Our Ad read: 40's couple wants to swing with couple of same age. No expectation of friendship sole desire is for intimate relationship including M/F, M/M and F/F and group activities. Those interested should be in good physical condition as activities will be strenuous and rough. If interested send anonymous Email to )Email address omitted for story)
The ad in the Tribune was longer than most and expensive but we hoped it would be worth it if we landed the right couple to play with my wife and me. Karen had reservations about the ad. First, she worried it wouldn't get any response. Then she worried it would get response. She wondered what kind of people respond to those kind of ads. I asked her what type of people would submit such an ad.
Karen laughed and realized that there could be a nice couple out there that had the same interests as we did. We got a couple of replies from single men. We politely turned these down and began wondering if we would ever hear from any couple regardless of age. On Friday we were about to submit the ad for a second and final week when a message appeared in the special in box.
The Email read: Hi Hotman, My wife is 44 and I am 46 and we have never responded to a personal ad before. We have fantasized about having sex with another couple for a couple of years. We are high energy sex partners and love rough play. Kids are away now we can play. Reply if interested in getting personal details. One requests no picture sharing as we want to be surprised if we meet and remain anonymous if we don't. Also no lies about appearance or anything else.
Karen and I were excited beyond belief. Here was a couple our age whose kids were also out of the house. Karen was ready to meet them at that moment. I reminded her that we needed to find out more before jumping into bed with them. She sighed and agreed knowing that I was right. Carefully we wrote a reply.
It read: Nice to hear from you. We agree about picture sharing and in the same line we will use pseudonyms until we meet. I am Bud and am 49 years old with brown hair with streaks of white and have blue eyes. I am 5'8" and weigh 160 pounds. I am slightly overweight but have a skinny ass and a thick 7" circumcised cock. My wife, Betty, is 46 and weighs 145 pounds with dark brown hair and brown eyes. She is 5'4" with 36C tits and a plump round ass with a tight furry pussy. We like it rough, tit pinching, etc. If intrigued write back quickly. We can't wait to get kinky.
The last part about being kinky was intended to excite our contact and also let them know that we have wide boundaries. Patience was not our strong point. We began pacing the floor as soon as I hit the send key. Five minutes passed and we couldn't understand why they hadn't sent a message back.
After ten minutes we received this message: My husband and I are excited about the prospect of getting together. Our pseudonyms are Brad and Janet. Brad is 5'10" and 180 pounds with dirty blonde hair and blue eyes. He is in good shape and also has a skinny ass. His cock is 8" and circumcised. I am 5'2" 115 pounds. My tits are 34CMy ass is large and soft and my shaved pussy is as tight as you could imagine. We live right here in town.
Without hesitation we responded to their message. Karen was gushing with excitement. Several Emails flew back and forth dealing with the mundane checking each other out. After we were all satisfied our messages got more colorful. I even mentioned that I didn't care for shaved cunts. Janet replied that she only shaved it on a dare and it was starting to grow back.
It took most of Friday evening to convince everyone that we should meet each other very soon. Satisfied that we were really who we said we were and that we were truly married couples just looking to have a bit of extra fun. We all had family obligations on Saturday so we agreed to meet on Sunday.
It was decided to meet at a large food court at the nearby shopping mall where we would find out what each other looked like and real names would be revealed. The guys would wear baseball caps and the women would have a red flower in their hair so we would recognize each other.
That was Janet's idea as she had seen something similar in an old movie. Such a meeting place gave us the chance to change our mind if we didn't like what we saw as we spotted the other couple. Karen was absolutely sure that she wasn't going to change her mind as she really wanted to experience a foursome.
Sunday could not come fast enough for either Karen or myself. Finally, it was time to meet our potential new sex partners. Karen had us to the food court a half an hour early. She had fussed over every detail of her appearance wanting to be seductive but not sluttie. She wore a conservative dress that had just enough cleavage to tease a man and it showed off her ass very attractively. While I wanted to do this I didn't worry much about what I wore figuring that they would accept or reject me based on stuff other than the clothes I wore. Nervously we sat at the little table sipping on soda. Karen strained her neck looking around the room for some sign of them. My fingers tapped the table with an annoying repetitive rhythm.
