But, what if...
It was a herculean effort for Elea to dismiss all the carnal thoughts that came to her mind as she felt the proud grinther's pride swell beneath her, a shiver working its way through her slim body. His offer was so, so tempting to her. Nothing in her life had ever made her feel like
that
before, so... good. That was the only word for it, even though everything that led up to it was inarguably bad. No, inarguably
terrible
. There was nothing right about him cornering her, bullying her, ripping her clothes off of her and then taking the rookie adventurer's first time from her, no matter how kindly his tongue had soothed her pains and anxiety.
And then, if that wasn't bad enough, he took it and put it in her... in her
asshole
, of all things. As inexperienced and naive as Elea may have been, even she knew that wasn't where a man was supposed to put his
cock
. It absolutely should not have made her body explode the way it did, even compared to when it was where it was supposed to go. Even now, her ass was still sore from his rough penetration, almost as sore as he had left her womanhood after fucking it a second time with his
cock.
With his
cock
; she didn't even think of it as a penis anymore, his insistence on making her call it that crude word, crying it out and shouting it as he fucked her, managing to erase the far more precise and polite word from her vocabulary, at least in his presence. Despite that soreness, she could feel herself wet, and she could feel herself still dripping his cum, dried and drying streaks of it running down her thighs. Yes, his offer for her to stay was tempting, but she knew it was wrong.
Absolutely nothing that had happened in the last day was really good, no matter how it made her feel. It couldn't be. It went against everything she had learned.
Elea bit roughly on her bottom lip, cheeks flushed, then gathered her resolve. For all her effort, she knew pushing aside those carnal thoughts was a temporary thing. It was clear that she needed to make a decision here and now. Even hesitating a moment longer in Chrysus' lap could prove fatal to her willpower, to her ability to stand strong beside the decision she knew she
should
make. Her eyes searched the cave for a clue of what she should do. Surprisingly, she quickly found it on the floor, amongst her ruined clothes.
The slim brunette carefully rose despite how her hips ached and her weak-kneed legs protested any strenuous movement, taking a wobbling step towards the pile of shredded fabric. A part of her regretted leaving the safety of his lap and the temptation of his hardened cock, but she kept it pushed down while she could. Groaning quietly at the simple strain of it after her ordeal, Elea lowered herself into a squat and picked up one of her daggers, still unused, its immaculate and unbloodied blade so well-polished she could see her own warped reflection in the firelight that lit up the mirror sheen.
Slowly, Elea turned back towards Chrysus and rose back to her wobbling full height, one hand reaching back to gather up the long fall of her brown hair and bring it over her shoulder. In her home village of Fain, they had a simple tradition to prove one's sincerity when making an oath. She swallowed softly and hesitated for a moment as she lifted the blade. While she was not a particularly vain young woman, she knew she would miss however much of her hair she cut off. Even when she was a child, she wore it long, sometimes a little past the middle of her back and sometimes a little before it, but never much shorter than that.
To prove herself in both his eyes and hers, she would finally change that. The blade lifted.
Chrysus simply watched, unconcerned, his almost beady little eyes betraying only a mild curiosity as to what Elea would say and do next. Even if she left him today, he knew that he had left his mark on her. Wherever she went and whatever she did with the rest of her life, she would never forget him. She would always be his; she'd always remember her first. She belonged to him now, after all, and always would, even if they never met again.
Elea hesitated. Chrysus' eyes lifted and ticked slightly to the side, his interest in her suddenly dwindling, caught by something that Elea was far too distracted to notice. And then, right as the rookie adventurer was about to bring her dagger down and make her commitment to her captor, right as she was about to promise that she wouldn't betray him to the Bloodshrouds if he let her go -- a large hand caught her wrist and suddenly squeezed it with frightening strength, causing her fingers to quickly uncurl in both surprise and fright. The dagger fell from her hand, clattering to the cave's stone floor. At the same time, a shriek left Elea's throat, quickly cut off unlike her hair, the first hand's partner covering her mouth and muffling it.
Elea's eyes were left wide, her heart hammering away in the prison of her ribcage, her body beginning to shake.
W-what-- oh gosh, what--
Her mind was afire, racing with panic just like her chest. She tried to turn her head to look at whomever grabbed her, but she had little luck, their hand on her mouth exerting pressure and keeping her from turning her head. Even with the sudden surge of adrenaline pumping through her body she didn't even consider trying to struggle in another way. She couldn't have, not with how loose and also sore Chrysus had made her.
"Why would you let this little thing have a sharp object?" a deep, guttural voice asked behind her. Deep, but not as deep as Chrysus'. More husky, throaty. More... feminine? "You know how clumsy humans are." The female Grinther who had all but snuck up behind Elea chuffed. "And how fragile they are. What would you have done if she cut herself? Kiss it better, Chrysus?"
Chrysus snorted, barely budging from where he sat, shameless about his exposure, his meaty cock standing up tall and proud from his lap now that Elea's comparatively scant weight was no longer pinning it down. Confronted with the direct sight of the thing that had taken her virginity made Elea's heart pound faster, her cheeks getting redder. "Enough, Priscilla." He lifted one of his hands and motioned with his fingers. "Give her to me," he demanded, with just the barest hint of a threat backing those words, a sharp edge behind his laziness, his indulgence. It was paired with possessiveness.
Priscilla scoffed, then released Elea's throat and mouth, giving her a sharp shove towards the leader of the grinthers. The panicking girl couldn't help but cry out again, stumbling and almost tumbling right back into Chrysus' lap, made once more to feel the warmth of his cock and its stiffness against her skin. He drew Elea into his lap and wrapped one of his immense arms around her, all but pinning her into that contact and making it resolutely clear to Priscilla (and the other grinther soldiers who came into the cave after her) just who Elea belonged to. For her part, the rookie adventurer laid her hand on his chest and curled her fingers into its hair, shuddering. His other hand manipulated her body gently, subtly, turning her just so, adjusting the way her thighs lay just so.
For Elea, there was little in the way of comfort in the cave's cramped confines; the fire being one of them, and her blanket (well, her cloak) being another. Chrysus' hand slowly stroking along her back surprisingly proved to be another such source. She swallowed, took a deep breath, and forced herself to begin calming, to pay attention to her captors. Something was going on here; the grinther soldiers were grinning, their female leader included.
"You have something to report?" Chrysus asked, continuing to stroke at Elea's skin, coaxing her into a state of relaxation. Each slide of his hand ended with his hand on the delicious curve of her ass, giving it a soft squeeze that made the rookie adventurer give a soft gasp each time, those muscles tensing in a delightful reaction. It was gentle. Gentle enough after everything else he had done to her, at least. If she could see how the two of them looked to the other grinthers in the cave, she may not have been so accepting of it. What was simple comfort to her just looked like a man and his favorite pet to them.