"Yeah, you're real sensitive down there now, aren't you bitch? That young pussy has been resting on that sharp little rail quite a while now, hasn't it? Maybe you want to come down off of the horse for a bit, and you and I can show the detective here how good you are at FUCKING. How does that sound?"
The beautiful brunette began nodding her head up and down frantically. "YSSS. PWEEESSS. PWEESSS FKKK MEEE!" Despite the gag in her mouth, it was clear that she was wanting to cooperate, anything to get a reprieve from the brutal horse. Fay watched with a sinking feeling as Shorter Psycho undid the shackles around the girl's wrists, re-attaching her wrists so that they were shackled in front of her. Then he untied her ankles and gently lifted her off the horse. When he set the 19-year-old girl on her feet, she collapsed almost immediately, the blood not yet having a chance to rush back and give her any feeling in her legs or feet.
"Now where were we?" Shorter Psycho said brightly, sadistically, as he had the girl crawl toward Fay and lay faceup between her legs.
"Let me see that pussy, bitch. Open those legs wide." Kacie obediently opened her legs, her swollen cunt completely bare to her rapist as he knelt down. He fingered her clit now, and her head snapped back with a loud groan.
"Oh yeah, bitch, you REAL sore down there. I'll try to give you a gentle fuck," he said with a hidden smirk. Now he covered her body with his, positioned his cock, and then thrust forward as his cock-head nudged aside her delicate lips. The girl tensed up and groaned again as that shaft slowly thrust into her, filling her, and then the rhythm began. With the girl's head almost in Fay's lap, she had a close-up view of the depraved act as Shorter Psycho proceeded to fuck his teenage captive while at the same time looking at her eye-to-eye, his face less than a foot away.
"You like the view, detective cunt? It's going to get a lot more intimate in just a short while, I promise. My brother has a lot of things he wants to DO to you, bitch. You've been hunting us, and you know what? The one fantasy me and him share completely, and I mean 100 percent, is the fantasy of capturing a haughty cop or detective cunt and breaking her. Yeah, we got LOTS to look forward to with you, detective slut."
He was still fucking Kacie, who now just lay on the floor moaning softly, her shackled hands pressed to his muscled chest. Fay looked with disgust as the man's hips swung forward again, his cock slowly filling the helpless girl beneath him, her little moans punctuating each languid fuck.
"Mmmmm, yeah, this pussy feels nice. We didn't feel the need to keep the boyfriend alive, but Kacie here is a real keeper. Can't get rid of pussy this good, at least not yet."
Fay idly wondered whether the man was lying. She had no doubt that he was brutal enough to commit murder, he already had, but somehow he also struck her as the type to boast about things he hadn't done.
"Not real talkative, are you?"
She just stared at him coldly, not willing to waste her breath. Fay had already decided that she would kill him if at all possible. He deserved to die.
Shorter Psycho slowly pulled the entire length of his dark cock from Kacie's cunt, then slowly sank it back in to the hilt, relishing the snug fit with a satisfied grunt. Then his eyes bored into Fay's, and she knew that whatever he was going to do next, she wouldn't like it.
"Let's make this more interesting, detective slut. I want to kiss you while I fuck Kacie. He leaned forward and she promptly turned her head away. She thought about biting him, but it would have been pointless. All that would have accomplished was enraging a man nearly twice her weight who had complete control over her -- not a recipe for a survival.
"You're being difficult, bitch. That's not smart."
"Go to hell," she growled. Okay, so maybe Fay's 'don't piss off your captor' mentality was easier to follow in theory than practice.
"You know, your boyfriend Mason -- he's down here too. My brother's with him now. If I tell him how difficult you're being with me, I'm pretty sure he's going to bring a world of hurt down on your guy. Is that what you want?" He let the threat hang like a guillotine about to slice downward, and Fay felt a spike of worry even as she felt hope. If they'd brought Mason here, too, then that increased the chances of escaping. The more captives these two monsters were keeping here, the better the chance of one of them slipping up and making just one crucial mistake.
"No. Don't hurt him." She said the words more like a command than a plea. These sickos got off on the fear of their captives. Fay refused to give him the satisfaction.
"You want me to be nice to Mason, you gotta be nice to me, detective cunt. Now let's do some kissing." He paused. "And if you bite me, bitch...I promise you, you AND your boyfriend will learn to regret it."
