After Sheila washed me and massaged lotion into my skin, then dressed me in a short, sleeveless white gown, I sat in bed waiting for what was to happen next. I was too keyed up to read the books I had brought with me. I could practically still feel Sheila's mouth on my pussy where she'd licked me not long before. I was still wet, thinking about her and the Reverend, eager for whatever plans he had for me to commence. My body ached to be touched, to be penetrated.
I heard voices coming from the living room. At first I thought it was the Reverend and Sheila, but I realized I heard multiple male voices speaking in low tones. I stood close to the bedroom door and strained to hear, wondering who else was in the cabin. Within a few moments, Sheila came into the room. I was pacing the floor near the door. She was carrying leather handcuffs attached to short chains. And she had something else - a blindfold. In all of our sessions, I had never been blindfolded and wondered if this meant there was something secret I wasn't supposed to see.
She attached the handcuffs to the top corner joints of the canopy bed frame, then she led me to the foot of the bed. She pulled the white gown over my head, leaving me naked, and then having me face the bed, she stretched each of my arms up and secured my wrists to the leather cuffs attached to the bed frame so that my arms were spread wide apart above my head. I didn't have much room to move. They had never restrained me standing up before and it was a strange sensation. Once I was cuffed, she secured the blindfold over my eyes. It was snug so that it would not slip down.
It felt odd to be plunged into darkness, unable to see, while feeling completely exposed and vulnerable. But that feeling turned from odd to terrified when I heard voices and footsteps outside the door. The Reverend was not coming in alone. Who else was going to see me like this?
I heard a group of people come into the bedroom. "This is the case I was telling you about," I heard the Reverend say.
"Miss Ingram, I'm afraid I've been unsuccessful in reforming you. You are just as wicked as the day I found you in bed with my wife. I've brought in some colleagues to help me. These are godly men from other congregations who want to help deliver you from you evil ways. You don't need to know their names. If someone addresses you, you just call them Sir. Do you understand?"
"Yes, Reverend," I responded, my voice wavering. I hadn't agreed to this, but I didn't see how to get out of this situation now. I pulled against my cuffs thinking I might be able to get loose, but they were secured tightly around my wrists.
"Don't struggle, Miss Ingram. You won't get free." Then addressing Sheila, he said, "Sheila, a demonstration please."
I heard Sheila moving nearby and then I felt the sting of leather on my skin. She was whipping me with the cat o' nine tails. I felt the leather biting at my back, then my ass and thighs. She struck me over and over. And despite my discomfort about having others watch, I felt my body responding as always. In fact, the thought of other men watching her whip me was turning me on. I really am depraved, I started to think.
"Doesn't that hurt her?" I heard a voice ask.
"It does, but she likes it. She's getting aroused as I speak," the Reverend responded. "See for yourself."
Sheila stopped the assault and I sensed someone behind me. Then I felt strange fingers reach under me and rub my slit. I felt them slide smoothly against me and knew I was wet to his touch.
"My god, Mike, you're right! She's dripping wet," the man said.
"I'm sure her nipples are hard, too. Nothing we've tried has dampened her enthusiasm. She practically begs to be punished. She has a sex drive like an animal. I'm not sure she can be tamed."
I felt my face flush at his words. I had a healthy sex drive. There was nothing wrong with me.
"Sheila and I have been thinking there may one way we can suppress her animalistic desires. Motherhood."
What was he talking about? Motherhood?
The Reverend continued. "We think insemination is the only thing that will subdue her. And as some of you know, I'm not able to father a child. That's why I've brought you all here today. Sheila has been tracking Miss Ingram's cycles and this is her most fertile time of the month. We think insemination by another man of the cloth is the best option."
My mind was racing. What was going on? Did Sheila really betray me this way? Had they been planning this since the Reverend had me stop taking birth control?