All characters are at least 18 years old.
------
"What are you doing here?" I managed.
"I came to see..." He looked around, apparently stumped for words and stalling. He was about to lie. "I was in the area."
I almost laughed. "That's the worse excuse in the book." Already, my mood had improved drastically. "You wouldn't be here to see little old me on such a special day, would you? Seems you guys have a lot of free time at the FBI."
He folded one arm in front of him while the other scratched his jawline. He was cute when he was sheepish. Changing the subject, he said, "I saw you with that couple earlier. Were they your parents?"
And he had to foul the conversation just like that. "They were. Do you recognize them?"
He shook his head with a quizzical expression, then moved out of the way as a car passed him. "Hey, uh... School parking lot isn't a great place to talk. Wanna sit down somewhere?"
With a smirk, I teased, "You mean like a coffee date?"
He studied me for a moment, then smiled. "Yeah. Like a coffee date." His smile spread into a grin as he added, "If we're gonna get married, we might as well get to know each other."
"Fair point." I looked back toward the football field. My friends were probably looking for me by now, getting ready to head to Coco's to celebrate. I... wasn't ready to see them. At least not right now. Plus, I needed to talk to August about our situation anyway. "Why don't I meet you at the bistro at the corner? I need to get changed out of this poncho." I gestured down to my gown, and he chuckled.
"Not a fan, I take it."
"Not at all."
"Alright, sure. I'll grab us a table. This better not be your way of ghosting me, though," he warned playfully, and I just winked at him before heading off.
I had a change of clothes in my car -- as I always did, not just for this occasion -- and was about to change when I got a text.
Brie:
where you at, girl?
Brie:
you just up and vanished
Me:
sth came up. ill meet you at coco's
I got dressed into a violet t-shirt and blue jeans, tying my hair up in a loose ponytail. Staring at myself in my rearview mirror, I took a deep breath and steeled myself. Fuck Charles for being a bitch. I was going to get the answers I wanted in spite of him. My ponytail gave off the air of a good blend of utility and style, and with how tight my t-shirt was, I expected August to drool at least a little. Alright, show time.
He was sitting with an iced tea while he waited for me, and stood to greet me as I approached. Such a gentleman. Charles had coached him perfectly.
"Hope you haven't been waiting long," I said casually.
"We just saw each other," he chuckled. "It wasn't much of a head start."
As expected, his gaze drifted down to my bust, and I had to resist the urge to grin. I ordered a pink lemonade and leaned back in my chair, putting on my usual flirty look. He maintained a gentle smile, twinged with a hint of worry. Worried about what? About me finding out his connection with Charles? About us being forced to marry? About something from work?
"Hey," he said. "Are you okay?"
Alright, that caught me by surprise. Did I have a strange look on my face? He couldn't possibly have been worried about me.
"Of course. Why?"
He paused as my lemonade arrived, then continued when the waiter had left. "When you were talking with your parents... you looked..."
Fuck. God damn it, he'd seen.
"Yeah, turns out he's not getting me a new car for college," I delivered dryly. "Still pretty torn up about it. I was hoping to get a BMW or something."
With a dramatic sigh, I sipped my lemonade. He continued to watch me, not saying anything, and it began to bother me. Was this guy soul reading me or something? Or maybe he really was as interesting as a tree stump.
"You don't need to hide from me, Lexi," he murmured, and I froze. I just couldn't catch a break today. I'd been caught out by some of my friends before, like Stef or Coco, but who the hell did this guy think he was?
I let enough time pass to indicate that I was thinking about my response, then said, "No offense, Auggie, but I don't know you that well. And you should already know me well enough to understand that controlling what people know is my job."
"So you're always hiding," he summed up, and I shrugged. He chuckled and nodded. "Hiding's great. It's comfortable. My dad was a sniper, so I imagined he was really good at hiding." He looked at me meaningfully. "Until one day, when either he didn't hide well enough, or there was nowhere to hide at all. And somebody found him when he wasn't ready."
"Using your dead dad to spin a life lesson," I commented. "Strange tactic, considering I don't even listen to my own father." It was a low blow -- cruel, even -- but this guy was getting too close. And his presumptuousness was kinda pissing me off.
He took the jab in stride, which was quite impressive. It made me wonder what would be effective at getting under his skin. "If that's the case, why are you not ignoring the engagement? Why are you even meeting me at all if you could just blow it off?"
"Because Charles can become a massively annoying bastard."
"To the point where you'd rather marry a stranger."
I held up a finger. "We're not getting married, remember? It's why we're meeting like this: to figure out what he's up to so we can rebuff him. Unless, of course, you guys are in cahoots. Then I'll just go with Plan A and tell you both to go fuck yourselves. Or each other, if that's your fancy."
He snorted, unable to hide his smirk. He could laugh at himself. I liked that. Too bad I had to try my best not to like him. I imagined we would've been quite good together. In a different life, perhaps.
"Well then, did you find anything out while talking to him?" he asked.
I scowled. "I lost my cool with him. Any subtlety was shot, and I'm pretty sure I've revealed my hand. He's gonna clam up around me if I try to fish any more. He flat out denied both being your benefactor and colluding with you, but then of course he would. And he's hard to read, so I can't even tell if he's lying."
I clenched my teeth. He wasn't better than me. He just had an unfair advantage.
Life's not fair, Lexi. Sometimes if you wanna win, you gotta make your own rules.
I know, Jordan. But what did that look like in this scenario?
"I tried shaking a few trees of my own, for all it was worth," August added. "Casually asked my commander, but I'm pretty sure he doesn't know anything either. Then I asked my mom how she talks to the benefactor."
"And?"
"Letters."
"You've gotta be kidding me," I groaned.
"Typed. Unmarked envelopes. I brought one of them to the lab, pulled a favor. Clean of prints except for mom's, no traces of saliva. Envelope was sealed by melting the glue with heat. Same with the stamps."
I narrowed my eyes. "And how does she write back?"
August snapped his fingers. "That's where it gets interesting. She mails it back. To
your
home address."
My blood froze in my veins. "What?"
"Yeah." He folded his arms and frowned down at his drink, lost in thought. "I did a double take when I saw who lived there too. It's why I dropped by to confirm yesterday. If you're not receiving them, then somebody else is intercepting them. You wouldn't happen to have surveillance footage of your mailbox, would you?"
I sighed. "I was too focused on putting surveillance on the
inside
of the house." My mind was in overdrive. "Wait. You've had a benefactor since you were--"
"Seventeen," he supplied. "So, for five years now."
Five years ago... Suddenly, I felt reinvigorated. I was back on the trail. No way all this was a coincidence. "I didn't even have this house five years ago. Where did she mail them before? There had to be a second address."
He leaned his head back, pressing his knuckles to his eyes. "Shit," he groaned. "Fine, I'll check again. Meanwhile, you get some cameras set up and point them at your mailbox. When you're ready, I'll have my mom write them again. We'll see who shows up to grab the letter."
I nodded. It was a decent step forward. Regardless, my mind was fully occupied by one thought.
Five years ago.
No, it was impossible. Utter bullshit. But in my line of work, there were no coincidences.