*********************
If you haven't done so already, please read The Rugby Squad (Prequel) to get the backstory. The following is based on true events *********************
The week after getting the motorcycle, things continued to heat up with me and Kelly, while I had to distance myself from Cara. Truthfully, I had no interest in Cara due to my Golden Rule to never fuck a friends girlfriend or ex (and I technically didn't) and things were gravitating towards "couple status" with Kelly, which I wanted. She was giving in so many ways, and like other past relationships, she became obsessed and possessive of my physiologically perfect 7.5 inch cock. I didnt mind though, it was somewhat flattering in a way, and her "do anything you want to me" depraved sense of sexuality had me hooked as well. Cum loads had been spilled, and it was clear where things were headed. We were in a grey area in our relationship, but also rapidly approaching a convergence of circumstances in ditching singledom and cutting the baggage with other people.
As expected, after what had happened with Cara, I was getting text message after text message the following week. "Hey, sup?" "Hey, what u up to?" and the like. I largely ignored her until on Saturday morning, she called me instead. Kelly was morning-after slow stroking my still bloated cock, with her rhinestoned "Cum Whore" black leather choker left on from the night before. The glossy, hot pink ball gag was on the nightstand, and a crotchless pair of black lace panties, dried cum around the stretched hole seam.
"Who's calling this early?" Kelly asked, clearly annoyed.
"It's Cara," I said. "Maybe it's serious, most people don't... call... I should probably answer it."
Kelly sighed, stopped playing with me, and rolled over.
"What's up?" I said, answering the call from Cara.
"Oh nuthinnnnngggg," came the voice on the other end. "I got some free tickets to this play and was looking for somebody to go with. What are you up to?"
"Well, I have Kelly here with me," I answered.
"She can come too," Cara replied, "I have extra seats."
Cara could never take no for an answer and always had her next move ready in advance.
I put her on hold and asked Kelly what she wanted to do.
"I thought you didn't want me hanging out with her, that she is a relationship wrecking slut?" Kelly said wryly.
After some deliberating and convincing that it would be a nice afternoon out as "decent" people, we agreed to meet Cara later that day.
"Oh- I also have some amazing blow by the way," Cara said before hanging up the phone.
When I told Kelly this, she perked up from bed. I knew from that story I had heard that she loved nothing more than to get numb and pounded hard in her face and pussy. I was still unsure if she'd ever been gangbanged before, but the thought had crossed my mind a few times.
Later around 2 PM, we met at the playhouse, which was a short distance from a local Rugby bar. For "decent people", neither girl was wearing a bra, and Kelly had on a pleated tennis-style skirt. It was off-white and slightly see-through, and her hot pink G-string wasn't helping our case. Her PAWG butt and high hips pushed the skirt up slightly higher in the rear, exposing her lower tush every so often.
At the play, I sat between Kelly and Cara, and Cara slid by me in the row as her tighter, heart-shaped brunette butt in short, black denim shorts grazed by my face.
"Oh excuse me," she said flirtatiously.
Her pussy wafted a latex condom and cum smell like she also had sex the night before, and hadn't bothered to have a shower (I also wondered why she had even bothered with condoms). When she sat down next to me, one of her fat, purpleish, shaved pussy lips accidentally slid out of her shorts.
"Oops," Cara said, blushing, as the theater lights dimmed down.
During the show, I was holding Kelly's arm and stroking her wrist while Cara kept brushing her leg against me. When there was a funny part, we all would laugh and Cara continued to laugh and lean in and playfully touch my chest while putting her head on my shoulder, but never long enough for Kelly to take notice.
During the Intermission, we all took turns doing a few key bumps of blow in the restroom, and drank 2 glasses of chardonnay each. Outside in a courtyard, Cara modelled for me again while Kelly was powdering her nose. I looked through the glass French doors from the courtyard as Kelly walked from the restroom, as some older rich-looking men stopped to hit on her. Their eyes kept glacing down at her braless DD's in a tight halter top, and at her bare, all-american countrygirl legs disippating in some wicker wedge heel shoes. Hard to walk in, the shoes made her stumble and sway around like a prostitute. They all eventually looked my way and the one gentleman winked and nodded towards me while making a little finger gun and raising his plastic wine tumbler in a little "Cheers" gesture.
The girls were now a bit looser, and my ego now feeling stronger about being with two extremely hot and (extra) slutty girls. My cock started waking up and yearning for attention. During the second half of the play, Kelly's hand fell to my lap and lightly stroked my bulge while Cara kept looking down at it, alternating between biting her lower lip in jealousy, and pushing her tongue into her cheek, mimiking oral sex when I happened to look at her.
It was a warm, sunny Saturday afternoon when we stepped out of the play and while Kelly was tired and wanted to go home, Cara and I convinced her to have a round of beer and a bite at the local Rugby bar.
Kelly begrudgingly grumbled, "Finneeee, let's get this over with..."
Although Rugby isn't particularly popular in America, there are smaller regional club teams that play one another. In our town, the Rugby players had their own bar, which was doubled as a sort of punk/dive bar with cheap drinks and fried food. The bartenders were "punk hot" girls (black hair, lots of tats and piercings, black clothes) and the bathrooms came complete with endless graffitti, cartoon dicks, and... hidden glory holes with slider panels. It would be a lie to say that women felt "safe" and comfortable in the bathroom there. Locks were busted, there was rarely a roll of TP, and toilets were often "out-of-order" and dirty.
When we arrived, we smoked a weed pen outside before stepping in and ordering a big pitcher of some local whatever light beer, and headed out to a very small, open air rear patio, sandwiched between two brick buildings and a fence. The three of us were totally alone and the rest of the bar up front was a typical weekend sports crowd.
After downing about 2 pitchers between the three of us, Cara got up to say that she had to take a piss and powder her nose. She was looking loose and tipsy, and slightly slurring her words.
"I'll go with you," Kelly told her, also slurring and meandering around in the wedge heel shoes. "I heard those bathrooms are prettyyyyyy seedy."
Both of the girls disappeared to the restroom. Some time went by as I finished the pitcher off and ordered another round.