This story occurred during my earliest days with Jamie (see Jamie stories for background), about the time we'd first met. We'd met and were seeing each other fairly regularly, but were not boyfriend and girlfriend. I liked her, but she had some tendencies and issues that I didn't like. I met Becky Jo about the same time. After about 6 months Becky Jo went off the deep end, and I quit seeing her all together. She and I were never what you'd call boyfriend and girlfriend; not even close really. So I juggled the two, without ever having any intention of staying with either of them.
Yeah, Jamie could be fun and we had some good times and she had a nasty streak to her, which I later learned was more than a little perverted. She was also a psychology major in college and, after graduation, entered into a graduate program in which she specialized in abnormal psychology, focusing on aberrant sexuality. She came up with some pretty wild ideas. Many of them were interesting and fun. But, many more were just plain weird - to the point that I didn't want anything to do with them. Still, when she'd get that wild glint in her eye, I knew something was coming, probably something I'd like.
Early on in my relationship with Jamie I'd also met this chick named Becky-Jo. Yep, that was her real name - Ok, very close to her real name, don't want anybody suing me. She lived on a farm with her divorced mom and her grandparents (who actually owned the farm). She was pretty cute, with medium length, very light blonde hair, nice little titties, a beautiful smile and funny looking round eye-glasses (think: John Denver).
I didn't seek Becky-Jo out. I can't even remember how we met, but it was around the time when I'd first met Jamie. Becky-Jo somehow developed a knack for showing up at my cabin when Jamie was there. I don't know how she'd know when Jamie was there, she just started showing up, with uncanny timing. My cabin was at the end of a long, dead-end canyon and Becky-Jo's grandparents lived on a farm at the bottom of the canyon, nowhere near the road heading up. I always figured she had a friend, who lived up the canyon, that'd call her when she'd see Jamie's white Mustang Fastback (GT 350 Fastback that Daddy bought for her). Who knows? She didn't show up every time Jamie was there, but pretty damn often, and usually within minutes of Jamie's arrival.
Anyway, she'd show up, and the tension in the air, between those two chicks was palpable. I wasn't in love with either of them and I thought it was funny as hell. Sometimes I'd intentionally slip in little remarks, just to spur it on a little. Becky Jo was shameless and she'd make catty remarks like "you can just feel the negative energy in here." Jamie had a short temper and those remarks would piss her off to no end.
Of course, even as a guy that was fairly clueless about how women interacted with each other, especially when another guy is involved, I could tell that Becky-Jo made those comments just to piss Jamie off. And, it worked! When Jamie got mad, she had this birthmark that you couldn't normally see. Except when she got mad and her blood pressure went up, this red "V" shaped mark would appear right between her eyebrows and up onto part of her forehead.
Whenever Becky-Jo was there, that mark glowed like a beacon in the night. I thought it was funny and I think Becky-Jo thought it was funny, but Jamie hated her guts and didn't think it was funny at all. Even before I'd picked up on it, Jamie knew that Becky-Jo was after me. Becky-Jo would show up on regular intervals, hang around just long enough to really piss Jamie off, then leave. After a few of these visits, when she'd leave she'd make vaguely suggestive sexual remarks to me, and she started kissing me on the cheek and whispering things in my ear.
Of course, that made Jamie furious. But, we weren't an item. We weren't in a steady relationship, so she was just a girlfriend to me, but one with no commitments or strings. I have to admit, after awhile, I used to look forward to the whole dynamic between the two girls - it was pretty damn funny.
When I realized that Becky-Jo was interested in me, I wasn't really all that interested in her. She had some weird mannerisms. Plus, she usually dressed in jeans and plaid cowgirl shirts that were baggy on her and certainly not very flattering. She dressed more like a boy and rarely wore any makeup. In fact, her clothes were so baggy and unflattering, the first time I saw her without clothes, I was completely shocked at what was hidden under those dirty farm clothes.
So, when you combined her farm clothes with the funny glasses and a bit of an attitude, she just wasn't my gig. Still, I liked her enough as a friend and, I admit, even if it was mean, I really liked watching her punch Jamie's buttons! She was good at it and Jamie would get so pissed. What can I say, I wasn't in love with either of them and what guy doesn't like watching two chicks fight over him?
One day, Becky-Jo invited me down to her farm to go horseback riding. I knew how to ride, but at that point in my life I wasn't all that experienced (my experience and expertise with horses began to change dramatically a couple of years later). So, we saddled up. Becky-Jo made sure everything was just right on my horse, and I didn't care for that at all. I wasn't a complete greenhorn.
Anyway, we rode off into the rolling hills, and eventually went up to the top of the ridge that paralleled the canyon where I lived. We had a good talk, she was funny and easy to be around. By the time we stopped for a little break, I'd come to view Becky-Jo in an entirely different light. It didn't hurt that instead of her usual baggy pants and shirt, she was now wearing skintight wranglers and a nicely fitted snap-front shirt that was unsnapped a snap farther than normal. When you added in a little push-up bra. The whole package looked pretty damn good!
We tied the horses off and sat down, side-by-side, leaning up against a big log. As we talked, even I realized that her whole demeanor had changed. She was cute and flirty and acting just a little shy. I liked it, a lot! It didn't take long until we kissed, then we were making out, and soon I had a few more snaps undone and had my hand on a very nice set of tits. They weren't huge - maybe bigger than a baseball, barely. They were very soft, not squishy, just extraordinarily feminine. The softness of her tits was starkly contrasted by very hard and almost strangely long nipples.
When I'd touch them or roll one between my fingers she'd gasp and pant and start breathing harder. They were definitely a hot-button for her and I liked that a lot, too. It didn't take long for me to get her shirt completely unsnapped. But, she wouldn't let me take it off her. I did manage to get her bra unhooked and when I sucked one of her nipples into my mouth she gasped, loudly! The more I sucked on them the more she moaned, and she wreathed in my arms almost like she was trying to get away, but not quite. The whole effect made me hard as hell.
I managed to get her pants unsnapped and her zipper down. Her Wranglers were skin-tight and I had to work to get my fingers down to her pussy. When I finally got my hand deep enough into her pants, I rubbed my middle finger over her slit as I sucked her nipple back into my mouth. She squirmed and gasped and moaned and said "No." But, she wasn't pushing me away and she wasn't trying to get away. In fact, she wasn't saying it like she really meant it. She said it in a horse, slightly high-pitched little whisper that was more inviting than repellent.