Chapter 4 - Holy's Ass and the Golden Buttplug
Monika came, and came as soon as she got to my place. It was not even her fault, as she tripped in the doorway, landing ass-first on one of the lockboxes. It was a little golden orb, and when she sat on it her face opened wide in shock while her asshole swallowed it whole. I realized the box was small, but it was still about four inches wide. Monika must have been making do with anal stimulation a lot now that we figured out her curse.
Fau came up to help the priest out, but found herself pussy to mouth as Monika turned into her walking up. In that instant, Faustyna's top button fell off, exposing her to Monika's mouth in an inhale of breath, sucking her pussy lips into her mouth.
"Whoa, your friend moves fast," Fau said, grabbing hold of Monika's head to push her away from the suction, only to look down to find a drip of saliva on Monika's face. Perhaps inspired by my suggestion, Fau crouched down to lick the drool off Monika's face into a kiss. "Yup, that was mine. Sorry about that."
Monika blushed and tried to stand up, but the small box was still inside her, so I stepped in to help her up. We sat and watched the small priest girl try to push the ball of gold out of her asshole, smiling with enjoyment before Fau decided to help her.
"I'm going to stick a finger in to try and dig it out, ok?" She asked, then slipped TWO fingers into Monika's pussy, hitting the penetration limiter. "Whoa, there is a barrier."
"Yeah, it's part of her curse," I said. "There is one in her ass as well, that's probably why the box is still visible. Can you wiggle it out?" I watched her fingers the few inches of space in Monika's pussy while she yipped in cancelled orgasms.
"You can heal, right?" Fau asked. I knew where the idea was heading, but could not stop her as she pulled out a dagger to cut the sphincter trying to close for just a moment as the golden ball of a box fell out. Monika's face contorted in pain, but she centered her golden holy power to heal up the wound back to normal. She stood back up and lowered her skirt to hide herself away. It was nice seeing her in something else, and I wondered if she did that on purpose. I remembered Fau saying that she wore no underwear, and this confirmed it. Neither did I under my robes, but it was different for some horny mage when compared to a holy vessel.
"I am so sorry about this, Szymon," she said, bowing. I held up my hand that still had a hole through it and smiled.
"Wanna lick it?" I asked stupidly, then fanned out my hands to stop her thinking weird thoughts. "Sorry, Fau liked licking it, is all. I understand a priest wouldn't like the same stuff."
"I-- I can!" Monika burst out, blushing red. I held up the hand and dropped the magic again. Monika took the hand, and licked the surface, then teased her tongue in the hole while looking in my eyes. She was so shy about it compared to Faustyna. When her tongue went entirely through the hand, I leaned down and sucked on it for a moment, before giving it back to her.
"Well? How do I taste?" I asked, hoping to get another confession from Moni that she had never tasted a girl.
"Kinda like a very hard vulva while on the period," Monika said. "I guess you taste like a girl, but you probably feel it less."
"Damn, holy," Fau said. "You go down on many girls?"
"Just a few," she replied, then smiled with a blush probably remembering it. She must have been an entirely different person before the curse, and now just stumbled everywhere getting into sexual situations she could not benefit from. "Let me heal that up for you."
I watched as her holy power coated my hand, stitching it back together. I flexed it, good as new, and realized Fau still had her pants unbuttoned. We shared a look of soundless agreement, as I walked over to rub her pussy while Monika watched.
"Oh, sorry!" She exclaimed. "I will leave you to it." I held out a hand to stop her, and accidentally pulled the cloth off her shoulder. She looked back so fragile.
"I haven't thanked you properly yet," I said. "If you're up for it, want to join Faustyna and I for a bit of fun?" Moni looked away.
"Come on, holy," she said, then opened her mouth as I slipped a finger inside her. "Be my first?"
"Y-- Your first?"
"My first girl, that is," Fau said. "You have more motion than me when it comes to that, it seems. Come on! Have some fun."
"I-- I'm sorry, but I should go!" Monika pulled on my hold of her robe as one of her tits popped out all bouncy. I wasted no time to find that holy nipple in my mouth, and she gasped from surprise. "I-- I can't come! I want your first time with a girl to not be burdened by my curse!"