"Oh my gawd, it can't be," Karen gasped with her face turning bright red. Then I heard another gasp come from a few feet away. I looked up to see Karen's sister and her husband standing in shock in the middle of the room. None of us knew what to do. I guess they decided this wouldn't go away by just leaving and walked slowly over to us.
Janet was actually Theresa who looked exactly as she portrayed herself in the Email exchange. And, Brad was my brother-in-law Terry who also told the truth about himself. In the exchange with blushing faces we nervously greeted each other. There was no good way to open up the conversation.
"Well, I guess we are all sex maniacs," I said trying to laugh as I said in hopes of lightening things up. Theresa smiled at me acknowledging my effort. Karen half smiling and half frowning slapped me on the leg. An overbearing deafening silence seemed to float over the small table.
"I guess that is right Bob, but what do we do about it now? We can't just forget about all of this as Theresa and Karen are sisters," Terry replied.
"I can't believe we didn't figure it out sooner. The descriptions of everyone on Email of each of us were dead-on correct, Theresa spoke up.
"Well Sis, none of us was thinking about family we were looking to get fucked. So it is only natural we wouldn't make the connection as we were all too turned on," Karen calmly answered. For the next twenty minutes the discussion went around in circles as we tried to figure out where we went next.
A pesky thought kept creeping through my mind of what it would have been like to have sex with my sister in law. I really had wanted to see her pussy hair growing back. My libido seemed to be taking over my common sense and I found myself ogling Theresa's tits. Our faces were no longer red but we were no closer to a resolution to our problem.
Terry and Theresa offered to go over and snag us some lunch. While we all were hungry the purpose was obviously to give each couple a chance to chat privately. This became clear when the two of them stopped in the middle of the room and whispered to each other. I whispered to Karen, "This is awkward and I don't know what to do."
"It seems at least part of you knows what it wants to do. I saw you looking at my sister's boobs," she replied sneaking a quick grab of my very erect cock. Sitting back she gave me what can only be described as a wicked smile.
"It is no secret that I've always found Theresa sexy but that doesn't mean we should jump into bed with them," I replied treading carefully. It wouldn't take much for me to give into temptation but wanted the others to give in first, especially Theresa and Karen as this would be true incest for them.
There was no warning or discussion about incest. We all knew what we were talking about. We just had to decide whether to cross the line. Karen then said she saw a large bulge in Terry's pants as he left the table. Then she admitted she would love to see what made that bulge.
She held my hand and told me that if I wanted to go for this she really wanted it too. A minute later we had decided to see if Theresa and Terry wanted to go ahead and if they did we would make our plans accordingly. They were smiling when they returned with a couple of bags of burgers.
We were about half through the burgers before the taboo subject came up again. I had no doubt that Terry was ogling Karen's body or that Theresa was trying to size me up. What I didn't know was whether this translated into them being willing to have sex with us.
"So, you guys want to do this with us or not?" I bluntly asked. My question surprised no one as I tended to be tactless. Everyone's faces began turning pink and the tension was thick. Terry and Theresa looked at each other and he patted her knee. Karen fidgeted in her chair nervously anticipating the answer.
"Well, we talked it over and we don't think that we can say no. Let's finish this food and go back to your place and rip off each other's clothing," he said smiling. Karen was frowning after the first few words but as Terry finished the biggest smile I'd ever seen lit up the room. Suddenly all of the tension left my body.
We had already set up all of the rules and boundaries in our Email discussions. Rules Like no threesomes unless the person left out gave permission because of things like illness or that they were out of town. Terry's blunt response startled me for a moment but I realized he was right as all of the ground work was in place.