Understanding exactly where the boundaries lay, Fay steeled herself for what would come next. First rule of survival; don't lose control, stay alert, wait for an opportunity. She let her detective's brain coolly detach her from the situation, waiting for her chance. Still wearing his mask, Shorter Psycho rolled up the bottom part so that just his mouth was uncovered. Fay wasn't sure why he even bothered still wearing the mask since she had already seen his face, but maybe it was part of his brutal persona, maybe he got off on a sense of power from wearing it. Now, as Shorter Psycho leaned forward, his lips pressed to hers, and she let him. She let him start kissing her. His tongue thrust into her mouth, exploring, cajoling her to respond in kind. Concerned that he would be angry if she was too passive or listless, Fay responded back. Her mouth worked in tandem with his, and her tongue dove into his mouth, tasting and exploring with every bit as much zeal.
Even as Shorter Psycho kept fucking Kacie and kissing Fay, he now reached one free hand forward...
Fay was all too aware of her pussy, bare and helplessly exposed with her legs chained so wide apart. She sucked in a sharp breath as his finger gently pressed to her bare sex. His finger immediately found Fay's clit, rubbing with tantalizing strokes. Meanwhile he maintained his other arm extended beneath him for leverage so that he could keep fucking. Fay gritted her teeth, all too aware of her body's natural response...her cunt's natural response to the plying finger battering her little joy nub. She wouldn't give in. She wanted with all her being to squeeze her legs shut, to keep him out, but of course she couldn't. She could only sit there, wrists chained behind her back, kissing him, wanting to glare daggers at him while he fondled her pussy.
Finally he pulled away from their kiss.
"You don't like this, bitch? You know what, I think you're being ungrateful. You want me to be violent, eh? Like I am in the videos we left you like fun little bread crumbs. I better see some response from you, detective cunt, or you're not going to like what comes next. You hear me?" Again, his threat hung in the air like a weapon, and Fay didn't want to test out to see whether or not the sick bastard was bluffing. She slowly began to move her hips forward in time to his strokes. Her pussy bucked into his caressing fingers. The sexy blonde detective gave him a hard stare as she helped him rape her. Given the situation, her body's responses took a long, long time to build. Yet gradually, as he kept stroking and caressing her cunt, she closed her eyes and forced herself to stop resisting. This wasn't the same as wanting it. That still hadn't changed. But she was willing to just blot out all other thoughts temporarily and surrender to the sensations that her brutal captor was intent on giving her. She didn't do it for him. She did it for her own sanity, and because frankly, Fay didn't want to think about poor Mason and what might be happening to him.
So within about twenty minutes, Shorter Psycho's fingers had progressed to rubbing more and more furiously along Fay's clit, and the gathering wetness in Fay's cunt had now coated his fingers too. She was nudging her cunt forward, meeting his strokes. When he began to plunge two of those fingers between her cunt lips, she impaled herself on those fingers even harder, fucking him and looking at him every bit as coldly. Yet he could see the flicker of desire in her eyes, knew he was getting through to her even if the trickle of juices between her legs didn't already make that fact obvious.
Soon the pinnacle was approaching. Shorter Psycho was slamming hard into the slender brunette. Kacie moaned loudly as his cock shot forward, his testicles slapping against her inner thighs.
"UHHH!!" Kacie squealed as he greatly upped the tempo of her rape.
"UHH!! Sorry, bitch, I'm getting excited. No time to be gentle now. Now here's the deal, detective bitch, I want you to cum on my fingers right as I'm cumming deep inside this brown-haired slut. Think you can handle that, or am I going to have to hurt your boyfriend?"
"I can handle that," she said icily, slightly breathless.
"Say 'Yes Master, I will,'" he growled, his fingers pumping her pussy with even firmer strokes while his thumb caressed her clit.
"Yes Master, I will," Fay ground out, shoving her cunt to meet his swiftly plunging fingers again and again, the heat in her sex blooming like a slowly-building yet unstoppable force. Fay felt her captor's fingers slide along the inner walls of her cunt, creating a new friction of appallingly pleasurable sensations. Loud, wet squelchy sounds of her cunt eagerly sucking up his plunging fingers now echoed in the underground room, making Fay feel a stab of shame. And then he was pounding harder now into the other girl, his body smacking into Kacie's with each emphatic fuck.