Thank you Gustavca for your help with editing this story
***************
There was a possibility I was pregnant with William's child and the guilt and self-reproach for what I had done was overwhelming. I had felt drawn to William. He was physically attractive, smart, and ambitious. He treated me as if I mattered to him, was important to him regardless of racial and social taboos. I think William, in his own way, offered closeness and intimacy with another person, something I so desperately wanted and needed but I couldn't get from Robert.
I broke it off with William never telling him about the pregnancy. My tears and regret, along with his anger, recriminations, and of course hurt masculine pride filled our last meeting.
"Suppose I'm not ready for it to end?" he said angrily. "I could fuck you right here and no one would know, Cass. I could bend you over, fuck you hard, put your ass in that buggy and send you home, wet with my cum dripping out of you and you wouldn't tell a soul, would you?"
He'd never spoken to me like that. I had never felt threatened or frightened by William, but I did that day. He came toward me and I flinched when he suddenly lifted his hand. He looked at me, surprised at my reaction.
"Did you think I was going to hit you?" he said with disbelief in his voice. "Go home, Cassie . . . go home."
That was the last time I saw or heard from William.
Though not perfect, our lives soon fell into a familiar pattern. Robert was usually at his office in town during the day and I spent most of mine gardening (his mother had cultivated the most beautiful rose garden), working with my horses, visiting friends, charity work and occasionally substituting at the school.
I did not leave Robert, learning I was pregnant all but made that impossible. Except for Janine, no one else knew I was expecting, not even Momma. It was difficult not to tell her, I think in my heart I knew it was Robert's child but, the fact remained, I had been with both men and the possibility of either being the father was undeniable. I didn't feel I could deal with the questions or the necessary lies, and so I said nothing for as long as I possibly could. It was still very early in my pregnancy and, if Janine was right, with my small frame and this being my first baby, I might not become obvious until my fourth or maybe even fifth month, time enough for me to figure out what I was going to do.
*****
Janine and I were in the garden gathering the last of the roses one afternoon.
"You feeling okay, honey?" Janine asked.
"Oh yes, I'm a little tired, but I feel fine," I said.
She turned, picked a few more flowers then, out of the blue, "When was the last time you seen William?" she wanted to know.
I looked at her puzzled.
"Janine, why would you ask me about William? You know I ended it with him. I haven't seen or heard from him in weeks."
I stood there watching her, remembering the last time William and I had been together, feeling more than ever convinced I had made the right decision. The pain and heartbreak from Robert and the betrayal of Janine had felt crushingly oppressive for a long time; William helped me see that I could be happy. What happened between William and me was wrong, and as horrible and insensitive as Robert could be, he was still my husband.
Nothing in my background or experience had prepared me for my marriage or life with a person like Robert Grafton. Though I could never forgive and forget the things that had happened, I tried desperately to reconcile what I had hoped my life would be with what it actually had become.
The sound of Janine's voice startled me out of my revelry, "I said, I guess you don't need to worry about him anymore, good riddance. I know you cared about him, Sweetness, but we both know it was for the best." Janine repeated herself.
"What do you mean, I don't need to worry about him?"
Janine took a deep breath and pretended she was arranging the flowers. "Last I heard he married that girl he'd been seeing. He'd gotten her pregnant, you know. Seems William got into some kinda accident, and they just all a sudden packed up and moved all the way out to Toledo Bend."
"Janine, that makes no sense at all. William had worked very hard to get his business started here and his brother is here too. He'd never just pack up and move away like that," I said.
"Well, I don't know about all that, but that's what I heard."
That night at dinner, we were talking, and without thinking, I foolishly asked Robert if he had heard anything about William Lathrop suddenly moving out of town.
He stopped eating and looked at me guardedly, before saying, "As a matter of fact, I did hear something about that. I was at William's shop a few weeks back and it was boarded up then. Pendleton says he decided to move to Toledo Bend out in Sabine County. His new wife has people up that way."
"Robert, that doesn't make sense," I said skeptically.
"You seem awful interested in this William. You and William were friends, weren't you?" he asked watching me closely.
"We were acquaintances," I said, unable to look at him. "You can't have forgotten you've had him here working off and on for at least the last three or four months."
He got up, walked over to the open dining room window and lit one of his cheroots.
"You know Chuck Jimerson? He works at the livery?" he asked matter of factly. "He says a couple of times when he's been shoeing horses out at old Mrs. Bingham's, he's seen you and William out on the back road talking, real friendly like talking and when you'd see him coming, you'd ride off down the road and William would head off in the other direction. Now, Cassie, the question in my mind is why would Mrs. Robert Grafton be out on a deserted back road talking real friendly to a nigger?"
With clear certainty the thought 'he knows' formed in my mind and then the realization that it was him, he had hurt William.
"How could you let that nigger touch you?" he shouted, his face contorted in rage.
He came around the dining table and grabbing my arms pulled me so close I could smell the alcohol on his breath, "You little whore, you let him fuck you, didn't you? You're not going to tell me he forced you, are you, Cassie? We both know that would be a lie," he all but spat the words into my face.
Hearing the ruckus, Janine ran from the kitchen into the dining room. Seeing Robert, she began trying to pull him off me, to pry his hands away.
"Mr. Robert, Mr. Robert, stop, please stop, you're going to hurt her . . . stop!" Janine screamed at him.
He pushed me away from him and I stumbled backward into one of the chairs and sat down.
I looked up at him defiantly, "what did you do to him? What did you do?" I screamed.
He looked at me as if he wanted to strangle me and said, "Did you think I wouldn't find out about you two, Cassie? I had a couple of men go out to his shack. I thought about having the nigger killed, but decided a good beating would be enough to persuade him to stay away from you."
"It was over, Robert, had been over. Why did you have to hurt him?" I foolishly asked in my naivetΓ©.
He said nothing, just stood there seething, and then, "Why, Cassie, why with a nigger?" He asked taking my face in his hands.
"Oh my god! Is that all you're concerned about? His being a nigger? Would it have been okay if he had been a white man?" I replied angrily. "I cared about him, you bastard! Can you understand that? Robert, do you know how much I wanted to love you? You didn't want that from me, did you? Can you even imagine what it's been like knowing, feeling that I had never been anything to you except . . . except a receptacle?"
Janine hurriedly came and stood next to my chair and started schussing me, "That's enough, honey, don't say any more. Please, baby, that's enough."
I turned and looking directly at Robert wanting to hurt him, not caring what I said, "I wonder, is this how it was for your first wife, Robert? She wasn't a tramp or whore like you wanted people to believe, was she? I mean, like me, did she finally have to turn to someone else because you kept rejecting her, because you really didn't want her as a wife? You couldn't forgive her for that, could you? Even though it was you who pushed her to it."
He looked as if I'd slapped him.
I sat there, Janine holding my hand, my hot tears falling unchecked.