah. So limber up bucko." The mini skirt really shows off her legs. Her thighs are perfectly plump and lean. The kind that get nicely squeezed by thigh highs. Below her calves are perfectly shaped from working out everyday for years. God I want those legs wrapped around me instead of sitting across the coffee table.
"Oh! You're all here?!" Sarah walks down the stairs as she finishes putting her hair up into a ponytail. "David why didnt you get me?" She teases, while going into the kitchen. "Give me a hand in here will you?" I head in, and see she's prepared some cocktails. "I figured we could start the night off right." She hands me three drinks to hand out, and brings two with her. We sit down, and start in on the cards against humanity. It starts off pretty benign for all my worries. We're all sitting around, and laughing. I get up to go to the bathroom 3 drinks later (never a good idea to break the floodgate) and when I get back I've been kicked off the couch to the floor.
"No. No. Don't move back over, I'll just sit on the ground. So not a problem."
"Good, because Sarah and I need room, we've got hips ya know?" Jess smiles cockily as she jokes. I mock being put out, and get ready for more of the game.
"Maybe we start the trivia now?" Alli speaks up, and giggles. She's already getting tipsy, and you can tell by the faint pink underlining of her eyes.
"Only if it's a drinking game!" Jess says, but starts putting away the cards before we agree to the new terms. It wasn't a suggestion I guess. Still, I stand up to get Alli some water in between games.
"Anybody want some water?" All hands shoot up.
"I'll help you!" Emma swings off the chair, and bounces after me into the kitchen. "Ugh, I wish we could just skip to the twister. You know?"
"Heh. I mean, at the rate we're going we'll see if we even make it to that game."
"Oh we will, and hopefully after a good amount of drinking. Even if it's just you and me left conscious." Emma winks, and bounces out with two of the glasses. Oh Christ, why was I still holding hope this could go by without event... And why am I kinda happy I was wrong. God, I'm the absolute worst.
------
"The teams are David, Jess, and Sarah against Emma and Alli." Again, Jess commands. She doesn't suggest. Those two are way better at trivia so we get the advantage of the extra head; though I doubt that'll end up actually helping.
Yep. That was beyond fast as I find myself chugging my drink because I lost. Then, of course, Emma pours the rest of her drink evenly amongst the losers. "Don't forget you finish ours too!" Oh, so she wants to play that way? I mean... Ain't no thaaang... I think I'm tipsy now, and when I bring fresh drinks for the group I notice Emma's moved to the ground with me. I think my horny sister in law might be about to be obvious about us... I'm a schmuck. Why am I happy about that? This could ruin my marriage if I let it. But I take the bait, I ignore the now empty chair, and sit right next to her on the ground.
"Let's change teams! I'll be on David's team! You're welcome. I'm willing to take the loss here."
"Great, thanks Emma. Good morale boost."
"Oh you know I'm teasing." She flourishes her hand, and runs it on my thigh.
Gulp! Fricking gulp! I. Am. I. Trouble.
I blush and cringe and pop a chub all at the same time. As I adjust my sitting to hide my growing... I see Jess giving me a curious smile. Oh shit. Did she notice? Does she think it was weird. Am I over thinking barely a moment with barely an interaction?
Shit tune back in to the conversation, and let's play some trivia.
We trade points pretty evenly at first, but it's still pretty clear Emma and I are gonna lose. Sarah's ecstatic, and Alli doesn't seem the least bit surprised. Jess is barely playing as she spends the whole time chatting and laughing.
Emma, and I start to win out of left field, and with every point she gets a little touchier. On another losing streak, we finish our drinks first so I stand to get more.
