Part twooo! Make sure to read part one of this story before you start this one!
-~o~-
"Sweetie? Lilly? Wake up, Lilly."
She did, with a start. Bed. She was on a bed. It wasn't her bed, but it was soft and comfortable. The room around her was unfamiliar. It was large, but sparsely decorated. Aside from the bed, there was a sofa off to her left, and in the corner there was a television next to a large stack of DVDs, and that was it. The walls were bare, the paint old and peeling. Both of the room's two windows were old and grimy, and one of them was cracked. She could just barely make out the glow of the moons through them. She was wearing her tank top and shorts, which was what she had been in underneath her cow costume.
The costume...
The party! The vampire! She clasped her hands to her neck, searching for bite marks, but she felt nothing but smooth, untouched skin.
"Shhh, shh! It's okay! Calm down, sweetie." It was Rose. She was there in the bed with her, dressed in lingerie that Lilly had never seen her wear before. There was a pushup bra, beautiful but unfamiliar, which emphasized her breasts almost as much as her witch costume had, and a pair of panties that covered...
"You're not Rose," said Lilly instantly.
She looked surprised. "How did you..."
"Rose never calls me sweetie. And you don't smell like her. And she doesn't have one of those." She gestured between Not-Rose's legs.
She blinked and looked down at her panties. "What? What does she have, then?"
"Where is she? What did you do to her!?"
"There! She's right there! I did not hurt her!" She said frantically, pointing to a sofa. Just a moment before it had been empty, but now Rose and Mari were both lying on it, still asleep, and still in their costumes. Lilly rushed over and checked their necks, one by one. There were no bite marks.
"How do I know that this is really them?"
Not-Rose tilted her head to the side. "Well... um. I did not think about that... I guess that you don't. You have to trust me."
Lilly took a deep breath. She wanted to scream. The Magnusson person that they had talked to said that they were sending an agent. If she could just distract her until they got here... "That's a little difficult to do when you're impersonating my fucking girlfriend."
"It is them! The real thems! I promise! I just wanted to... I never meant to scare you."
"So instead you decided to lie to me from the moment that I woke up?"
She cringed. "I wanted to make you feel comfortable, since you were so afraid, but... This was a bad idea... I understand that now." Lilly blinked, and all of a sudden she did not look like Rose anymore. She was still wearing the lingerie, but she now looked as she did when they had met her: pale skin, slitted eyes, pointy teeth...
"So what kind of vampire are you?" asked Lilly. "Are you one of the ones that came back with the Quake, or are you newly-made?"
She blinked. "Vampire? You think I am a vampire? Oh! Oh, goodness! No wonder you were so scared!"
"You've got the teeth for it! And if you're not, what was that shit about starving if we leave?"
"I don't want your blood. That is yucky. I, uh..." She rubbed her hands together nervously, and Lilly was starting to have doubts that it was an act. "You want me to be honest. Yes. I have not been honest, and that is bad, and I am very sorry..."
"What do you want from us? You're... You're not going to eat us, are you?"
"No! Nothing like that. I only need to have sex with you. I, uh... Is that still possible?"
Lilly gaped. "You set up an elaborate lie to get the three of us to come here, and now-"
"Well, just those two. I did not know that you would come along, but you were a welcome surprise."
"And now you want me to fuck you? Go fuck yourself! What the hell is wrong with you! If you're actually sorry, then let us leave!"
"I will! I swear, I will! But it took me a week to plan everything and find the courage to bring you here, and I cannot wait that long again. I will let you all go... But I will talk to your friends first. I see that you do not want to do anything with me. I do not blame you. But maybe those two-"
"If you need to fuck somebody just fucking... I don't know, go to a bar or something! Why the hell would you lure people here and then make a whole party... Were all of the guests fake except for us? Are we the only real people here?"
"Please," said Xeplegh, "go back to sleep."
As she said it, exhaustion once again washed over Lilly. "No! I'm not done talking to you!" She fought it, forcing herself to stay awake. "Don't just put me back to sleep, answer my question! Did you invent this whole goddamn party? What is the point?"
"Are you human?" asked Xeplegh.
"What? Yes! Of course I am!"
She tilted her head to the side. "Are you sure?"
