She woke up to the feeling of her breast being grabbed. Avery kept her eyes closed and remained quiet as she tried to figure out what was happening. Even with her eyes shut she could tell it was completely dark in the room; it was still night. She was on her side, and someone was groping her from behind. Matt? Did Matt get into her bed while she was asleep? Great. She did not appreciate him deciding to use her while she was asleep, but she couldn't exactly refuse, either.
His arm reached over her side, gently squeezing her left boob as he played with it. His fingers closed around her nipple, slightly pinching and twisting it. Avery bit her lip, trying not to squeal as he continued toying with it. That's when she felt his length touch her bare ass. Oh god, here we go.
Matt grinded himself against her, quietly moaning as he did. Then he removed his hand from her breast and she breathed out in relief. That is, until she felt the same hand slide in between her legs and touch her clit. Avery could feel her face getting red again as she anticipated what was about to happen. Matt began slowly rubbing it, moving his fingers in a circular motion as he did. Unlike the face fucking she'd partaken in before, Avery couldn't deny she was actually enjoying this. She failed to stop a quiet moan exiting her body as he continued rubbing her clit, but she was pretty sure Matt still believed she was asleep. She would still have made noise even if she wasn't conscious, right?
Matt stopped playing with her clit and Avery was sad he was stopping so soon, but then he readjusted his fingers and spread apart her pussy lips. A second later, she felt a bulge press up against her open lips and she froze. Matt paused for just a moment, and then slowly pushed in and took her. Avery gasped as his dick slid up inside her. She thought she was going to pass out right then and there from the sensation, and she involuntarily clenched up around him. Matt groaned in response and put his arm back over her waist to hold her there. Avery didn't know how to describe what she was feeling. She felt so... full. She was used to that being, well, empty space, and now something was inside that space. She almost felt like she was... complete.
It was a tight fit, and it took Matt some effort to partially pull out of her before thrusting back in. Avery moaned out louder, and Matt moved his other hand up underneath her head and grasped her chin. As he thrust into her and Avery opened her mouth again, he slid two fingers between her lips. She closed her mouth around them, sucking on them as she whimpered. At this point she didn't care if Matt knew she was awake, as long as he continued what he was doing. Seeing as she seemed to be okay with her situation, Matt decided to pick things up. He slowly thrust into her again and again, each time drawing louder and louder moans from the demon girl. Each time he buried himself into her a little more, his breathing getting louder as he got deeper and deeper. While he kept his pace, he made sure not to go too fast or too rough. He wanted Avery's first experience to be enjoyable, and something she'd want to do again in the future - not something that was too much for her, and would only make her regret it.
As Matt eased into her, each thrust was accompanied by a sloppy squelch as both their fluids met. Avery grabbed the arm around her waist and held it tightly as she was fucked, continuing to suck on the fingers in her mouth. She didn't know why she had waited this long to experience this; she'd never felt anything like this her whole life. At this point she didn't even mind if the townspeople lusted over her. They might want her for their own benefit but she would enjoy it just as much.
Even though Matt was going at a reasonably slow pace, Avery couldn't stop herself from crying a bit anyways, still moaning. The sensation she was feeling was still very new and almost too much for her. She opened her mouth and turned her upper body around to look back at him for comfort, tears in her bright green eyes. Matt leaned forward and their lips met as he kissed her.
Avery felt herself getting close as his cock continued to slide back and forth against her inner walls. Just then, Matt buried himself all the way inside her and stayed there as a loud moan escaped his lips. Avery felt the same gooey strands shoot up inside her, and she moaned out as well. He pumped into her a few more times, then stopped. They both lied there panting as Matt removed himself from her. Avery still looked back at him with a sad look on her face. "Wait, don't stop." Matt stroked her hair with his right hand and moved his left down to her pussy lips again. He started rubbing her clit again with increasing speed and she started whimpering again. A few seconds later her body convulsed and she came, moaning loudly. After she was done she fell back on the bed on her back, shaking. Matt smiled and leaned down to her, kissing her again. He repositioned himself so he was lying on his side towards her, and she reached a hand out to him with a whimper. He grasped it with interlocked fingers and he looked down at her. "How was that?" he asked.
Avery stared back at him. "Can we do that again?" she asked softly. They had just finished but Avery found herself just as horny and wanting more. Unfortunately, Matt declined, smiling. "Tomorrow. For now, sleep."
"Wait, don't go. Stay with me," she replied, pulling on his hand. After a moment of consideration, Matt threw the blanket over the two of them and put his arm back around her. Avery immediately closed her eyes. Whatever her thoughts on Matt had been before didn't matter anymore. This experience had changed her, and she was happy where she was right now.