"Guess we have to break the curse first then," Faustyna said. "Then we break Monika in, together." I slipped a second finger inside her as she let out a soft moan, which made me suck harder on Moni's nipple, which also prompted a moan out of her. I felt my erection poking up again, ready to bury myself in either of the beautiful women in my presence.
"I will take your virginity," I said, sounding cheesy, but Fau looked entertained.
"Not if I take it first," she said, as I teased a third finger in her opening, but her hand caught my wrist, which freed Monika from my grasp and my mouth. She blushed crimson at the attention, and bowed in thanks before hurrying out without remembering to cover her exposed boob. That curse was some ditzy power play of some loser warlock. The cooler warlocks didn't torment priests, only summoning demons to fuck, or ones that could fuck them.
"Oh right, you wanted me to talk to some of my warlock buds," I said.
"Definitely," she said. "But let's take care of this right now, ok?" She looked down, then reached out to smooth a hand over my robes, cupping the head of my cock to rub precum into the fabric.
"Same time?"
"Get some magic involved this time, magic," Faustyna said, setting her ass down on the desk with my fingers still inside her. Tightly pressed up against her pants that lost a button and unzipped randomly for Moni. I smirked, picturing an object coming into being right at her sphincter, and going right up into her asshole where she sat. Fau's mouth opened to a moan-sigh of enjoyment, as I felt the butt plug inside against the wall of her pussy.
"Wider," she said, and I raised my eyebrows, growing the buttplug a bit inside her tight ass. "And a bit longer. Make it your size."
"You sure it won't fuck with the vault in there?"
"Stop asking questions and just put your magic cock deep inside me!" I felt a shiver of excitement as I expended the butt plug more until she started gripping my dick hard from the pressure. Her eyes went wild, on fire, with her mouth open. I wanted to bury myself down her throat so badly, and found myself looking down at her purple hair still tied up in a bun with eyes as golden as every time I saw them. I used magic to move the cock in her ass, while she supplemented herself with one hand on the clit, and one holding my cock steady to suck on it.
I wanted to push her head in, force myself fully inside, but let her control that side while I sped up moving the cock in her ass that did not care one bit that she still had pants on. She was the only one feeling the pressure of the magic inside her asshole. When I was close, I slipped myself out of her to bring us back to the first time we met, leaving a dollop of cum over her face in a few spurts. I half expected her to shadowstep behind me and knock me out, but she just wiped some off her eyes and held it out to me.
I sucked on those fingers right away, tasting the cum in my mouth, together with her sweat and flesh, scraping my teeth on her knuckles as she finished herself looking up from inside cum still coating her face. I wanted to help, but she grabbed hold of my lower jaw when the pleasure of my magic cock and her clit rubbing brought her a release, dragging me down by the teeth and bone to her pussy. I needed no instruction, sucking on her folds as they twitched in unison to my sucking.
"You gonna pull your cock out, or just leave it in my ass?" Faustyna asked a few minutes later. I was too aware of the mana drain, but held it fully inserted to get her there. "Pop me like a cork."
I pulled the whole thing without shrinking it in size, and heard a slurp instead of a pop as her asshole started tightening back up. It would take some time after getting pushed to such a degree, but it was what she wanted to get off. I helped her take off the pants afterward, as we both cleaned up in the bathroom. She seemed to be enjoying being around me for the first time, rather than just using me.
"Open wide," she said, then poured something bitter in my mouth.
"W-- What was that?"
"Poison," she said.
"You're kidding," I said, then found her eyes. She wasn't kidding, or she was really good at lying. She raised her eyebrows.
"Fine, it's something a lot more expensive," she said. "Enjoy yourself as I ask you some questions and you answer me truthfully."
"Truth serum?" I asked, feeling dizzy, Fau guided me to the edge of the bathtub, as I slipped inside. She climbed in beside me with hot water pouring out at our feet, making the bathroom steamy.
"Works best in a warm place that gives the feeling of safety," she said. "You're safe beside me, magic."
"I feel safe beside you," I said, feeling giddy all of a sudden.
"Good, now tell me, how do you really feel about Faustyna. You can tell me anything, I'm your most trusted friend."
"I can tell you anything," I said. "I trust you. Faustyna? Oh, I'm so in love with her that she could peel the skin off my whole body with tiny cuts, and I would let her do it if it made her happy. I feel like it would."
"Do you really love her?"