"You're just fucking with me now, aren't you?"
"No human has ever resisted my magic. The only ones who... But no, you can't be one of us. You would know if you were, I think... You must just have some sort of natural power... Now, sleep."
The exhaustion swept over her once again, and she raged against it, but it was stronger than ever now. She tried to stand, but she found herself sitting on the couch, next to Rose. She was so warm, and it was so comfortable...
—
"Rose? Time for you to wake up."
She did, without actually opening her eyes. "Hmm? Wha?" She could feel somebody asleep on her shoulder. Somebody who was very soft and warm, and who smelled like milk. Lilly. She cuddled up to her, wrapping an arm around her instinctively.
"I'm sorry that things went like this. I only wanted to have some fun before I fed. I thought that it would be fun for you, too..."
She opened her eyes. She was on a sofa. Lilly was in her arms, asleep, and Mari was asleep next to her. And standing over her...
Everything came back to Rose at once, and at once she was awake. She screamed and kicked Xeplegh in the stomach as hard as she could. She seemed terribly surprised, and collapsed with a grunt.
"Lilly! Mari! Wake up!" Rose shook both of them. "We've got to get out of here! Come on!" They weren't dead- they were both quite clearly breathing, and Lilly even muttered a little bit in her sleep, but no matter what she did, neither of them would wake up. Would she have to carry them? She knew that she could carry Lilly, she had done it many times before, and Mari was probably lighter than her, but she couldn't carry them both at once, and she would probably only have a moment before Xeplegh recovered.
Well, actually... She was still on the floor. And she had curled up into a ball. And she was... crying? And coughing. Sputtering for breath.
"Uh..." Despite everything, Rose suddenly felt a bit guilty. She figured that a kick in the stomach wouldn't do anything to a vampire except surprise her, maybe slow her down a bit, but Xeplegh looked like she was in terrible pain. "Hey, uh-"
"I didn't-" Xeplegh coughed, and it was the wet and sputtering. The kind of cough a person did when they could only barely get air into their lungs. "I didn't want you to be scared! I have never- never been to a party in this time. I thought that if I made one, it could be fun." Her voice came through wheezing gasps.
"But after that you were going to drink our blood!"
"I am not a vampire!" she yelled, and yelling made her cough even more. "I am a succubus!"
"So you're a demon! Don't succubi, I don't know, steal souls, or something?"
"I am not a demon, I am Fae! And no, we don't!"
"But-!" Hmm... She had thought it a bit curious that the Magnusson Paranormal Database had listed succubi and incubi in the same category as sylvans and faeries. Xeplegh didn't look like she was going to get up any time soon, so Rose reached between her breasts for her phone... Ah. It wasn't there. She must have left it in the bathroom, but she wasn't about to leave Lilly and Mari alone with this creature, whatever she was, so that she could wander around and find it.
"I have been away from the world for so long, and the world has forgotten what I am," said Xeplegh. Her coughing was starting to cease, but she was still crying, and she was still on the floor. "I do not want to take your souls. I do not even have that power. I do not want to hurt you. I just wanted to make you feel good, and- and have friends, and laugh and be happy."
"But... If you wanted to be friends you could have just, you know... Talked to us, instead of sending us fake text messages to trick people into coming to your illusory party."
She curled herself up even tighter. "Yes, I know! I lied to you and that is bad and I am sorry! It's just that- every time I- I..."
"Listen," said Rose. "Why don't you wake Mari and Lilly up, and we can all talk about this? You know, if you really want to make friends with us, that's the way to do it. By being honest."
"I already woke Lilly up," said Xeplegh miserably. "She hates me."
"I mean, if everything you're telling me right now is really true, I don't think she would. But you have to earn our trust, if you want to be friends."
"She yelled at me. It made me feel bad."
"Well, yeah. It takes a lot to really get Lilly fired up, but when she's angry, she's a firecracker. And lying to all of us in order to get us in your house is something that would make her understandably very angry."
"I need to have sex with one of you. I can't wait long enough to find anyone else. And you and Lilly don't want to."
"Even if we did, we're kind of a package deal. We'll do threesomes, but for that to work we both need to be into you. So, you should wake her up, so that-"